Ever heard a playing partner suggest a game of Chicago on the first tee and you just nodded along, completely unsure of the rules? You’re not alone. While not as common as a Scramble or Best Ball, the Chicago format is one of the most exciting and fair betting games you can play, perfectly designed to make a round with your buddies competitive, no matter their skill level. This guide breaks down everything you need to know about the format, from its unique scoring system to the on-course strategy that will help you take home the cash.
The best AI golf app: Caddie is your personal AI golf coach. Get expert-level golf advice instantly, 24/7 to help you play like a pro. Try it free →
What is the Chicago Format in Golf, Anyway?
At its heart, the Chicago format is a points-based game where individuals compete against a "quota" or target score determined by their handicap. Instead of counting your total strokes, you earn points for your performance on each hole: eagles, birdies, pars, and even bogeys have a point value. The goal isn't to shoot the lowest score, but to accumulate the most points over 18 holes and finish with the highest positive score relative to your personal quota.
The beauty of Chicago is that it levels the playing field. A golfer who shoots 100 has a legitimate chance to beat a player who shoots 75 because their point targets are adjusted accordingly. It also changes your mindset. A blow-up hole that would kill your score in stroke play simply results in zero points in Chicago, allowing you to shake it off and focus on scoring points on the very next hole. It's a game that promotes recovery, aggression, and most of all, fun.
Get pro-level golf advice instantly, 24/7
Ask Caddie anything. From “what club should I use?” to “how do I play this shot?” and get instant answers.
The system might sound a little complex at first, but once you play a hole or two, it becomes second nature. It's essentially a two-part process: first, you figure out every player's point target for the round, and second, you start awarding points hole-by-hole. Let’s walk through it.
Step 1: Setting Each Player's "Quota"
This is the element that makes Chicago so balanced. Before the round begins, every player calculates their individual point target, or "quota." The most common formula used to determine this number is 39 minus the player's course handicap.
A "course handicap" is simply your handicap index adjusted for the difficulty of the specific course and tees you are playing from. If you're not an official handicap holder, you can use an honest estimate of your average score (e.g., if you usually shoot around 90, your handicap is roughly 18). Let's look at a few examples of how to calculate the quota:
A scratch golfer (0 handicap) has a quota of 39 (39 - 0 = 39). They need to get 39 points to break even.
An 8-handicap player has a quota of 31 (39 - 8 = 31).
A 15-handicap player has a quota of 24 (39 - 15 = 24).
A 30-handicap player has a quota of 9 (39 - 30 = 9).
As you can see, a player with a higher handicap has a much lower point target to meet, which is what allows them to compete directly against much better players.
Step 2: How Points Are Earned on the Course
Once the quotas are set, play begins. The scoring is simple and is based on your gross score - your actual strokes - on each hole. The standard point breakdown is as follows:
Note: Sometimes groups will add more excitement with extra points for big scores (an Eagle might be 8 points and an Albatross 16 points), or even introduce negative points for bad holes (-1 for a double bogey). For your first time, however, sticking to the standard points above is the easiest way to go.
Step 3: Calculating the Winner at the End of the Round
This is where it all comes together. Simply tally up the total points you earned throughout the 18 holes. Then, you subtract your starting quota from your point total. The result is your final Chicago score. The player with the highest final score wins the game (or the money).
Let's play out a hypothetical scenario with two friends, Frank and Susan.
Frank is an 11-handicap golfer. His quota is 28 (39 - 11).
Susan is a 24-handicap golfer. Her quota is 15 (39 - 24).
After 18 holes, they add up their points:
Frank's Round: He had a solid day with 2 Birdies (8 pts), 8 Pars (16 pts), and 7 Bogeys (7 pts). His total points are 8 + 16 + 7 = 31 points.
Susan's Round: She struggled a bit but managed to avoid any major disasters. She made 4 Pars (8 pts), 9 Bogeys (9 pts), and five double bogeys (0 pts). Her total points are 8 + 9 = 17 points.
Now, let's calculate their final Chicago scores:
Frank's Final Score: 31 points - 28 quota = +3
Susan's Final Score: 17 points - 15 quota = +2
Although Susan shot a much higher stroke play score than Frank, the game was extremely close. Frank wins by a single point! If the bet was $1 a point, Susan would owe Frank $1. This is a perfect illustration of how the format creates a very competitive match between players of different abilities.
Why You Should Play Chicago Golf
Beyond being a fair betting game, Chicago offers some great benefits that can make any round more enjoyable, especially for casual golfers.
