Can a Golf Ball Bounce Out of the Hole?

You’ve hit the perfect putt. It rolls end over end, tracking beautifully toward the center of the cup. For a glorious split second, the ball disappears, you start to raise your putter in triumph... and then, horrifically, it leaps back out onto the green. This isn't just a bad dream, it's a real and deeply frustrating part of golf. This article will explain exactly why golf balls can bounce out of the hole, what the official rules dictate in this situation, and most importantly, what you can do as a player to stop it from happening to you.

Yes, a Golf Ball Can Absolutely Bounce Out of the Hole

First, let’s confirm what you might have experienced firsthand: a golf ball can, and does, pop out of the hole after entering it. It’s not a myth or a tale told to spook amateur golfers. It happens at every level of the game, from your weekend fourball all the way to the PGA Tour. A very visible example was Justin Thomas at the 2019 Genesis Open. He stroked a 35-foot eagle putt that looked perfect, dropped into the hole, hit something inside the cup, and jumped back out by a good foot, forcing him to settle for a birdie.

It’s heartbreaking, but it happens. Understanding the "why" is the first step toward preventing it. The cause usually comes down to a combination of physics, equipment, and course conditions.

The Physics and Factors Behind the Bounce-Out

When a ball refuses to stay in the cup, it's rarely just one single thing to blame. Several factors work together to create that moment of putting agony. As a coach, I see pattern recognition as so important to improving, and this is no different. Once you can spot the causes, you can work on the solutions.

Factor 1: Speed is the Main Offender

If there's one primary reason a ball pops out, it's excessive speed. A golf hole is only 4.25 inches in diameter. When a ball arrives with too much momentum, it doesn't have time to fall gently into the cup. Instead, it hits the back wall, the flagstick, or the plastic liner with enough force to ricochet straight up and out.

Think about a basketball shot. A ball that arcs high and drops softly through the rim almost always goes in, sometimes gently touching the rim on its way through. A line-drive "shot" that slams into the backboard or rim, however, has a much higher chance of bouncing away. It’s the same basic principle with putting. A ball that arrives at what we call "dying speed" - so it just has enough energy to fall over the front lip - will almost always be captured by the hole. A ball that would have rolled five or six feet past the hole had it missed is carrying knockout power, and sometimes it knocks itself out.

Factor 2: The Flagstick and Cup Liner Interaction

Since the USGA and R&,A changed the rules in 2019 to officially allow putting with the flagstick in, the stick's role in bounce-outs has become a major topic of conversation.

• Direct Hit: A fast putt that strikes a rigid flagstick dead in the center can easily bounce straight back out. The energy has nowhere to go but 'backward.'
• Leaning Pin: If the flagstick is leaning towards the golfer, it effectively closes the gap between the front of the cup and the pin, making the entry point much smaller. A putt can hit the pin and get deflected out before it ever gets below the surface. Conversely, a pin leaning away from you can act as a helpful backstop.
• The Cup Liner: The plastic or metal cup that lines the hole is another significant factor. If the liner is set too high - meaning its top edge is not at least an inch below the surface of the green as is regulation - it creates a hard, elevated lip inside the hole. Justin Thomas' infamous putt was a perfect example of his ball hitting a high liner and vaulting out. This is a maintenance issue, but one that players have to deal with.

Factor 3: The Condition of an Ill-prepared Hole Edge

The turf right around the edge of the hole takes a lot of abuse. Over time, a few things can happen:

• Raised Edges: Repeatedly putting the flagstick in and out, plus general foot traffic, can cause the turf and soil around the lip to become compacted and slightly raised. A ball that catches this lip with speed can be launched upwards.
• Old Holes: On busy courses, sometimes hole locations aren't changed daily. An old hole location is more prone to these raised, compacted edges, increasing the chance of a "lip out" that looks more like a hop.

The Official Ruling: When Is Your Ball Actually "Holed?"

So your ball just did the impossible leap. What now? The rules are extremely clear on this point. According to USGA and R&,A Rule 13.2c, for a ball to be considered "holed," two conditions must be met:

1. It must be at rest within the circumference of the hole.
2. All of the ball must be below the level of the putting green surface.

