Heard Best Ball shouted across the fairway and wondered exactly what it meant? You're not alone. Best Ball is one of the most popular and enjoyable team formats in golf, but its rules can be a bit confusing if you’ve never played. This guide will walk you through everything you need to know, from the basic rules and scoring to handicaps and strategy, so you can show up for your next tournament or casual round feeling confident and ready to contribute to the team.
Understanding the Core Concept: What is Best Ball?
At its heart, Best Ball is a team competition. You can have a team of two, three, or four players. The concept is refreshingly simple:
- Every golfer on the team plays their own golf ball from the tee to the hole, just like you would in a normal game of stroke play.
- After everyone has putted out, you look at all the individual scores for your team on that hole.
- The single lowest score among the teammates becomes the official team score for that hole.
Let's use a quick example. Imagine you're on a two-person team playing a long par 4. You hit a great drive but eventually make a bogey (a 5). Your partner, on the other hand, hits a perfect approach shot and drains the putt for a par (a 4). For that hole, your team's score is a 4. Your 5 gets erased from the scorecard as if it never happened. Pretty cool, right? You repeat this process on all 18 holes, and the team with the lowest total score at the end wins.
Two-Person Best Ball vs. Four-Person Best Ball (aka Four-Ball)
You’ll often see different names for Best Ball games, which can add to the confusion. The truth is, the fundamental rules don't change whether you have two, three, or four players on a team. The only difference is the number of players whose scores you get to choose from on each hole.
The most common formats you'll encounter are:
- Two-Person Best Ball: Just you and one partner.
- Four-Person Best Ball: A team of four golfers. In official circles and major competitions like the Ryder Cup, this format is correctly called "Four-Ball." For your average club event or weekend game, people use "Four-Person Best Ball" and "Four-Ball" to mean the same thing.
The Ryder Cup actually features Four-Ball match play, where two-player teams from the USA and Europe compete hole-by-hole, which highlights how popular this format is at the highest levels of the sport.
The Step-by-Step Rules of Playing a Best Ball Hole
To really get a feel for the flow of the game, let's break down how a single hole is played. Following these steps will help you handle any situation on the course.
1. At the Tee Box
Everyone on the team tees off, just like in a standard round. While there isn't a strict rule for the teeing order within your team, smart teams often develop a strategy. For instance, a consistent player might hit first to get a "safe" ball in the fairway. This takes the pressure off the other players, freeing them up to be more aggressive with their drives.
2. Playing Your Own Ball
This is the most important part to remember. After the drives, every golfer walks to their own ball and plays it until it's holed out. You are responsible for your own strokes and your own path to the green. This isn't a scramble where the team selects the best shot and everyone hits from there. You are playing individual stroke play, but as part of a team effort.
3. The Art of Picking Up and Why It’s Great for Golf
One of the best features of Best Ball is that you don't always have to finish the hole. Let's say your partner holes out for a birdie. Meanwhile, you're lying in a bunker after three shots on a par 4 and have no chance of beating their score. In this situation, you can simply pick up your ball. You don't have to finish the hole. There's no penalty.
This is not only legal, it's encouraged! It does two wonderful things:
- It significantly speeds up play. There's no need to watch someone grind out a triple bogey when it won't count.
- It reduces stress and frustration. Having a bad hole? No problem. Pick it up, forget about it, and know you can start fresh on the next tee to help your team.
4. Scoring the Hole Correctly
After everyone on your team has either holed out or picked up, it's time to mark the scorecard. Gather as a team and compare everyone's scores for that hole. Identify the lowest score - that’s your "best ball."
You then write that single score in the team's scoring row. To avoid confusion, many teams will put a small circle around that score on the scorecard. It's also a good habit to write down the initials of the player who posted the score, which makes it easier to track contributions and check scoring accuracy at the end of the round.
Best Ball vs. Scramble: The Critical Difference
If there's one area new players get mixed up, it's distinguishing between a Best Ball and a Scramble. They are both team formats, but how they are played is completely different. Let’s clear this up once and for all.
