Almost every golf fan remembers the intense, 38-hole final of the 1996 U.S. Amateur, where a young Tiger Woods first showed the world his incredible grit. But what about the other player in that duel, the man who nearly changed golf history? This article will tell you exactly what happened to Steve Scott, the golfer who went toe-to-toe with Tiger, and explore the powerful lessons his unique journey holds for every one of us who loves this game.
The Match That Forged a Legend (and a Legacy)
To understand Steve Scott’s story, you have to start in August 1996 at Pumpkin Ridge Golf Club in Oregon. Scott, a talented sophomore at the University of Florida, found himself in the final match of the U.S. Amateur against a 20-year-old phenom named Tiger Woods, who was gunning for an unprecedented third straight title. For 35 holes, the match was an epic battle, with Scott holding a 2-up lead with just three holes to play. A victory for Scott would have denied Woods his historic "three-peat" and possibly altered the timeline of his professional debut.
But the most memorable moment of the match, the one that defines Steve Scott's character, happened on the 34th hole (the 16th of the afternoon round). After holing a birdie putt to go 2-up, Tiger had an 18-foot putt to stay in the match. Before he putted, however, Scott noticed something. Tiger’s coin, his ball marker, was directly in the line of his own potential putt. Unprompted, Scott walked over and reminded Tiger to move his mark.
Tiger did so, made the putt, and kept the match alive. Later, Woods would famously go on to win in a dramatic 38-hole finish.
A Lesson in Sportsmanship
Why is this moment so important? In the heat of the biggest match of his life, with a U.S. Amateur title on the line, Scott chose integrity over a potential advantage. He could have remained silent. Had Tiger putted from the wrong spot, it would have been a loss of hole penalty, and the match would have belonged to Steve Scott. But that’s not who he was. As a golf coach, I point to this moment as the ultimate example of what the game is about. Your character, your honesty, and your respect for the rules and your opponent are more important than any single victory.
The Road Taken: Pursuing a Different Path
After that life-changing final, the paths of the two competitors diverged dramatically. Tiger Woods turned professional almost immediately, signed massive endorsement deals with Nike and Titleist, and began his ascent to global stardom. The world expected Steve Scott to follow suit.
Instead, Scott made a profound decision. He chose to return to the University of Florida to finish his degree. He valued his education and wanted to experience his final two years of college golf with his teammates. While Tiger was winning his first Masters in 1997, Scott was leading the Florida Gators and earning First-Team All-American honors. For Scott, there was more to life and the game than simply cashing in at the first opportunity. It was a mature and considered choice, but one that undeniably altered the trajectory of his playing career.
From a coaching perspective, this highlights a critical point: there is no single "right" path in golf. For some, like Tiger, seizing immediate professional momentum is the key. For others, developing as a person and enjoying the journey is paramount. Scott’s choice was a brave one that prioritized personal growth over immediate professional gain.
The Pro Ranks: A Journeyman's Hard-Fought Battle
Steve Scott turned professional in 1999, but the world of professional golf proved to be a challenging place. The immense pressure and expectations created by his duel with Tiger followed him everywhere he went. He competed on what was then known as the Buy.com Tour (now the Korn Ferry Tour), as well as the Canadian Tour and other circuits around the world.
While he had periods of success, he never broke through to establish a consistent career on the PGA Tour. The professional tour is a brutal reality, the margins are razor-thin. For every Tiger Woods, there are thousands of incredibly gifted players like Steve Scott who battle week in and week out, living out of suitcases and grinding just to make a cut. This part of his story is a humbling reminder of how difficult it is to reach the highest level of the sport. It's a journey filled with minor swing faults, missed putts, and relentless competition. Many golfers get stuck trying to fix their technique, but often, the challenge is simply the relentless mental and physical toll of the tour.
Scott's professional playing career represents the reality for the vast majority of aspiring pros. It's a testament to his love for the game that he continued to compete for years, chasing the dream with everything he had.
Finding a New Calling: The Rise of a PGA Head Professional
So, where is Steve Scott today? He is thriving. He found his true calling not as a touring professional, but as one of the most respected club professionals and teachers in the country.
Realizing his passion had shifted from pure competition to helping others enjoy the game, Scott transitioned into a career as a PGA Professional. This has been the most successful chapter of his story. He has held prestigious positions as a Head Golf Professional at several top clubs, including Paramount Country Club in New York and more recently, the Outpost Club and Matchplay Golf Club.
In this role, Scott isn't just a great player - he’s a leader, a mentor, an organizer, and most importantly, a teacher. He now uses his immense experience - from the pressure-cooker of the U.S. Amateur final to the grind of the pro tours - to help golfers of all levels. He found a way to turn his incredible on-course knowledge into a deeply fulfilling career that keeps him at the heart of the sport he loves.
Coaching Takeaways: What We Can Learn from Steve Scott
Steve Scott’s journey is packed with powerful lessons that any golfer can apply to their own game and mindset. As a coach, I see his story as a roadmap for finding true success in golf, and it has little to do with your scorecard.
- Play with Honor: The most enduring part of Scott's legacy is his sportsmanship. Remember this on the course. Give putts that are good, respect your playing partners, and always, always play the game with integrity. A good reputation lasts longer than any low round.
- Success Isn't a Straight Line: Your golf journey will have highs and lows. You might dream of being a scratch golfer but find more joy playing in your weekend scramble team. Like Scott, you may have one goal in mind, only to find true fulfillment in another. The key is to stay open to what the game gives you, rather than being fixated on a single A-to-B path.
- Relinquish Unfair Expectations: Scott carried the heavy burden of being "the guy who almost beat Tiger." That's a lot of weight to put on your shoulders every time you tee it up. For you, the expectation might be to finally break 90 or beat your buddy. Put those expectations aside. Focus on the shot in front of you and a simple process, not the outcome. Your freedom to swing will improve dramatically.
- Find Your Place in the Game: Scott’s story is the perfect example that a life in golf doesn't have to mean being on the PGA Tour. It can mean being a great Caddie, a club pro, a weekend warrior, a junior golf coach, or just the person who loves introducing new people to the sport. Find the part of golf that gives you the most joy, and lean into it. That is what true success looks like.
Final Thoughts
So what happened to Steve Scott? He didn't fade away, he redefined his relationship with golf, building a career based on leadership, sportsmanship, and a genuine passion for teaching. His story is a powerful reminder that "making it" in golf isn't just about winning trophies, but about character, integrity, and finding a lifelong home within the game.
Making a smart, honest decision under pressure - like Steve Scott did - is what separates a good outcome from a disastrous one on the golf course. We designed Caddie AI to be that caddie and coach in your pocket, giving you expert advice in those tough moments. Whether you’re stuck behind a tree, unsure of club selection, or facing a tough short-game shot, you have a guide to help you think clearly and make the right play, turning potential blow-up holes into manageable ones.