Trying to pick the single best tournament in golf is a bit like trying to pick your favorite child - each one holds a special place in the hearts of fans for entirely different reasons. There is no single correct answer, but there are definitely top contenders. This article dives into the handful of events that have a legitimate claim to the title and breaks down what makes each one so iconic, helping you decide which tournament truly stands out as the greatest spectacle in the game.
The Unquestionable Big Four: Golf's Major Championships
Any conversation about the "best" golf tournament has to start with the four majors. These are the championships that define a golfer's career, the ones that are etched into history. Winning a regular PGA Tour event is a fantastic achievement, but winning a major makes you a legend. They are the benchmark for greatness, and each one offers a unique test and a distinct personality.
- The Masters: Played every April at Augusta National Golf Club, it's the only major held at the same course each year. It’s known for its unparalleled beauty, sacred traditions, and gut-wrenching Sunday drama.
- The PGA Championship: Held in May, this major often features a strong field and travels to various iconic courses across an America. It's known as a pure, fair test of all-around golf skill.
- The U.S. Open: The United States Golf Association (USGA) notoriously sets up courses in June to be the most demanding tests imaginable. Thick rough, lightning-fast greens, and narrow fairways make par an incredible score.
- The Open Championship: The oldest golf tournament in history, played in July on a rotation of windswept, seaside links courses in the UK. It requires creativity, imagination, and a completely different style of golf.
While all four are extraordinary, most arguments for the "best" tournament tend to focus on a few specific events that transcend the game itself. Let's look closer at the main contenders.
Which Tournaments Make the Shortlist?
While the majors get most of the attention, a couple of other events have such powerful identities that they demand to be included in the conversation. They challenge the majors not on the official "major" status, but on pure prestige, drama, and atmosphere.
For the Diehard Fans and Players: The PLAYERS Championship
Often referred to as the "fifth major," The PLAYERS Championship has one massive argument in its favor: the strongest field in golf. While major-championship eligibility can be a bit quirky, The PLAYERS uses the Official World Golf Ranking to gather the best of the best, year in and year out. If you want to see the top 100+ players in the world go head-to-head, this is where it happens.
It's held every March at TPC Sawgrass in Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida - a course designed specifically to test every facet of a player's game without favoring any single style of play. A bomber can't overpower it, and a short-game wizard can't just rely on their putter.
The Ultimate Test of Nerve
What really makes TPC Sawgrass famous, however, are the final three holes. The driveable par-5 16th offers a classic risk-reward eagle opportunity. The short, signature Par-3 17th, with its famous island green, is probably the most terrifying 137-yard shot in golf. Then comes the 18th, a daunting par-4 that hugs water all the way down the left side. Leading the tournament on Sunday and facing this closing stretch is one of the most intense psychological challenges a golfer can face. There's nowhere to hide, and dreams are made - or completely shattered - in that final 30-minute walk.
For Unrivaled Passion and Drama: The Ryder Cup
If you're judging the "best" tournament by raw emotion, unadulterated passion, and sheer entertainment value, the Ryder Cup wins in a landslide. Held every two years, this event pits a team of the top 12 American golfers against the top 12 European golfers. What makes it special? It’s not about money or ranking points, it's about playing for your flag, your teammates, and your continent.
The stroke-play precision you see every week is replaced by the head-to-head combat of match play. Every holed putt can create a massive momentum swing. The crowds are unbelievable - more like a soccer match than a golf tournament - with passionate chants, songs, and roars that echo across the course. Players who are normally quiet and stoic transform into emotional leaders, pumping their fists and high-fiving teammates. It’s golf in its most primal, tribal form.
For a Trip Back in Time: The Open Championship
For the golf purist, The Open Championship is often the answer. As the world's oldest golf tournament, it's steeped in over 160 years of history. Winning the Claret Jug connects a player to a timeline that includes legends like Old Tom Morris, Harry Vardon, Bobby Jones, Jack Nicklaus, and Tiger Woods. It represents a victory over not just the field, but over the origins of the game itself.
