Match play is a completely different beast than the stroke-play golf you see most weekends on TV. It's a head-to-head battle, a classic duel where your total score for the round means absolutely nothing. This guide will walk you through the fundamentals, strategies, and mindset you need to not just play match play, but to win it.
What is Match Play? The Core Concept
Forget about grinding to save a double bogey to keep your score down. In match play, you’re playing a series of 18 individual, one-hole contests against a single opponent. Your goal is simply to win more holes than they do. If you make a 4 and your opponent makes a 5 on the first hole, you win the hole and go “1 up.” If you both make a 5, the hole is “halved” (tied), and the score remains the same heading to the next tee. The player with the higher score for the hole simply loses that one hole - whether by one stroke or five doesn't matter. A triple bogey loses the hole just as cleanly as a bogey does.
This single rule changes everything. It means a blow-up hole where you make an 8 or a 9 is no more damaging than losing with a squeaked-out bogey. You lose the hole, shake it off, and start completely fresh on the next tee. This format invites aggression, strategic risk-taking, and a fascinating layer of psychological gamesmanship.
Understanding Match Play Scoring and Terminology
To walk the walk, you’ve got to be able to talk the talk. The scoring and language of match play are unique, but simple once you get the hang of them.
- Up/Down: This indicates who is leading the match. If you’ve won two more holes than your opponent, you are "2 up." If they’ve won two more than you, you’re "2 down."
- All Square (A/S): This means the match is tied.
- To Play: This refers to how many holes remain. For instance, "2 up with 4 to play" means you’re leading by two holes with just four holes left in the round.
- Dormie: A player is "dormie" when they are leading the match by the same number of holes that remain. For example, if you are 3 up with 3 holes to play, you are dormie. Your opponent cannot win - they can only tie the match by winning the remaining holes, which would force a playoff. If you are dormie, you only need to halve one of the remaining holes to win.
- Halved: A tied hole. No one wins or loses the hole, and the match score doesn't change.
- Concession: You can “concede” a putt, a hole, or the entire match to your opponent at any time. If your opponent has a one-foot putt, you can say "that's good" to save time and be courteous. This is a strategic element we’ll get into later.
The score is announced on the tee box before either player hits. For example, if you won the first hole and tied the second, the honor is yours, and the starter might announce, "Player A is 1 up."
The Golden Rule: Play the Opponent, Not Just the Course
In stroke play, you wage a personal war against the course architect and your own limitations. In match play, your focus shifts. You’re playing one person. Their shots directly influence your strategy. This is the single biggest mental adjustment you need to make.
Let's use an example. You’re on the tee of a tricky par 4. It’s a narrow fairway with out-of-bounds left and a line of thick trees right. In stroke play, you might conservatively hit an iron to make sure you find the short grass and avoid a big number.
But in match play, your decision depends entirely on your opponent.
- Scenario 1: Your opponent tees off first and hits a perfect drive down the middle. The pressure is on. Your safe iron off the tee might not be enough. If they’re in a great position, you likely need to be, too. This is a time to be a bit more aggressive and hit a driver or 3-wood to keep pace.
- Scenario 2: Your opponent tees off first and hooks their ball out-of-bounds. Suddenly, everything changes. They will be hitting their third shot from the tee. You are in complete control of the hole. Your goal is now simple: don't make a disaster of your own. That conservative iron now looks like the smartest play in the world. Put the ball in the fairway, hit it on or near the green, two-putt for a bogey, and you will almost certainly win the hole. There is absolutely no reason to take on risk when your opponent has already handed you a massive advantage.
This principle applies to every shot in the match. Is your opponent on the green in two on a par 5? You probably have to go for it. Did they just chunk their approach shot into a bunker? You can play safely to the middle of the green and all but guarantee a win.
Strategic Decision-Making: Hole by Hole
Good match play strategy is a fluid dance between aggression and conservatism. The score of the match and the situation on the current hole dictate which style you should adopt.
When to Be Aggressive
Calculated aggression can claw you back into a match or slam the door on an opponent.
- When You're Down: If you're 3 down with just a few holes left, playing for par might not be enough. You need to win holes, which means making birdies. This is the time to go for that par 5 in two, to aim at the pin tucked behind a bunker, or to hit a driver on a hole where you’d normally layup. You have little to lose and everything to gain.
- When Your Opponent Is in Trouble: Sometimes, the most aggressive play is to step on the gas when your opponent stumbles. If they hit a poor drive into the trees but you have a good lie in the fairway, you shouldn’t just play for par, play to make a birdie. Firing at the pin and making the putt not only wins you the hole but delivers a psychological blow.
When to Play Conservatively
"Boring golf" is a powerful weapon in match play. Hitting fairway after fairway, green after green, puts continuous pressure on your opponent.
- When You Have the Lead: If you are 2 up late in the match, your goal shifts from winning holes to not losing them. Don’t take unnecessary risks. Aim for the middle of fairways and greens. Force your opponent to come up with heroic shots to beat your solid-but-unspectacular pars. The pressure of having to constantly make birdies can lead to costly mistakes.
- After Your Opponent's Mistiake: As mentioned before, if your opponent hits a ball in the water, into a tough a bunker, or OB, your job is simple: avoid catastrophe. Play for the "easy" bogey if you must. Let them make the big number and hand you the hole.
The Art of the Concession
Conceding putts is more than just good sportsmanship, it’s a strategic tool. Early in a match, it’s common to concede very short "tap-in" putts to build goodwill and maintain a friendly pace of play.
However, the strategy changes as the match wears on. That two-foot putt on the 16th green, with the match on the line, feels a lot different than it did on the 2nd green. Never concede a putt you aren’t absolutely certain your opponent will make when the pressure is on. Making your opponent lag a long putt and then forcing them to "clean up" a nervy two or three-footer is a classic match-play tactic. It keeps the pressure on them until the ball is in the cup.
Similarly, know when to pick up your own ball. If your opponent is on the green putting for birdie and you’re 20 yards short lying 3 in the thick rough, don’t waste energy trying to hole an impossible shot. Concede the hole, tip your cap, and move on to the next. It keeps you mentally fresh.
The Mental Game
Match play is as much a test of mental fortitude as it is of technical skill. Your demeanor can be a weapon.
- Stay Steady: Never let them see you sweat. Whether you just piped a drive or skulled a chip, try to maintain the same calm, steady routine. A consistent temperament can be unnerving to an emotional player.
- Apply Pressure Quietly: You don’t need to talk trash. The most effective pressure is the relentless presence of your golf ball in the fairway or on the green. Making your opponent feel like they have to hole every chip or make every putt to keep up is the ultimate goal.
- Never, Ever Give Up on a Hole: So you duffed your drive and are still 200 yards out while your opponent is on the green. Don’t mentally check out. Make a determined effort to save par. If you pull off an unlikely up-and-down while they three-putt, the momentum shift is enormous. You’ve let them know that no hole is a guaranteed win, which adds another layer of pressure for them on every subsequent hole.
Final Thoughts
Mastering match play is about embracing its unique rhythm and strategic demands. It’s a dynamic format that rewards smart, adaptable thinking over raw, repetitive scoring ability. By playing your opponent, not just the course, and understanding when to attack versus when to defend, you can become a formidable match-play competitor.
The beauty of match play is how every situation presents a puzzle. When you're standing over a tough shot with the hole on the line, the decision-making can feel intense. Our goal in creating Caddie AI was to give you an expert second opinion right in your pocket for those specific moments. Whether you need a simple strategy for playing a new hole or want to figure out the best way to handle a tricky greenside lie that could decide the match, we provide quick, clear advice to help you make smarter, more confident choices when it counts most.