- In a Best Ball: You play your own ball from tee to cup. At the end of the hole, the team selects the best individual score.
- In a Scramble: Everyone on the team tees off. You then select the best shot, and all players hit their next shot from that location. You repeat this process until the ball is in the hole. You’re playing from the best spot on every stroke.
Think of it this way: In Best Ball, teamwork is about having each other's back If one person has a bad hole, hopefully, someone else has a good one. In a Scramble, teamwork is about collaborating on every single shot. If you remember that Best Ball is about the best score, not the best shot, you’ll never get them mixed up again.
How Handicaps Work in Best Ball Tournaments
Many Best Ball events, especially charity or club tournaments, use handicaps to level the playing field. This is called a "net" competition. If you have a handicap, this is where the format gets even more interesting.
The USGA provides official recommendations for handicap allowances to make it fair. While a tournament committee can set its own rules, these are the most common allowances you’ll see:
- Four-Ball (Four-Person Best Ball): Men receive 90% of their Course Handicap. Women receive 95% of their Course Handicap.
- Two-Person Best Ball: Typically, both men and women receive 85% of their Course Handicap, although it's sometimes 90% for men and 95% for women. Always check the tournament rules sheet!
So, how does this work in practice? Let's say your Course Handicap is 20. In a Four-Ball tournament with a 90% allowance, you would get 18 strokes (20 * 0.90 = 18). These strokes are applied on the 18 most difficult holes, as ranked on the scorecard (Handicap 1-18).
Example:Your team is playing the #1 hardest hole, a par-4. Your partner, a scratch golfer, makes a 4. You have a stroke on this hole. You manage to make a 5. With your handicap stroke, your "net" score is a 4 (5 - 1 = 4). In this case, your score officially ties your partner's scratch 4, and the team takes a 4 for the hole. If your partner had made a 5, your net 4 would be the team score.
Simple Strategies to Win Your Next Best Ball Event
Now that you know the rules, let's talk about playing smart. A good strategy can easily make up for a lack of raw talent.
1. Use the "Safe & Aggressive" Method
This is the classic Best Ball strategy. On each hole, decide who will be the "safe" player and who will be the "aggressive" player. For a four-person team, this might be two of each.
- The Safe Player: Their job is to just get the ball in play. Aim for the center of the fairway and the center of the green. The goal is to make a par and ensure the team has a decent score "in the bank."
- The Aggressive Player: Once a safe shot is on the map, this player is free to take risks. They can try to cut a dogleg, go for a tiny pin tucked behind a bunker, or try to drive a short par-4. If it pays off, you get a birdie. If it fails, the safe player's par is there to back them up.
2. Choose Your Partner Wisely
Building a great Best Ball team is about more than just finding the four lowest handicap players. Look for players whose games complement each other. A long, but sometimes wayward driver pairs perfectly with a teammate who is consistently straight off the tee. A phenomenal putter can give the entire team a confidence boost on the greens. Think about pairing different skill sets together.
3. Communication is Everything
Talk with your teammates throughout the round. Decide on the teeing order. On the green, plot out who should putt first. A common strategy is to have the player who is furthest away putt first. However, if one player has a straightforward 5-footer for par and another has a tricky 30-footer for birdie, let the player with the par putt go first. If they make it, the par is secured, and the other player can be aggressive with their birdie putt without fearing a three-putt.
Final Thoughts
Best Ball is a wonderful format that emphasizes camaraderie and strategy while still allowing every player to enjoy their own individual round of golf. By understanding that you play your own ball, choose the best score, and can pick up on bad holes, you're set up for a much more relaxed and enjoyable day. Pairing that knowledge with simple tactics and clear communication will make you a valued teammate in any event.
As you get more into team formats and developing a smart game plan, having an an extra dose of confidence can make a huge difference. That's we designed our on-demand coaching app, Caddie AI. It's purpose-built for those on-course decisions - like when you're the 'aggressive' player needing a second opinion on trying to carry the water, or you're facing a tough lie and need the smart play. Asking for an instant recommendation can give you the clarity to commit to your shot and truly help your team.