Can Golf Shoes Be Resoled?

You’ve had that favorite pair of golf shoes for years. They’re perfectly molded to your feet, carrying memories of countless A-grade shots and maybe a few that ended up in the woods. But now, the soles are worn thin, and the spikes are more like smooth nubs. This forces you to ask the question buzzing in every frugal golfer's mind: Can golf shoes be resoled? This article breaks down exactly which types of golf shoes can receive this treatment, how to tell if yours make the cut, and whether the process is actually worth your time and money.

The Quick Answer on Resoling Golf Shoes

So, can you resole your golf shoes? The short answer is: it depends entirely on a shoe's construction. Some high-quality, traditional golf shoes are built specifically to be resoled multiple times. However, the vast majority of modern, athletic-style golf shoes are not. Trying to resole a shoe that wasn't designed for it is often impossible or, at the very least, a recipe for disaster. The key difference comes down to one thing: how the sole was attached to the upper part of the shoe in the first place.

Cemented vs. Welted: The Two Worlds of Shoe Construction

To understand if your shoes are a candidate for resoling, you first need to understand the two primary methods shoe manufacturers use. This single difference is the dividing line between a shoe you repair and a shoe you replace.

Cemented Construction: The Modern Mainstay

Think about your comfortable spikeless shoes or that pair that feels more like a running shoe than a golf shoe. Those are almost certainly made with a cemented construction. In this process, the shoe's upper (the part your foot goes into) is attached directly to the sole with a powerful, industrial-grade adhesive. The sole is essentially glued on.

This method is efficient, cost-effective, and excellent for creating lightweight, flexible, and comfortable shoes right out of the box. It’s why nearly all athletic footwear, from trainers to most modern golf shoes made by brands like adidas, Nike, Skechers, and many FootJoy models, uses this technique.

The bad news? That powerful bond makes replacement next to impossible. Tearing off a cemented sole will likely destroy the midsole and damage the bottom of the leather or fabric upper, making it structurally unsound to attach a new one. It's a one-and-done design.

Goodyear Welted Construction: The Classic and Resoleable Choice

Now, let's turn to the classics. High-end, traditional leather golf shoes are often built using a Goodyear welt construction. This is a much more labor-intensive and old-school method of shoemaking, reserved for premium footwear. It's the gold standard for durability and repairability.

Here’s how it works:

• A leather strip, called the "welt," is stitched firmly around the bottom edge of the shoe's upper.
• This welt is then stitched to the outsole.

You can see there are two separate lines of stitching. The critical part is that the main outsole is stitched to the welt, not directly to the upper itself. This design brillaintly creates a buffer. A skilled cobbler can cut the stitches holding the outsole, remove it cleanly without damaging the integrity of the upper, and then attach a brand-new sole to the very same welt. This process can be repeated a few times, dramatically extending the life of the shoe. Brands famous for this style include FootJoy's "Classics" line, Johnston & Murphy, and other high-end dress shoe makers that also produce golf shoes.

How to Tell If Your Golf Shoes Can Be Resoled

Alright, time for a little detective work. Put your golf shoes on a table and inspect them closely. Here’s a simple checklist to determine their construction method:

• Look for the Outer Stitching: The most obvious giveaway of a welted shoe is a visible row of heavy-duty stitching that runs along the very edge of the sole, where it meets the upper. This is the stitch connecting the welt to the outsole. If you see this, you’re likely in luck.
• Examine the Sole Edge: On a cemented shoe, the edge where the sole and upper meet is typically smooth and seamless, often looking molded. You won’t see any external stitching threads there.
• Consider the Style and Material: Does your shoe look like a classic leather dress shoe adapted for golf? Or does it look like something you could wear to the gym? Traditional, heavy, all-leather models are your best bet for being welted. Lightweight, mesh, synthetic, or sneaker-style shoes are almost guaranteed to be cemented.
• Check the Price Tag (Past and Present): Goodyear welting is an expensive process. If your shoes cost upwards of $250-$300, there's a higher probability they were built to last and to be repaired. If they were in the sub-$150 range, they are very likely cemented.

If you're still unsure, typing the exact brand and model of your shoe into a search engine followed by "Goodyear welt" will often give you the confirmation you need.

The Resoling Process: Leave It to the Pros

If you've determined your shoes are indeed welted, your next step is not toward a DIY kit. This is a job for a professional cobbler. Proper resoling requires specialized tools, heavy-duty stitching machines, and years of skill. Attempting it yourself will almost certainly ruin a beautiful pair of shoes.

Look for a local, reputable shoe repair shop. Give them a call and ask specifically if they have experience with Goodyear welted shoes and golf shoe resoling. Some cobblers specialize in this work and even offer mail-in services if you can't find a capable one nearby.

A full resole typically involves:

1. Careful removal of the old, worn outsole.
2. Cleaning and preparation of the midsole and welt.
3. Stitching on a brand new, high-quality sole.
4. Finishing the edges and polishing the uppers for a new-shoe feel.
5. Installing a fresh set of new spikes into the new sole.

Expect the cost to range anywhere from $75 to $150 or more, depending on the cobbler and the materials used. The process could take a few weeks, so plan to use a backup pair in the meantime.

Is It Actually Worth It? A Cost-Benefit Analysis

Just because you can resole your shoes doesn’t always mean you should. Before you hand them over to a cobbler, honestly assess your shoes.

When Resoling is a Great Idea:

This is a solid move if:

• The Uppers Are in Great Condition: The leather is still supple, free of major cracks, and has maintained its shape. The sole is the only part that’s failed.
• They Are Perfectly Broken In: You love the fit. Resoling preserves that custom-molded comfort that took years to achieve.
• They Were Expensive Originally: Spending $120 to refurbish a $400 pair of shoes is fantastic value.
• You Value Sustainability: Repairing is almost always a better choice for the environment than replacing.

When You Should Just Buy a New Pair:

It’s time to move on if:

• The Uppers Are Shot: If the leather is cracked beyond repair, the inner lining is torn to shreds, or the waterproofing has completely failed, a new sole is just lipstick on a pig.
• Resoling Costs Too Much: If a new pair of comparable shoes is on sale for $160 and the resole costs $140, the value just isn’t there.
• They Are Cemented Shoes: As we've established, these aren’t good candidates and any attempt at repair likely won't last.

The Simpler Alternative: Replacing Your Spikes

Let's make an important distinction. Often, golfers with replaceable spike shoes think they need a "resole" when what they really need is simply fresh spikes. If the sole itself is intact but your cleats are worn down, you don't need a cobbler - you just need a spike wrench and a new set of spikes.

This is a simple, 10-minute task you can easily do at home. Make sure you buy spikes with the correct screw thread for your shoes (e.g., Fast Twist 3.0, PINS), clean out the receptacles, and use a wrench to twist the old ones out and lock the new ones in place. This can make a huge difference in your stability and costs less than $20.

Final Thoughts

So, a premium pair of classic, Goodyear-welted golf shoes can absolutely be resoled, offering a fantastic way to extend the life of your investment. For the majority of athletic-style, cemented shoes that most of us wear today, however, once the sole or traction wears out, it's time to retire them and find a new favorite pair.

Figuring out whether to repair or replace your gear is one of the many small decisions that make golf such a thoughtful game. We built Caddie AI with that same spirit in mind - to give you expert advice for all the other decisions you face out on the course. Whether you're unsure about club selection on a windy par-3 or need a smart strategy for a tricky dogleg, we put a 24/7 golf coach in your pocket to help you play with more confidence and make smarter choices with every swing.