Dreaming of playing golf for a living? The first question that pops into most minds is, What handicap do I need? While you won't find a single magic number that opens the door to the tour, there is a clear standard of play you must reach. This guide clarifies what that standard is, what a plus-handicap truly means, and the tangible skills you need to build to walk the path of a professional golfer.
The Simple Answer: The "Plus-Handicap" Benchmark
Let's get straight to it. To even consider playing professionally, you need to have a "plus" handicap. This means your handicap index is a number below zero (e.g., +1, +2, +3). Officially, the United States Golf Association (USGA) states that to become a professional, a male golfer must have a handicap of 0.4 or better, but that's just the paper requirement to reclassify your status from amateur to professional.
The real-world, unwritten rule on the path to the pro tours is that you should be at a +2 handicap or better. Most aspiring tour professionals who are competing in top amateur events and trying to qualify for pro tours carry handicaps of +3, +4, +5, and even lower.
What Does a "Plus" Handicap Actually Mean?
A golf handicap is designed to measure a player's potential, not their absolute average score. It's calculated using the best 8 of your last 20 official rounds. But what does "plus" mean? It’s a bit counterintuitive.
- A 10-handicap golfer is expected to shoot approximately 10 strokes over par on a course of average difficulty.
- A scratch (0) handicap golfer is expected to shoot par.
- A +4 handicap golfer is expected to shoot four strokes under par.
Essentially, players with a plus-handicap are so good that they need to give strokes back to par. This is the minimum price of admission to the world of professional golf. It signifies that on your better days, you are consistently breaking par. But as you'll soon see, this number is only the beginning of the story.
Why Your Handicap Is Just a Starting Point
A club handicap and a professional’s performance are two different animals. Tour pros don’t walk around talking about their handicap, they talk about their scoring average under tournament conditions. This is a massively important distinction.
Your official handicap is calculated from scores made in, typically, casual rounds. You’re playing a course you know well, a friendly foursome, and relaxed conditions. Maybe you give yourself a good lie in the fairway or concede a 3-foot putt. There's no real pressure.
Now, think about tournament golf:
- Course Setup: The course is set up to be as difficult as possible. The tees are all the way back, the rough is thick and punishing, and the pin placements are tucked in corners you have to be precise to reach.
- Immense Pressure: Every shot counts. There is prize money on the line, rankings, your career, and spectators watching every move. A simple 4-foot putt can feel like the hardest shot in golf.
- No Second Chances: There are no "breakfast balls" or gimmes. You play the ball as it lies, no matter how bad the bounce.
A local +3 handicap player might be dominant at their home club, but their first professional event under pressure could be a totally different experience. It's the difference between singing well in the shower and performing solo on a live talent show. The environment fundamentally changes the difficulty of the task.
The Real Metric: Professional Scoring Averages
If you want to know how good you need to be, forget the handicap for a moment and look at the scores pros actually shoot. If you plugged their tournament-condition scores from the world's hardest courses into a handicap calculator, the numbers would be staggering, likely in the +6 to +9 range.
PGA TOUR
The best golfers in the world play on the PGA TOUR. In a typical season, the average score for the entire field of players is around 70.5 to 71.0. The players at the very top, those contending for major championships, average under 69.5. To maintain a PGA TOUR card, you need to be able to average close to par or better on brutally hard golf courses day in and day out.
Korn Ferry Tour
The Korn Ferry Tour is the primary path to the PGA TOUR. The dream is nearly a reality for these players, but the competition is ferocious. Their scoring average is only slightly higher than on the main tour, often just a tenth or two of a stroke. The difference between making it and staying on the mini-tours is razor-thin.
Mini-Tours
This is where most aspiring pros grind it out. To win a three-day mini-tour event, you usually have to shoot a score between 15 and 20 under par. That means shooting in the mid-to-low 60s every single day. Players who consistently win on these tours are exceptional and have scoring averages in the 67-69 range. If you can’t consistently go low in these events, the chances of advancing are slim.
