What Do College Golfers Shoot?

The straight-up score a college golfer shoots is probably the most common question junior golfers and their parents have, but it’s loaded with a lot of it depends. The gap between a player on a top-5 Division I powerhouse and a player on a developing Division III team is significant. This article will break down what college golfers really shoot, separating myth from reality and giving you a clear picture of the scores required at different levels of collegiate competition.

Beyond the Score: It’s About the Scoring Average

Before we jump into specific numbers, it’s important to understand how college golf performance is measured. Coaches aren't looking at your single best round of 68 at your home course. They are looking at your tournament scoring average.

This average is typically calculated over dozens of rounds played in competitive events, under pressure, and on courses you've often never seen before. Furthermore, a 74 on an easy, short course is not the same as a 74 at a course like Bethpage Black or another U.S. Open venue. Coaches know this. They evaluate scores in the context of the course's difficulty (its rating and slope) and the strength of the competition.

The bottom line is that consistency is everything. A player who consistently shoots between 73-76 in tournaments is often more valuable to a coach than a player whose scores swing wildly between 69 and 85.

Scoring Averages by NCAA Division

The level of competition and the scores required change as you move through the different divisions of college golf. Let’s look at what you can expect at each level. Keep in mind these are general benchmarks, there are always exceptions.

NCAA Division I: The Path to the Pros

This is the highest level of amateur competition in the world. Rosters at top DI schools are often filled with the best junior players from around the globe. To even get a look from a top-25 program, you need a seriously impressive playing resume.

• Top 50 DI Men’s Programs: The #1 player on these teams often carries a scoring average under par, usually in the 70.0 to 71.5 range. The rest of the starting lineup will typically average between 72 and 74. To be a recruit for these programs, you'll generally need a scoring average of 73 or better in multi-day national junior tournaments.
• Other DI Men’s Programs: For teams outside the top 50, the averages relax slightly, but the competition is still fierce. Expect the best players to be around 72-74, with the team average falling somewhere in the 74 to 77 range.
• Top DI Women’s Programs: The elite women’s players also post phenomenal scores. The top players in the country hover around 71.0 to 72.5. The starting lineup for a top-tier team will generally have averages between 73 and 76.
• Other DI Women’s Programs: For programs further down the rankings, leading players will still shoot in the mid-70s, with team averages often falling between 76 and 80.

To put it simply, to get real consideration, especially for a scholarship at the DI level, being able to consistently post tournament scores in the low 70s is a must.

NCAA Division II: A Hotbed of Talent

Don't sleep on Division II golf. The best DII teams can and do compete with DI programs. Many DII golfers were DI-level players who sought a different school environment, a better scholarship offer, or a chance to be an immediate starter.

• DII Men: The best players on top-ranked DII teams will average between 72 and 74. A lineup player at a competitive DII school will likely need an average in the 74 to 77 range. You’ll find a much wider spectrum here, but a tournament average below 78 is a good place to start for recruitment.
• DII Women: Top DII women’s players often have scoring averages in the 74 to 77 range. To play on a competitive team, maintaining an average under 80 in tournaments is often necessary, with lineups often rounding out in the low 80s.

NCAA Division III: Excellence on and off the Course

Division III student-athletes cannot receive athletic scholarships, so the focus is truly on the scholar-athlete experience. However, the golf at the top DIII programs is incredibly competitive. Top DIII teams rival many DII and even some DI programs.

• DII Men: The top DIII players showcase scoring averages between 73 and 76. For a solid mid-tier DIII program, players who consistently shoot in the high 70s (e.g., 77-79) are valuable assets.
• DII Women: Leaders on top DIII women's teams will post averages in the high 70s. Players on many DIII rosters will have averages in the low-to-mid 80s. A player who consistently breaks 85 in tournament play can find a spot on many DIII teams.

What About NAIA and Junior College?

The National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics (NAIA) and Junior Colleges (JUCO) are also excellent and competitive routes. The scoring averages at these schools range widely. Top NAIA and JUCO programs operate at a DII or low-DI level, with players moving on to four-year NCAA schools after a year or two. Their scoring benchmarks are typically very similar to what you'd find in a strong NCAA DII conference.

Tournament Golf is a Different Animal

One of the hardest things for aspiring players to grasp is why their "casual round" scores don't translate directly to tournaments. A high school golfer might shoot 74 every week with their friends but struggle to break 80 in a two-day event. Here’s why:

1. Course Setup and Conditions: Tournament courses are set up to be a test. Greens are faster, the rough is thicker, and hole locations are tucked in corners. There are no "gallery pins" in the middle of the green waiting for you.

2. Pressure: Every single stroke counts. There are no mulligans, no "that's good" putts, and no improving your lie in the fairway. The mental weight of playing a round that will be officially recorded and seen by coaches adds a few strokes all by itself.

3. Playing it Down: You play the ball where it lies. Did your tee shot roll into a divot in the middle of the fairway? Too bad. Are you half-stymied behind a tree? You have to figure out a recovery shot, not just nudge it over a few feet "for practice". This reality is one of the biggest adjustmnents for new competitive golfers.

"Five Count Four": The Value of Not Having a Bad Day

College golf tournaments most often use a format where five players from a team compete, but only the top four scores from each round count toward the team total. This is an absolutely central concept to understand.

Your job as a college golfer isn't necessarily to shoot 68 every day. Your primary job is to avoid shooting 82.

A team's #1 player may have the ability to go low and post a 70, but what really makes a team great is a solid #4 or #5 player who, on a day when they don’t have their best stuff, can still grind out a 78 instead of an 84. The player who can manage their game and avoid "blow-up holes" is incredibly valuable.

When coaches are recruiting, they aren't just looking for flashy, low scores. They are looking for resilient players who show a high golf IQ, possess a great short game to save pars, and have the mental toughness to turn a potential 80 into a 77. Those are the players who help teams win championships.

Final Thoughts

College golf scores range widely based on division, team ranking, and gender, but the common thread is the ability to perform consistently under tournament pressure. Earning a spot on a college team is less about shooting a once-in-a-lifetime low round and more about proving you can consistently shoot competitive scores and, most importantly, avoid the big numbers on your bad days.

Knowing these target scores is one thing, but figuring out a plan to lower your own average is an entirely different task. That’s precisely why having a smart, objective "second opinion" can be a game-changer. We created our AI coach to provide a personal guide right in your pocket, whether you need a smart strategy for a tricky par 4 or need help figuring out the best shot to play from a photo you snap of a terrible lie. Instead of guessing, we use data-driven insights to give you clear advice, helping you play with more confidence and make the kind of smart decisions under pressure that coaches love to see. Caddie AI is designed to help you simplify the game and sharpen the skills you need to reach that next level.