A 6-6-6 tournament, also famously known as Devils & Angels or a Chapman, mixes up the day's competition by changing formats every six holes. It’s one of the best ways to keep a group of golfers engaged, but its unique structure means you can't just slap a standard handicap on and call it a day. This guide will walk you through exactly how to handicap a 6-6-6 golf tournament to make it a fair and fun event for everyone, from die-hard competitors to casual weekend players.
What Exactly is a 6-6-6 Golf Tournament?
Before we can handicap it, let's make sure we're on the same page. A 6-6-6 is three tournaments packed into one 18-hole round. Normally played with two-person teams, the format changes every six holes. While the specific formats can be swapped around, a classic 6-6-6 consists of:
- Holes 1-6: Scramble. Both players on a team hit a tee shot. They pick the best shot and both play their second shot from that spot. They repeat this process until the ball is holed. It's a forgiving format that often leads to low scores.
- Holes 7-12: Best Ball (or Fourball). Each player plays their own ball from tee to green. At the end of the hole, the team records the lower of the two scores as their team score.
- Holes 13-18: Alternate Shot (or Foursomes). Teammates alternate hitting the same golf ball. Player A tees off, Player B hits the second shot, Player A hits the third, and so on until the ball is in the hole. This is the most demanding format and can test the strength of any partnership.
The beauty of this format is how it shifts the dynamic of the team. A high-handicap player might be a huge asset in the scramble section, where their best shots can save the team, but a potential liability in alternate shot, where every single shot counts.
Why Regular Handicapping Presents a Problem
Your World Handicap System (WHS) handicap is brilliant for individual stroke play. It's a reflection of your demonstrated ability or potential score. But when you start mixing in team formats, its direct application gets a little messy.
Think about it: in a Best Ball format, you have two chances to make a good score on a hole. In a Scramble, you get to choose the best of two shots every single time. And in Alternate Shot, you're only hitting half the shots. A player’s individual handicap doesn’t neatly transfer to these situations.
Just combining two players’ handicaps (e.g., a 10 and a 20 make a 30 handicap team) isn’t truly fair. That system gives a huge advantage to the higher handicappers in the scramble and best ball, while punishing them in alternate shot. The goal is to find a system that accounts for the unique challenges of each six-hole segment.
How to Choose Your Handicapping Method
There are a few ways to approach handicapping a 6-6-6 tournament, ranging from super simple to officially sanctioned. Which one you choose depends on your group and how seriously you're taking the competition.
Method 1: The 'Keep it Simple' Approach for a Casual Round
If your 6-6-6 is just for bragging rights among friends, you might not need complex calculations. This is all about fun and moving at a good pace.
Just for Fun - No Handicaps
If all players in the group have similar skill levels (for example, everyone is between a 10 and 15 handicap), the easiest way to play is straight up, with no strokes given. You're simply playing gross scores for each format. The lowest score wins. This works well for a casual bet but can fall apart if there are big skill gaps in the field.
Simple Team Handicap
For a slightly fairer approach that doesn't require a spreadsheet, you can use a basic team handicap. Add both players’ Course Handicaps together and divide by two. This gives you a single team handicap for the entire round. (Note: A player’s Course Handicap is their Handicap Index adjusted for the difficulty of the specific course and tees being played.)
Example: Player A has a 10-course handicap and Player B has a 24.
(10 + 24) / 2 = 17 Team Handicap
The team gets 17 strokes for the 18-hole round. You'd mark these on the scorecard on the 17 toughest holes (handicap holes 1 through 17). While this is simple, it doesn’t quite solve the fairness problem, as it values all formats equally.
Method 2: The Proper Tournament Method (Using Handicap Allowances)
For a club event or a serious group game, you'll want to use the handicap allowances recommended by governing bodies like the USGA. This method treats each six-hole stretch as its own mini-tournament, with a handicap calculated specifically for that format. This is the most equitable way to run a 6-6-6.
In this system, you’re not competing for an overall 18-hole score. Instead, you're trying to win each six-hole segment. You can award points for first, second, third, etc., in each segment and the team with the most points at the end wins.
Step-by-Step Guide to Proper Handicapping
Let's walk through an example. Imagine we have two teams competing:
- Team 1: Alex (8 Course Handicap) & Ben (22 Course Handicap)
- Team 2: Chris (13 Course Handicap) & Dave (15 Course Handicap)
Here's how we'd calculate their strokes for each 6-hole competition.