The PGA Club Professional
It's also important to distinguish between a "Tour Professional" and a "PGA Professional" (or Club Pro). A Club Pro is an expert in the business of golf - they run the shop, give lessons, and manage the course. While they are fantastic players (almost always scratch or plus-handicap themselves), their focus is different. The standard to be a competitive Club Pro is slightly less demanding than being a Tour Pro, but it's still an elite level of golf.
What a Pro-Level Game Actually Looks Like
Getting to a plus-handicap isn't just about shooting lower scores, it's about a complete skill set that has no weak links. Amateurs bleed strokes in areas a pro has mastered.
1. Elite Ball-Striking
A pro’s ability to control the golf ball is on another level. It’s not about power - it’s about precision and consistency. They hit the ball in the center of the clubface nearly every time, which produces predictable distances and spin. Their “misses” are often still better than an average amateur's best shots. They can shape the ball both ways and control trajectory (low, medium, high) on command.
2. A World-Class Short Game
From 100 yards and in, a pro becomes an artist. This is where they score and where they save rounds. They don’t just hope to get the ball on the green, they expect to get it close. From a greenside bunker or a chip in the rough, their mindset isn’t “Don’t mess this up,” it’s “I can make this.” They master different types of shots - the low spinner, the high soft flop, the bump-and-run - and know exactly which one to use. Getting up-and-down is the norm, not a celebrated success.
3. No Three-Putts
Every pro can roll the ball beautifully. Inside six feet, a putt is almost considered a tap-in. More importantly, their distance control is sublime. On long lag putts of 40, 50, or 60 feet, they consistently leave the ball within a three-foot circle, guaranteeing a simple a tap-in for par. Three-putts are tournament killers, and they are exceptionally rare in a pro's game.
4. Bulletproof Course Management
A pro thinks their way around a golf course like a chess grandmaster. They know which pins to attack and which to avoid. They understand playing to the ‘fat’ part of the green, leaving themselves uphill putts, and taking their medicine when they’re in trouble instead of trying a heroic shot that could lead to a double bogey. This strategic discipline saves them handfuls of strokes over a tournament.
The Path to Turning Pro
So, you see the mountain top. How do you start climbing? It’s a long journey, but it’s built one step at a time.
Step 1: Become a Dominant Amateur
Before you even think of taking money, you must prove you can win without it. Your first goal is to get to a scratch handicap. Once you’re there, strive to get to +2 and beyond. The new goal becomes winning your club championship, then your city amateur championship, then competing meaningfully in state and national amateur events.
Step 2: Excel in Competition
Your true measure is how you score with a card in your hand and something on the line. Regularly playing in tournaments is non-negotiable. This is the only way to build pressure-proofing and find out if your game holds up when it counts.
Step 3: Track Everything, Find Your Weakness
Pros are surgical in their self-analysis. Don't just track your score, track your stats: driving accuracy, greens in regulation, scrambling percentage, and putts per round. Where are you bleeding strokes? Is it poor driving? Inconsistent wedge play? Find the single biggest weakness and attack it with purpose.
Step 4: Build a Team
Golf is an individual sport, but no one makes it alone. You need a swing coach who understands your game, a supportive network, and likely a fitness coach to build the physical strength and endurance needed for the grind.
Step 5: Practice With Purpose
Amateurs hit balls, pros practice. They don’t just mindlessly pound drivers. They play games against themselves on the range, create pressure situations, and work on specific shots they’ll need for upcoming tournaments. Every practice session has a clear goal and simulates the demands of real competition.
Final Thoughts
Becoming a professional golfer is less about a single handicap number and more about developing a complete game that can produce elite, under-par scores consistently under the most difficult conditions. The 'plus' handicap is your entry ticket, but what truly matters is your scoring average when the bright lights are on. It's a game of extraordinary skill, mental fortitude, and flawless execution.
Lowering your score from a 5 to scratch, and from scratch to plus, requires smarter decision-making on every shot. For improving course management and getting instant advice on difficult situations like club selection or shot strategy, our Caddie AI serves as a 24/7 coach in your pocket, helping you think like a pro and eliminate the mistakes that inflate your handicap.