Taming Spyglass Hill requires more than just good golf shots, it demands a smart, adaptable game plan. This is a course of two wildly different personalities, and knowing how to navigate both its sandy, seaside dunes and its tight, towering pines is the difference between a memorable round and a long list of lost balls. This guide will walk you through a clear, hole-by-hole strategy for playing one of the world's truly great and challenging golf courses.
Mastering the Two Faces of Spyglass Hill
Spyglass Hill is famously described as having two nines squeezed into one round, and a better description doesn't exist. The first five holes are pure, raw, links-style golf played along the Pacific coastline. You'll hear the barking of sea lions as you battle the wind across sand dunes and firm fairways. It's exhilarating and brutally exposes any weakness in your long game. Your round starts out feeling like a trip to the shores of Ireland.
Then, you cross the road after the 5th green, and everything changes. The ocean sounds vanish, replaced by a profound, cathedral-like quiet. You're suddenly transported into a forest of Monterey Pines and Cypress trees, playing holes that feel like they were borrowed from Augusta National or Pine Valley. The game shifts from managing wind and ground bounces to demanding pinpoint accuracy through narrow corridors to well-protected, undulating greens. To score well here, you have to be two different golfers in one day.
A Hole-by-Hole Strategy for Spyglass Hill
Success at Spyglass is about brains over brawn. It’s about knowing when to attack, when to play safely, and where the non-negotiable misses are. Let's walk through the course.
The Opening Salvo: Holes 1-5
This stretch is your introduction to the Pacific. Wind is the primary defense. Your main goal here is survival. Leave these holes around even par, and you’re way ahead of the game.
- Hole 1 (Treasure Island) - Par 5: A downhill par 5 is usually a birdie opportunity, but this opener is fraught with danger. The correct play is a 3-wood or hybrid down the left side of the fairway. Anything right will kick hard into the trees. For your second shot, lay up to a comfortable wedge distance. The green is long, narrow, and protected by deep bunkers. Don't be a hero, start with an easy par.
- Hole 2 (Billy Bones) - Par 4: The tee shot on this uphill par 4 is partially blind. The aiming point is the gap between the dunes. The fairway is wider than it looks, so trust your line and make a confident swing. The approach is to an elevated green. Take an extra club, as anything short will roll back down the fairway leaving a very tricky third shot.
- Hole 3 (The Black Spot) - Par 3: One of golf's most picturesque short holes. It's rarely more than a short iron, but the green is minuscule and surrounded by sand and ice plant. Pay close attention to the wind, which can swirl viciously. Hitting the green is a huge accomplishment. Aim for the middle, take your par, and run. Missing left is better than right.
- Hole 4 (Blind Pew) - Par 4: Many players consider this the hardest hole on the course, and for good reason. It’s a long, impossibly narrow par 4 that snakes between sand dunes. For most amateur golfers, the prudent play is to treat this as a three-shot hole. Hit a hybrid off the tee, another mid-iron to a good position, and a wedge onto the green. Trying to hit driver often leads to double bogey or worse. Don't let your ego write a big number on the card.
- Hole 5 (Captain Flint) - Par 3: Your last hole along the ocean is another challenging par 3. The green is two-tiered and often requires one or two more clubs than the yardage suggests, especially when the pin is on the back shelf. The slope in front of the green is severe. The main objective is to land on the correct tier.
Entering the Forest: Holes 6-9
As you cross the 17-Mile Drive, the course changes character. The fairways narrow, the trees tower, and precision a premium. This is target golf.
- Hole 6 (Long John Silver) - Par 4: A beautiful and difficult uphill par 4. Your drive must favor the right side of the fairway to have a clear look at the severely sloped green. The approach shot plays a full club longer than the yardage. The green slopes dramatically from back to front. Any shot that lands above the hole will leave you a lightning-fast, defensive putt.
- Hole 7 (Lafitte's Cache) - Par 5: A sharp dogleg left that offers a birdie chance if you place your tee shot properly. A draw around the corner sets you up perfectly. For your second shot, lay up just short of the series of bunkers that cross the fairway, leaving a simple third. The green is deceptive, so take your time reading the putt.
