Playing a round at Kinloch Golf Club is a special experience, but this masterpiece by Lester George and Vinny Giles demands a plan. Prepare for firm, fast conditions, massive undulating greens, and strategic questions on every single shot. This guide will give you a strategic blueprint for navigating Kinloch, covering overall course management and a detailed breakdown of its most defining holes.
The Guiding Principles of Playing Kinloch
Before you stick a tee in the ground, it helps to understand the club's philosophy. Kinloch was designed to be a thinker's course, a true examination of golf. It’s a walking-only facility, which encourages you to connect with the landscape and the subtleties of the design. The fairways are generally generous, but that width is deceptive. The real challenge at Kinloch isn’t hitting the ball, it's placing it. The proper angles into these huge, contoured greens are everything. Hitting the wrong side of the fairway can completely cut you off from a pin, turning a simple-looking approach into an impossible task. This isn't a course you can overpower with brute force. It's a game of chess, and every move (and shot) requires forethought.
General On-Course Strategy: A Framework for Success
Success at Kinloch boils down to discipline and smart decision-making. If you want to post a good score, you must commit to a sound strategy before you start pin-seeking. Here’s the approach I recommend for every player.
Off the Tee: Position Over Power
You’ll notice the fairways seem wide, and that’s intentional. The architects want you to feel comfortable pulling the driver, but they’ve created specific zones you need to be in. Before every tee shot, look at where the pin is located on the green. A back-right pin almost always means the ideal tee ball is on the left side of the fairway, and vice versa. Being on the wrong side can leave you with no direct line to the flag, a view blocked by bunkers, or an approach over the most treacherous part of the green. Forget just hitting the fairway, focus on hitting the correct portion of the fairway. A 260-yard drive in the right spot is infinitely better than a 300-yard bomb in the wrong spot.
Approach Shots: Finding the Right Neighborhood
This is the heart of Kinloch’s defense. The greens are enormous, averaging over 8,000 square feet, and they are filled with tiers, ridges, and swales. Your target is rarely the entire green, it’s a small, specific 'neighborhood' around the hole. Missing the green at Kinloch isn’t always a penalty, but being 'short-sided' - missing on the same side as a tucked pin - is disaster. This leaves you with an awkward chip or pitch over a bunker to a downhill sliver of green. Bogey, or worse, is almost guaranteed.
The smartest play is often to aim for the center of the green, regardless of pin location, or to miss on the side that gives you the most green to work with for your next shot. Play the percentages, get comfortable with the idea of a 25-foot putt for birdie, and you will avoid the big numbers that derail a round here.
Greens: Pace, Pace, and More Pace
The greens at Kinloch are pure, and they are fast. Often running at 12 or more on the Stimpmeter, they require a delicate touch. A three-putt is almost a "Welcome to Kinloch" moment for first-timers, but it doesn't have to be. Your primary goal is to master lag putting. Spend a good 15-20 minutes on the practice green before your round, focusing not on making putts but on getting your 30- and 40-footers to stop within tap-in range. Inside 10 feet, the breaks may look subtle, but they are there. Trust your reads, make a confident stroke, and accept that on these surfaces, two putts is an excellent result.
Bunkering: Avoid at All Costs
The bunkers at Kinloch are deep, strategically placed, and punishing. They are true hazards. Trying to be a hero from the steep-faced sand traps will likely lead to another shot from the very same bunker. The game plan here is simple: get it out. Don’t get greedy. If you have to take your medicine and just splash it out sideways onto the fairway or the green, do it. A bogey from the proper side of the green feels a lot better than a double-bogey that started with an ambitious bunker shot.
A Strategic Walk-Through of Kinloch's Key Holes
Every hole at Kinloch presents a unique test, but some stand out as defining moments in your round. Here’s how to approach a few of them.
Hole 4 (Par 4, 'Bunker Hill')
This dogleg right is the first severe test of your driving accuracy. A massive bunker and waste area guards the entire right side of the hole. The only play is a tee shot aimed down the left-center of the fairway. Anything pushed right leaves you either in the sand or completely blocked out by trees for your approach to the challenging, elevated green. A smart tee shot here sets up a mid-to-short iron, a poor one instantly puts you in scramble mode.
Hole 7 (Par 3, 'Old's Pond')
At around 170 yards, this is not an overly long par 3, but it’s all carry over water to a shallow and wide green. Club selection is vital, as the prevailing wind can swirl here. The front-right bunker is a magnet for any ball that comes up short or weak. The safe play is always one extra club, aimed toward the middle-or-left side of the green. A putt from 30 feet long and left is a much better fate than a tee shot sleeping with the fishes.
Hole 9 (Par 5, 'Returning Home')
A brilliant risk-reward par 5 to close the front nine. The fairway is split by a creek, and water protects the front of the green.
- The Safe Play: Lay up with your second shot to your favorite wedge distance, leaving yourself a simple third into the receptive green. This easily takes the water out of play.
- The Aggressive Play: A strong drive allows you to go for the green in two. It’s a heroic carry over water and sand to a well-guarded green. This shot demands full commitment. Anything less than a perfect strike will find a hazard.
Hole 14 (Par 4, 'Long')
A brute of a par 4 playing uphill. This hole demands two of your best shots. Your drive must find the fairway to have any chance. The approach shot, often with a long iron or hybrid, is played to a green that slopes hard from back to front. Anything above the hole leaves a treacherous downhill putt. Your goal should be to leave the ball below the pin, even if it means being on the front fringe. An uphill chip or putt is infinitely more manageable.
Hole 16 (Par 5, 'Vinny's Gamble')
This is Kinloch’s signature hole, for good reason. From the tee, you are presented with a choice: play to the wide, inviting fairway on the left, or take on the adventurous "island" fairway on the right, which drastically shortens the hole but brings water into play on both sides.
- From the Left Fairway: This turns the hole into a traditional three-shotter. From here, your second shot should be a layup that leaves you with a full swing for your third, avoiding the need for an awkward half-swing over the water that protects the green.
- From the 'Island' Fairway: If you find the island, you're rewarded with a chance to reach the green in two with a mid-to-long iron. It’s an intimidating, glorious shot over water a back-to-front sloping green. It’s a definitive moment in the round where courage can be handsomely rewarded.
Hole 18 (Par 4, 'The Final Uprising')
The closing hole offers no respite. A tough, uphill dogleg right with the lake defending the entire right side. The tee shot must find the fairway - bailing out too far left will leave an impossibly long approach. The second shot is played blind and uphill to a massive, three-tiered green. Knowing the pin position is absolutely essential. Taking one or even two extra clubs for the uphill approach is common. Finish with two confident swings, and you’ll have earned your post-round beverage.
Final Thoughts
To score well at Kinloch, you must embrace its central challenge: it's a test of strategy, not just execution. Focusing on hitting specific zones - the proper side of the fairway, the correct portion of the green - and playing away from trouble will save you far more strokes than trying to force a heroic shot. Manage your game with patience and respect for the design, and you'll find it to be one of the most rewarding rounds of golf you'll ever play.
Having a game plan is one thing, but making confident decisions on the spot is another, especially on a mentally demanding course. This is exactly where our tools can help. With Caddie AI, you can get real-time course strategy in your pocket. Imagine facing a tough approach, you can get an instant opinion on club selection and the smart target line. If you find yourself in a tricky spot with a questionable lie, you can even snap a photo of your situation and get clear advice on the best way to play it, helping you turn potential bogies into pars.