That origin is links golf. Unlike the manicured, aerial-focused courses in America, The Open venues are defined by the elements.
- The Weather: It might be sunny and calm one minute, then sideways rain and a 40 mph gale the next. Players can experience all four seasons in a single round.
- The Ground Game: Links golf isn't about hitting high, towering shots that stop on a dime. It’s about navigating pot bunkers (steep, deep sand traps), using the hard, rolling fairways to your advantage, and hitting low, controlled "punch" shots that run for yards. It demands a level of creativity and imagination that no other major can.
Watching players adapt to these conditions is a masterclass in strategy and feel. It's less about mechanics and more about artistry. When a player hits a low, running 5-iron from 180 yards that bounces, weaves through mounds, and settles next to the hole, you're seeing a display of skill that many modern pros never get to show off.
For Flawless Beauty and Legendary Moments: The Masters
For millions of fans, the answer is, and always will be, The Masters. There is an aura around this tournament that is simply unmatched. It signifies the true beginning of the golf season, opening its doors every April with vibrant azaleas, towering pines, and a golf course that looks almost too perfect to be real.
Augusta National isn’t just a course, it's a character in the drama. Unlike the U.S. Open which penalizes bad shots, Augusta entices players to hit heroic ones. It dangles birdie and eagle opportunities while knowing that a slight miss can lead to a round-killing double bogey. This is never more apparent than on the back nine on Sunday.
The Ultimate Stage for Golfing Drama
The stretch of holes from 11 to 13, known as Amen Corner, is where tournaments are often won and lost. The par-5 13th and 15th holes are both reachable in two, offering a player the chance to make up ground with a spectacular eagle. But with Rae's Creek protecting the front of both greens, those heroic shots can easily end up in the water.
Combine this incredible design with decades of tradition - the presentation of the Green Jacket, the ceremonial first tee shot from legends of the game, the Champions Dinner - and you have an event that feels more like a sacred ritual than a sporting contest. Moments like Jack Nicklaus’s charge in 1986, Tiger Woods’s dominant win in 1997, and Phil Mickelson’s long-awaited victory in 2004 are not just historic golf moments, they are iconic moments in all of sports.
So, What Is the Best Tournament?
In the end, it boils down to what you value most as a golf fan.
Do you believe the "best" should be determined by the strongest, deepest field from top to bottom on a course designed to be perfectly fair? Then The PLAYERS Championship is your tournament.
Do you crave passion, team drama, and raw, unfiltered emotion where every shot feels like a do-or-die moment? Then nothing on earth compares to The Ryder Cup.
Are you a purist who values history, tradition, and the creative challenge of playing golf as it was originally intended, battling the elements as much as the opponent? You’re likely picking The Open Championship.
Or do you look for the perfect combination of mythic beauty, heart-stopping drama, and legendary moments on a course that consistently separates the contenders from the champions? It’s hard to bet against The Masters.
There is no wrong answer. Each one provides a phenomenal spectacle, and the best part is we don't have to choose - we get to watch and enjoy them all.
Final Thoughts
Deciding on the best golf tournament is a personal choice that depends entirely on what you love about the game - raw passion, historical significance, or the ultimate test of individual skill. Each of the major contenders offers a completely different flavor, but all of them showcase the very best that golf has to offer.
As you're watching the pros navigate the strategic challenges of these incredible tournaments, it can give you a new perspective on your own game. When you see a player facing a dicey lie in the fescue at The Open or choosing a landing spot on an approach shot at Augusta, you're seeing course management at the highest level. If you want to better understand those decisions and learn to think like a pro on your own course, tools like my app, Caddie AI, can give you that same strategic guidance. You can even snap a photo of a tricky lie or situation you're in and get instant advice on the best way to play it, removing the guesswork so you can play with total confidence.