Constantly writing 6 on a par 4 or 5 on a par 3 can make you feel stuck, but a double bogey golfer is a very common and understandable stage in your development. It simply means you have a huge opportunity for improvement. This guide will explain exactly what handicap that translates to and give you a clear, actionable plan to start turning those double bogeys into bogeys, and eventually, pars.
So, What Exactly Is a 'Double Bogey Golfer'?
In golf terms, a "double bogey" means you finished a hole in two strokes more than its par rating. If you’re playing a par-4, a score of 6 is a double bogey. On a par-3, it’s a 5, and on a par-5, it’s a 7.
When someone is labeled a "double bogey golfer," it's a casual way of saying they average a double bogey on every hole they play. It doesn't mean you make a double bogey on all 18 holes, but that your final score averages out to that number. On some holes you might get a bogey or even a rare par, but on others, you might have a triple bogey or worse that brings your average back up.
Let's do some simple math to see what that looks like on the scorecard:
- There are 18 holes in a standard round.
- A double bogey is +2 strokes per hole.
- 18 holes x 2 strokes over par = 36 strokes over par.
On a typical par-72 golf course, adding those 36 strokes gives you a final score of 108 (72 + 36 = 108). So, a true "double bogey golfer" is someone who consistently shoots right around a 108. Many golfers at this level are working hard to break the milestone of 100 for the first time.
Translating a Score of 108 to an Official Handicap Index
This is where things get a bit more nuanced. Your official Handicap Index isn't just your average score. Instead, it's a measure of your potential skill, calculated using the best 8 of your last 20 rounds of golf. This system recognizes that nobody plays their best every single time and aims to reflect what you're capable of on a good day.
A Quick Primer on the Handicap System
Your Handicap Index is calculated using your score along with two numbers that define a course's difficulty for a "scratch" (0 handicap) and "bogey" (around an 18 handicap) golfer:
- Course Rating: Predicts the average score of a scratch golfer. A 71.5 rating means a scratch golfer should shoot about 71.5.
- Slope Rating: Measures the relative difficulty for a bogey golfer compared to a scratch golfer. The average slope is 113. A higher number (e.g., 135) means the course is significantly harder for a higher handicapper.
The system uses these numbers to create a "Score Differential" for each round you post. It then takes the average of your 8 lowest differentials from your last 20 rounds to give you your Handicap Index.
So, What's the Handicap?
Because the handicap system uses only your best scores, a player who averages 108 isn't going to have a handicap that reflects a 108. Their 20 rounds will likely have scores clustered around 108, but their 8 best might be closer to scores like 102, 103, or 104. The handicap formula will then factor in the course and slope rating from the courses where those better scores were shot.
Taking all this into account, a golfer who consistently averages around 108 strokes per round will typically have an official USGA Handicap Index in the range of 30.0 to 36.0. At many courses, this is the upper limit for an official handicap.
Don't be discouraged by this number! A handicap is just a tool to measure progress and to allow for fair games against players of different skill levels. Knowing your starting point is the first step toward getting that number lower.
The Common Culprits Behind Double Bogeys
Players at this handicap level aren't held back by a lack of a perfect, “tour-pro” swing. More often than not, the issues are strategic and mental. Double bogeys are frequently the result of one small mistake snow-balling into a catastrophe. Let's look at the primary sources of these big numbers.
1. The Tee Shot Penalty Cycle
Nothing inflates a score faster than penalty strokes right off the tee. For a 30-handicap golfer, the driver can feel like a weapon of mass destruction. A single shot slices out of bounds, and you're already hitting your *third* shot from the tee box. From there, you're playing catch-up. Another weak shot into the trees to avoid going OB again, a punch-out back to the fairway, and suddenly you’re lying 4 before you even have a clean look at the green. That simple mistake off the tee has almost guaranteed a double bogey or worse.
2. The "Hero Shot" Mentality
This is when ego overrides strategy. Your tee shot lands behind a towering oak tree, 180 yards from the green. The smart play is a simple 50-yard punch-out sideways to the fairway, leaving you a reasonable approach shot. But the "hero" in us sees a tiny gap in the branches and thinks, "I can totally hook a 5-iron around that tree!"
