Can You Change a Golf Ball Mid-Hole?

It’s one of the most common rules questions in golf: you’ve just hit a terrible shot, maybe your ball is now sitting at the bottom of a penalty area, and you wonder, Can I switch to a fresh ball, or do I have to play this scuffed-up one? The short answer is yes, you can often change your ball mid-hole, but only in very specific situations. This guide unpacks the rules in plain English, explaining exactly when you're allowed to swap out your golf ball and when you must stick with the one you started with.

The General Rule: One Ball Per Hole

The foundation for this topic is found in Rule 6.3a of the Rules of Golf. The basic idea is that you must "hole out" with the same ball you played from the teeing area. If you tee off with a Srixon #3, the goal is to see that same Srixon #3 fall into the cup at the end of the hole. This prevents players from, for example, using a firm "distance" ball for their tee shot and then switching to a soft "spinning" ball for their approach shot into the green. The game intends for you to manage a single ball through all the challenges a hole presents.

However, the rulebook is filled with exceptions. While the principle is "one ball per hole," you are allowed to substitute a ball anytime a Rule permits it. Let’s look at exactly what those situations are.

When You Are ALWAYS Allowed to Change Your Golf Ball

Think of these as the green lights for grabbing a new ball. If you find yourself in any of the following scenarios, you can legally substitute your ball without any penalty. These are the most common situations where changing a ball is part of the normal procedure.

1. When Taking Relief (Penalty or Free)

This is the most frequent and broadest category where a ball change is permitted. Anytime you take relief under any Rule, you are allowed to substitute a new ball. It doesn't matter if the relief is free or if you're taking a penalty.

This covers a wide range of common on-course situations:

• Penalty Areas (Red or Yellow Stakes): Your ball goes into the water or a penalty area. When you decide to take your drop (either back-on-the-line, lateral relief for red stakes, etc.), you can use a brand new ball. You do not have to retrieve and play the original ball.
• Unplayable Ball: You hit your ball into a thick bush or a horrible spot where you can't make a swing. You declare it unplayable under Rule 19. When you take your drop, you can use a new ball.
• Abnormal Course Conditions (Free Relief): This is a big one. Abnormal Course Conditions include immovable obstructions (like cart paths, sprinkler heads, drainage grates), ground under repair, and temporary water. If your ball is on a cart path, for instance, you are entitled to free relief. When you find your nearest point of complete relief and drop, you are free to substitute a new ball.
• Embedded Ball (Plugged Lie): If your ball is embedded in its own pitch mark in the "general area" (anywhere except the teeing area, penalty areas, bunkers, and the green), you get free relief. You can mark, lift, and clean your ball, and if you choose, you can substitute a new ball before dropping.

The takeaway is simple: If you are lifting your ball to take a drop for any reason, think of it as an opportunity to put a fresh ball into play.

2. When Your Ball Is Lost or Out of Bounds

This one is fairly intuitive. If your ball is lost, you can't find it within the three-minute search time. If it’s out of bounds, it's no longer in play. In both of these cases, you are proceeding under the stroke-and-distance penalty. The ball you put into play next - whether you hit another shot from the previous spot or played a provisional - is by its very nature a substituted ball.

3. When Your Ball Is Severely Damaged

This rule gets misinterpreted all the time. You are allowed to substitute a ball if it becomes "cut, cracked, or otherwise out of shape" while you are playing the hole. Keyword: severely. A simple paint scuff or a surface scratch from hitting the cart path does not count.

The procedure for this, governed by Rule 4.2c, is very strict. You can't just pick up your ball because you think it might be damaged. Here is the correct process:

How to Check for a Damaged Ball:

1. You must have a reasonable belief your ball has been cut or cracked on the last stroke.
2. Before lifting, you must announce to another player (or your marker in a competition) your intention to lift the ball to check for damage.
3. You must mark the position of your ball before lifting it.
4. You can lift and examine the ball, but you are not allowed to clean it (unless its condition prevents you from determining if it's damaged).

If you lift your ball without following this procedure, you get a one-stroke penalty. If the ball is truly damaged (split, cracked), you can substitute a new ball and place it on the original spot. If it’s just scuffed, you must replace the original ball on its spot. Be warned: with modern two- and three-piece golf balls, a truly cracked ball is extremely rare.

Clearing Up a Major Myth: The "One Ball" Rule

Many golfers play their entire lives believing they must use the same exact brand and model of ball for an entire round. For example, if you start with a Titleist Pro V1, you can only use other Pro V1s until the round is over. This is almost certainly not true for your daily game.

This is known as the "One Ball Condition," or more formally, Model Local Rule G-4. The key term here is "Local Rule." It is NOT part of the standard Rules of Golf. It is a specific condition that can be put in place by a tournament committee, and it's typically only used for high-level professional and elite amateur competitions.

For your weekend round with friends, club tournaments, or league play, this rule is almost never in effect unless the committee has explicitly announced it. This means that when you are allowed to substitute a ball (e.g., taking relief from a penalty area), you are free to swap that Callaway for a TaylorMade, or your Pro V1 for a Bridgestone. Feel free to use whatever conforming ball you want whenever a substitution is allowed.

The Grey Area: Playing Between Holes

A small but important clarification: you are always allowed to change your golf ball between two holes. Once you have holed out on, say, the 4th green, the a new hole begins once you make a stroke on the 5th tee. You can swap your ball for a fresh one before you tee off on the 5th without any restrictions whatsoever. Even if the "One Ball" aodel aocal bule were in effect, you could still swap for a fresh ball of the same make and model.

What’s the Penalty For an Improper Substitution?

So, what happens if you break the rule? Let’s say your ball is fine and sitting in the middle of the fairway, but you pick it up and swap it for a different ball just because you felt like it. This action falls under "Playing a Wrong Ball" as defined in Rule 6.3b.

• In Stroke Play: You get the general penalty, which is two strokes. You must then continue playing with the substituted ball. You don't go back and fix your mistake.
• In Match Play: The penalty is much steeper. You incur the general penalty, which is loss of hole.

This is why understanding when you can and can't make a substitution is so important. A simple mistake can easily add two strokes to your score or cost you the hole in a match.

_Final Thoughts

To put it simply, you must play the same ball from tee to green on a given hole, with a few important exceptions. You can legally substitute a ball anytime you are taking relief (either with a penalty or for free), when your original ball is lost or out of bounds, or if it is confirmed to be cut or cracked. And remember, the idea that you have to play the same brand and model for the whole round is a myth for well over 99% of golfers.

These rules can feel like a lot to remember, especially when you're under pressure on the course. You shouldn't have to guess or interrupt your focus by flipping through a rulebook on the fairway. At its best, golf knowledge should empower you to play with clarity and confidence. Clear answers to your on-course questions should be immediate, which is the whole point of our Caddie AI. You can ask anything from situational rulings to club selection or strategy, and get a simple, jargon-free answer in seconds. It's meant to serve as an instant golf expert right in your pocket, taking the guesswork out so you can focus on your next shot.