Here’s what that means in a few common scenarios:

• In and Out: If your ball enters the hole and bounces out, it is not holed. You must play the ball from its new resting position. Painful, but simple.
• Leaning Against the Pin: If your ball comes to rest against the flagstick, part of it may be in the hole and part of it above the green's surface. Rule 13.2c(2) helps here. Treat the ball as holed if any part of it is in the hole below the surface. So there is no need to move or remove the flagstick. This used to be different in the old rules, where one had to see if the ball would fall in once the flagstick would have been removed. This is no longer the case. A part of the ball is in - the ball is considered "holed".
• The Dunk and Rest: Imagine you hit a chip that dunks straight in, pops up a little bit from the impact, but then comes to rest inside the cup with the entire ball below the surface. This is holed. As long as its final resting place meets the two criteria, you're good.

The key takeaway from the rules is that the ball's final resting position is all that matters. Its journey there - no matter how dramatic or unfair it seems - is irrelevant to the score.

How to Prevent Your Ball From Bouncing Out of the Hole

Now for the most important part: the action plan. As a coach, I'd want you to focus less on the bad luck and more on what you can control. Here are four practical things you can work on to minimize the chances of a soul-crushing bounce-out.

1. Become a Master of Putting Speed

This is, without a doubt, the most effective preventative measure. If you can learn to deliver the ball to the hole with the right pace, everything else becomes less of an issue. The goal should be to putt with 'die in' or 'pro-side' speed.

Actionable Drill: The 18-Inch Rule.
Go to the practice green and find a flat 15-foot putt. Your goal isn’t to make the putt, but to control the speed. Hit putts with the intention that, if they miss, they will roll no more than 18 inches past the hole. This trains your body and mind to understand the feeling of "delivery speed" rather than "hitting speed." A ball arriving with this pace doesn't have the energy to ricochet out, it's practically guaranteed to be captured by gravity if it catches any piece of the hole.

2. Be Strategic with the Flagstick

Deciding whether to leave the pin in or take it out is a strategic choice, not just a preference. Use it to your advantage.

• When to Leave It In: On long lag putts (30+ feet) or extremely fast, downhill putts where just getting the ball close is the main goal. Here, the flagstick can act as a helpful backstop to prevent the ball from rolling too far away. Don't aim for the pin, but use it as a safety net.
• When to Take It Out: On short to mid-range putts (inside 20 feet) where you feel confident about your line. Taking the pin out gives you the full 4.25 inches of the hole to use. It removes the risk of a freak ricochet off the pin itself. Also, always pull a pin that is leaning noticeably toward you, as it significantly shrinks your target.

3. Observe the Conditions

Controlling the arrival speed of your putts is a great start. It's also essential to check the conditions of the holes on the course. While pacing your first putt, take a quick look. Is the cup liner sitting flush with the turf, or is it raised? Does the edge look frayed, compressed, and bumpy? You can't ask the greenkeeper to recut it for you, but this awareness prepares you. If you know the cup liner is high, you'll know that extra-firm putts are especially risky on that day. Knowledge and adapting to the conditions around you give you the mental edge and let your skills do the rest.

4. Choose Lower-Risk Shots Around the Green

Bounce-outs aren't exclusive to putts. A delicately hit chip or pitch can also hop out. A high, spinning approach shot has to hit the small area, which increases the likelihood of an 'interaction' just by the greater descending angle a dropping ball can have when it's about to go into the hole.

When you have a choice, consider a lower-trajectory shot like a bump-and-run instead of a high-lofted lob that lands near the hole. When a ball tumbles towards the hole with overspin instead of dropping from high up and landing with lots of backspin, it is more likely to fall into the cup rather than checking up hard on the lip and potentially catching it the wrong way.

Final Thoughts

A golf ball bouncing out of the hole is real, it’s governed by simple physics, and it’s one of the most maddening situations in the game. But it’s not entirely random - it's primarily a result of too much speed meeting a small target. By focusing on speed control more so than anything else on the greens, you can dramatically reduce the chances of it happening. Knowing the rules and how to smartly use the flagstick will give you an even better probability of the ball staying down when it drops.

We built Caddie AI to support you right in these moments of uncertainty on the golf course. It is like a caddy available 24/7 in your pocket, advising on what to do next and what information is relevant to best plan for the next shot or hole. For example, if you struggle with getting the speed in your putts on sloping terrains and extremely fast green surfaces correct, you can ask our caddie, and our AI caddie provides you simple ideas to help with the pace as you're reading the green. Stuck on what shot to hit to the green when the hole is cut precariously close to an edge? Our AI caddie helps you pick the higher-percentage play. The app functions as your full-time, expert coach, bringing certainty to your decisions so you can play with more confidence and turn those near-misses into made putts.