- Hole 8 (Signal Hill) - Par 4: This is Robert Trent Jones Sr. design at its finest and toughest. A long par 4 that doglegs sharply to the right. A big fade is the ideal shot shape off the tee, but anything flared right is dead. To play it safe, aim for the 150-yard marker, which leaves a longer but safer approach to a large, elevated green guarded by deep front bunkers.
- Hole 9 (The Crows Nest) - Par 4: A medium-length par 4 that doglegs left back towards the clubhouse. The fairway bunker on the right is absolutely in play. Keeping your drive down the left side is the best strategy. The green is relatively flat, offering a good chance to end the front nine with a confidence-boosting par.
The Back Nine Gauntlet: Holes 10-18
The back nine continues its journey through the Del Monte Forest. You’ll be faced with ponds, elevation changes, and some of the most demanding greens you'll ever putt on.
- Hole 10 (Captain Kidd) - Par 4: A straightforward downhill par 4 to begin the back nine. A well-placed drive will leave you a short iron into a simple green. This is a real chance for a birdie, so take advantage of it.
- Hole 11 (Admiral Benbow) - Par 5: This hole is all about the second shot. After a good drive on this slight dogleg right, you’ll face a decision. The green is reachable, but a large pond protects the entire right side. The entire fairway and green slope towards that water. The smart play is to lay up down the left side, taking the water completely out of play.
- Hole 12 (Skeleton Island) - Par 3: This is RTJ Sr.'s version of Augusta's 12th hole. It’s a stunning downhill par 3 to a shallow green fronted by water. Club selection is everything. Check the wind and commit to your shot. Walking away with a par here feels like a victory.
- Hole 13 (Captain Smollett) - Par 4: A tight dogleg left that requires a right-to-left shot shape off the tee to hit the fairway. The trees on the left will block out any approach if you get too aggressive. A safe iron or hybrid aimed at the right-center of the fairway is often the best course of action.
- Hole 14 (Black Dog) - Par 5: This is a true three-shot par 5 that meanders through the trees. A long and straight drive is a great start. Your second shot then must navigate fairway bunkers to set up a challenging third into a monstrous, three-tiered green. Landing on the correct portion of the green is vital for having any chance at a two-putt.
- Hole 15 (Noon) - Par 3: A classic RTJ Sr. short par 3. It's played downhill to a green that is angled from front-right to back-left and protected by sand. It isn't a long shot, but it punishes any miss. Find the surface and secure your par.
- Hole 16 (Jim Hawkins) - Par 4: Get ready for one of the toughest approaches in golf. This beast of a par 4 doglegs right and plays significantly uphill. After a solid drive, you'll be left with a long iron or hybrid into a small, elevated green that you can't see. Take at least two extra clubs and aim for the dead center of the putting surface. Four is a spectacular score here.
- Hole 17 (The Spyglass) - Par 4: Not a long par 4, but the fairway is squeezed by trees on both sides. The prime landing area is small. After finding the fairway, you are left with a short iron into another green that slopes from back to front. Under the hole is always best on this approach.
- Hole 18 (Buccaneer) - Par 4: A wonderful finishing hole that curves gently to the right. A good drive down the right-center of the fairway will give you the best angle into a green protected by deep bunkers short and left. Finish strong by executing two solid shots and you might just get a final par to cap off an unforgettable round.
Final Thoughts
Playing Spyglass Hill is about respectful course management and strategic execution. You must embrace its dual nature - first battling the elements on the coast, then threading needles through the forest - to post a score you can be proud of.
For a course with this much strategic depth and so many potential pitfalls, sometimes an expert second opinion is just what you need to play with confidence. Our app, Caddie AI, acts precisely as that trusted partner. When you're standing on the 4th tee wondering whether to lay up, or looking at a downhill lie on your approach into the 16th, I can give you shot-by-shot strategic advice to help you avoid the big numbers and make smarter decisions on every hole.