Finding the right putter can shave more strokes off your handicap than any other club in the bag, but the endless options can feel overwhelming. This guide clears up the confusion by breaking down what you really need to know. We’ll cover the main types of putters, how to match one to your personal putting stroke, and showcase some of the best models available today so you can walk onto the green with confidence.
Understanding Your Stroke: Arcing vs. Straight
Before you even look at a putter, you need to understand your own putting motion. Most players have a natural arc to their stroke, while some have a motion that is more straight back and straight through. There's no right or wrong style, but your putter should be designed to complement your natural tendency.
Here’s a simple way to get a baseline read on your stroke:
- Find a straight putt on the practice green.
- Place two alignment sticks (or two other golf clubs) on the ground, parallel to your putt line and just wider than your putter head. This creates a "track."
- Take a few practice strokes without a ball, focusing on a smooth rhythm. Pay close attention to how the putter head moves in relation to the track you created.
- Strong Arc: Does the toe of the putter "open" on the way back (pointing away from you) and then "close" through impact (pointing toward you)? If the club head moves significantly inside the track on the backswing and then inside again on the through-swing, you have a strong arcing stroke.
- Slight Arc: If you see a little bit of arc but it’s not hugely pronounced, you have a slight arc. This is the most common stroke type among golfers.
- Straight Back, Straight Through: Does the putter face stay perfectly "square" to the target line throughout the stroke, moving straight up and down the track? This is a straight-back-and-through stroke.
Knowing this is the first step because it directly influences the type of putter balance you need, a concept we call "toe hang."
What is Toe Hang and Why Does It Matter?
Toe hang describes how the toe of the putter hangs when you balance the shaft on your finger. This balance characteristic is engineered to work with, not against, your natural stroke arc. It allows the putter face to open and close smoothly throughout the motion.
Here's how to check it and what it means:
- Balance the putter’s shaft horizontally across your open palm.
- Observe how the face of the putter settles.
- Full Toe Hang: The toe of the putter points straight down toward the ground. These putters have the most face rotation and are designed for golfers with a strong arc.
- Slight Toe Hang (Mid Hang): The toe points downward at a roughly 45-degree angle. This is the most versatile type of balance, designed to fit golfers with a slight arc.
- Face-Balanced: The face of the putter points straight up toward the sky. These putters resist rotation and are built for golfers with a straight-back-and-through stroke.
Using a putter that fights your natural stroke path is a recipe for inconsistency. A face-balanced putter will feel like you’re dragging it if you have a strong arc, while a full toe-hang putter will feel like you can't control the face if you have a straight stroke. Matching your stroke type to the right toe hang is one of the quickest ways to improve your feel and consistency on the greens.
Blade vs. Mallet: Choosing Your Putter Head Style
The next major decision is choosing between the two primary putter head shapes: blades and mallets. While personal preference plays a part, each design offers distinct performance benefits.
Blade Putters
Blades are the classic, traditional putter design. They are generally smaller, sleeker, and offer a heightened sense of feel. This direct feedback allows skilled players to have more control over distance and face angle. However, because they are smaller and have less mass distributed to the perimeter, they are less forgiving on off-center hits. If you miss the sweet spot on a blade, you’ll see a more noticeable drop in distance and likely a deviation in direction.
- Best For: Golfers with consistent strokes who prioritize feel and workability. They are often, but not always, preferred by players with an arcing stroke.
- Examples: Odyssey Tri-Hot 5k One, Scotty Cameron Newport 2, PING Anser 2D.
Mallet Putters
Mallets are larger-headed putters that come in a wide variety of shapes and sizes. Their primary benefit is forgiveness. The larger size allows manufacturers to push weight to the perimeter of the head, increasing the Moment of Inertia (MOI). High MOI simply means the putter head resists twisting when you strike the ball off-center. This means a putt hit on the toe or heel will lose less speed and roll more on-line than the same miss with a blade. Mallets also often feature more prominent alignment aids, which can be very helpful for golfers who struggle to line up correctly.
- Best For: Golfers who want maximum forgiveness and help with a consistent setup. They are often a great fit for players with a straight-back-and-through stroke.
- Examples: TaylorMade Spider Tour V, Odyssey Eleven, Scotty Cameron Phantom X 5.5, Bettinardi INOVAI 6.0
Other Features That Make a Difference
Beyond the head shape and balance, a few other elements contribute to a putter's performance and feel.
1. Face Design: Milled vs. Insert
The face of the putter is a major source of feel. There are two main types:
- Milled Faces: A milled face is carved directly from the metal head block itself. This typically produces a firmer, more crisp feel and a slightly louder "click" at impact. Milled faces often include intricate groove patterns designed to get the ball rolling end-over-end more quickly. They are preferred by players who want direct, unfiltered feedback.
- Face Inserts: An insert is a separate piece of material placed into the face of the putter. These are often made of softer urethane or polymers (like Odyssey's famous White Hot insert) to provide a softer feel at impact. Softer inserts can be wonderful for players who putt on very fast greens, as they can help keep the ball from racing past the hole.
2. Hosel Design
The hosel is the piece that connects the shaft to the putter head. You don't need to be an engineer, but its shape is what largely determines the putter's toe hang.
- Plumber's Neck: The classic, J-shaped hosel found on many blade putters. It typically creates moderate toe hang, fitting a slight arc.
- Slant Neck: A shorter, angled neck that often creates more toe hang, making it suitable for stronger arcs.
-
This is a shaft that bends twice before entering the putter head directly. This design is almost always used to create a face-balanced profile for mallets.
3. Grip Size
Putter grips have evolved. The traditional skinny grip is still popular, but larger grips can help quiet down overly active hands and wrists. A larger grip encourages a "palms facing" style and can promote a smoother, more body-driven stroke. If you find yourself constantly breaking your wrists during the putt, trying a midsize or jumbo grip could be a small change that yields big results.
So, Which Putter is Best for You?
With all this information, you're now equipped to answer this question yourself. The "best" putter on the market is not one specific model - it’s the one that checks the right boxes for your game.
Walk through these steps:
- Figure out your stroke type (arc, slight arc, or straight).
- Find a putter with the corresponding toe hang (full hang, slight hang, or face-balanced).
- Decide between a blade for feel or a mallet for forgiveness and alignment.
- Consider your preference for feel (firm milled vs. soft insert).
- Finally, ensure the length is right for your posture and the grip feels comfortable in your hands.
Don't just buy the putter that your favorite tour pro uses. Take the time to self-evaluate and test a few options with these principles in mind. Finding the right tool will give you lasting confidence where it matters most: on the green.
Final Thoughts
Choosing the best putter comes down to matching the technology to your tendencies. By understanding your stroke, the importance of toe hang, and the real differences between head types, you can stop guessing and find a putter that truly works with you, making it easier to start the ball on the right line, every time.
Of course, picking the right putter is a massive piece of the puzzle, but the other half is reading the break and picking the right starting line on the course. We designed Caddie AI to help take the guesswork out of green reading and on-course strategy. For tricky putts, tell it the break and distance, and it can give you a precise target to aim for instead of just guessing - giving you the clarity you need to make a confident stroke.