What happens next? The ball clips a branch, drops straight down, and you’re still blocked by the tree. Now you're frustrated and forced to take the sideways punch-out you should have taken in the first place, only you’ve wasted a stroke. This emotional decision-making is a primary factory for blow-up holes.
3. Wasted Strokes Around the Green
Many scores are sabotaged within 40 yards of the hole. It's an issue of multiples:
- You hit a decent drive and approach, but leave yourself 15 yards short of the green.
- Your first chip shot is a pure "chunk" - the club digs into the ground and the ball moves three feet. Stroke 3.
- Now frustrated, you thin the next chip, sending it screaming across the green into the back bunker. Stroke 4.
- It takes you two shots to get out of the bunker. Strokes 5 & 6.
- Finally, you two-putt for an 8.
What started as a great chance to make par or bogey spiraled into a quad-bogey because of poor short-game execution.
4. The Three-Putt Habit
Three-putting is a silent killer of a good round. A double bogey can be formed right on the putting surface. Hitting the green in 3 strokes on a par 4 feels pretty good - you have a putt for par! But if that putt is from 50 feet away, your job isn't to make it. Your job is to get it close.
Players who struggle with double bogeys often blast their long putts 8-10 feet past the hole, leaving a very difficult second putt that they frequently miss. Turning a very makeable two-putt into a three-putt is giving away a stroke for no reason.
Your Action Plan to Move from Double Bogey to Bogey Golf
The path to breaking 100 and lowering your handicap isn't about swing mechanics, it's about making better decisions and eliminating mistakes. Here's a practical, actionable plan to do just that.
Step 1: Put the Driver in Timeout
On any hole with tight fairways, water, or out-of-bounds, leave the driver in the bag. Hitting a hybrid or 5-wood 180 yards down the middle is infinitely better than a 220-yard drive into the woods. The main goal of your tee shot is simple: get the ball in play so you have a clear second shot. That's it. This one change alone can eliminate most of your penalty strokes and immediately lower your scores.
Step 2: Change Your Measure of Success
Stop trying to make par. This sounds counterintuitive, but it works. When you stand over a shot, your new goal is to make bogey. Embracing "bogey is my par" does two things:
- It eliminates the hero shot. Thinking about bogey makes you choose the safe punch-out instead of the risky shot through the trees.
- It removes pressure. When you see bogey as a success, you play more relaxed and confident golf. Funnily enough, when you play for bogey, you often end up giving yourself a chance at par.
Step 3: Develop One Reliable Chip Shot
You don't need a half-dozen different short-game shots with various clubs. You just need one reliable "go-to" shot. Take your 8-iron or 9-iron and practice hitting a simple bump-and-run. Stand a little closer to the ball, put more weight on your front foot, and use a putting-style motion to "bump" the ball onto the green and let it run out toward the hole. Getting the ball anywhere on the putting surface is a win. It builds confidence and stops the cycle of chunked and thinned shots.
Step 4: Master the Art of Lag Putting
When you have a putt longer than 20 feet, forget the hole exists. Instead, your goal is to get the ball to stop inside a three-foot circle around the hole. Practice this by laying a headcover or towel a few feet behind the cup and concentrating on getting your speed right so the ball finishes between the hole and the towel every single time. Making every long putt a simple two-putt is the fastest way to shave 5-6 strokes off your score.
Final Thoughts
Being a "double bogey golfer" means you shoot around a 108 with a handicap in the low-30s. It’s a common stage in golf that comes from compounding small errors, but breaking through is less about perfecting your swing and more about playing smarter with the skills you already have.
As you work on this, sometimes you just need a second opinion on the course, and our goal is to provide that. With an AI caddie and coach like Caddie AI, you have an expert in your pocket to help you avoid those blow-up holes. If you're stuck in the trees, you can take a picture of your lie and get an instant, objective recommendation on the smartest way to play the shot. Standing on a tricky par-5 you've never played, you can get a simple strategy for how to tackle the hole - turning that feeling of uncertainty into a confident plan to finally make that bogey or par.