Segment 1: The Scramble (Holes 1-6)
The USGA recommends a lower allowance for a scramble because choosing the best shot gives teams a big advantage. For a two-person scramble, the formula is:
35% of Player A's Course Handicap + 15% of Player B's Course Handicap (A is the lower handicap player).
- Team 1 (Alex & Ben): (35% of 8) + (15% of 22) = (0.35 * 8) + (0.15 * 22) = 2.8 + 3.3 = 6.1. We round to the nearest whole number, giving them 6 strokes for 18 holes.
- Team 2 (Chris & Dave): (35% of 13) + (15% of 15) = (0.35 * 13) + (0.15 * 15) = 4.55 + 2.25 = 6.8. Rounded, this is 7 strokes for 18 holes.
Since this segment is only 6 holes long, they get 1/3 of their 18-hole allowance.
- Team 1 gets 6 / 3 = 2 strokes for the scramble.
- Team 2 gets 7 / 3 = 2.33, rounded to 2 strokes for the scramble.
You apply these strokes on the two hardest-rated holes within the scramble section (e.g., if holes 1-6 have handicap ratings of 5, 11, 3, 17, 9, 13, you’d apply the strokes on the holes rated 3 and 5).
Segment 2: The Best Ball (Holes 7-12)
For Best Ball (or Fourball), players get a higher percentage of their handicap since they are basically playing their own ball. The standard allowance is:
85% of each player's Course Handicap.
In match play style, the lowest handicap player (Alex at 8) would play off scratch, and the others would get 85% of the difference. But for a stroke play competition format like this, it's easier to give each player 85% of their total handicap.
- Team 1 (Alex & Ben):
- Alex: 85% of 8 = 6.8, rounded to 7 strokes for 18 holes.
- Ben: 85% of 22 = 18.7, rounded to 19 strokes for 18 holes.
- Team 2 (Chris & Dave):
- Chris: 85% of 13 = 11.05, rounded to 11 strokes.
- Dave: 85% of 15 = 12.75, rounded to 13 strokes.
Again, let's find the allowance for the 6-hole segment:
- Alex gets 7 / 3 ≈ 2 strokes on holes 7-12.
- Ben gets 19 / 3 ≈ 6 strokes on holes 7-12.
- Chris gets 11 / 3 ≈ 4 strokes on holes 7-12.
- Dave gets 13 / 3 ≈ 4 strokes on holes 7-12.
You mark這些筆劃 on the team's scorecard based on individual players. On each hole, the strokes apply to the player who gets them, and the team takes the lowest net score.
Segment 3: The Alternate Shot (Holes 13-18)
Alternate shot is tough, and the handicap reflects a simple combination of the partners' skills. The allowance is:
50% of the team's combined Course Handicaps.
- Team 1 (Alex & ben): 50% of (8 + 22) = 50% of 30 = 15 strokes for 18 holes.
- Team 2 (Chris & Dave): 50% of (13 + 15) = 50% of 28 = 14 strokes for 18 holes.
For this six-hole stretch:
- Team 1 gets 15 / 3 = 5 strokes for the alternate shot section.
- Team 2 gets 14 / 3 ≈ 5 strokes for the alternate shot section.
Tips for Running a Smooth Tournament
- Provide Clear Rules Sheets: Give every team a printout that explains the format for each set of holes and clearly states their six-hole handicap allowance for each format.
- Use a Points System: The cleanest way to determine a winner is to award points for each segment (e.g., 5 points for 1st, 3 for 2nd, 1 for 3rd). Tally the points at the end. This avoids complicated math of combining different net scores.
- Set Up Your Scorecards: Before play, have players draw lines on their scorecard after holes 6 and 12 to create three distinct sections. This visual separation makes scoring much easier to manage.
- Make a Pre-Round Announcement: Always walk through the format, the handicaps, and the scoring system before anyone tees off. A few minutes of clarification can save an hour of confusion later.
Final Thoughts
Setting up a 6-6-6 tournament might take a little extra prep work, but using the correct format-specific handicaps makes it one of the most balanced and exciting events you can play. By treating it as three separate competitions, you ensure every team has a fair shot to win, no matter the mix of player abilities.
Knowing the right strategy for each format is part of the fun, and this is where understanding your own game is so valuable. At Caddie AI, we are focused on making that part easier. Should you hit driver or 3-wood on a tight par-4 in the alternate shot section? Just ask, and you’ll get an instant, smart strategy to help you make confident decisions under pressure, removing the guesswork so you can just focus on playing your best.