Ideal for Groups with Mixed Abilities
As we've seen, this is the format's greatest strength. The quota system acts as a built-in equalizer. It stops the low handicapper from running away with the game and prevents the high handicapper from feeling like they have no chance. If you have a regular group with a wide range of skill levels, Chicago is one of the best formats to ensure everyone stays engaged for all 18 holes.
Reduces Pressure and Speeds Up Play
This is an excellent benefit. In stroke play, one triple or quadruple bogey can wreck your score and your mood. Pockets are full, heads are down. In Chicago, disaster is limited to zero points. Once you’ve made a double bogey on a hole, you're at 0 and can’t do any more damage. This encourages players to simply pick up their ball and move to the next hole, which is fantastic for pace of play. No more watching your buddy grind over a putt for an 8 when it doesn't matter!
Rewards Good Shots, Forgives Bad Holes
The "pick up" rule also keeps morale high. Instead of dwelling on a tough hole, you can immediately refocus on the next one as a fresh opportunity to score points. A birdie is worth four times as much as a bogey, so making just one great hole can completely offset a few poor ones. This positive scoring system encourages a more resilient and attacking mindset, which is always more fun.
Plan every shot like a pro
Describe your situation and Caddie AI helps you pick your target, shot shape, and club with confidence.
Chicago isn't just about luck, playing with the right strategy can significantly increase your chances of winning. Here are a few tips from a coaching perspective.
Focus on Making Bogeys (or Net Pars)
For mid-to-high handicap players, the game-winning strategy isn't chasing birdies - it's eliminating zeroes. Earning at least 1 point for a bogey on every single hole gives you a baseline of 18 points. For a 21-handicapper with a quota of 18 (39-21), a round of all bogeys would mean you finish at 0, a very respectable score. See every hole as a mission to secure at least one point. Avoiding the blow-up is more valuable than making a single birdie.
Know When to Be Aggressive
If you're a low-handicap player with a high quota, playing for bogeys won't be enough. You need to hunt for pars and birdies. Since the penalty for a mistake is capped at losing a few potential points (not strokes), Chicago rewards calculated aggression. If you have a chance to go for a par-5 in two or attack a "sucker" pin, it might be worth the risk. A birdie nets you 4 points, a significant boost that can make up for a zero on another hole.
Learn When to Fold 'Em
Smart Chicago players have a great sense of self-awareness. If you hit your drive into the woods, take a drop, and then duff your third shot, the hole is likely gone. You’re lying 4 and still not on the green. Instead of trying for a heroic shot to save a bogey (1 point), recognize that the risk of making things worse is high. The smart play is to just get the ball back in play, accept you're probably getting a 0 on this hole, and reset for the next tee. Don’t let one bad decision bleed into two or three.
Play Golf like a Pro with Caddie
Learn and improve your golf game as you play. Get pro-level tips, strategy and guidance anytime.
Chicago is a fantastic golf format that brings a fresh, strategic element to your regular games. By using a handicap-based quota and a forgiving points system, it makes every round competitive and fast-paced, highlighting good shots while minimizing the pain of the inevitable bad holes.
Knowing when to play aggressively for 4 points versus laying up to secure 1 point is exactly where better course management makes a difference. This is something our Caddie AI simplifies for you. When you're facing a tough decision and you're not sure what the smart play is, you get instant, straightforward advice right in your pocket. We give you that on-demand second opinion to help you make smarter decisions, guiding you to turn those questionable holes into valuable points.
Spencer has been playing golf since he was a kid and has spent a lifetime chasing improvement. With over a decade of experience building successful tech products, he combined his love for golf and startups to create Caddie AI - the world's best AI golf app. Giving everyone an expert level coach in your pocket, available 24/7. Caddie's mission is simple: make world-class golf advice accessible to everyone, anytime.
Other posts you might like
What Is the Penalty for Signing an Incorrect Scorecard in Golf?
Signing an incorrect scorecard in golf can lead to one of the most painful penalties in the game, turning a great round into a heartbreaking disqualification on a technicality. It’s every competitive golfer's nightmare, but it doesn't have to be. This article breaks down the exact penalties for scorecard errors under the Rules of Golf, why they exist, and most importantly, provides a simple, foolproof process to ensure you never make this mistake again.
Ever glanced at a scorecard and wondered what the 'HCP' or 'Index' column means? You’re not alone. Those numbers, running from 1 to 18, represent the Hole Index, and they are one of the most underutilized strategic tools in a golfer’s arsenal. This ranking is your secret map to navigating the course intelligently and competing effectively in handicap games. This guide will break down precisely what the Hole Index is, how courses determine the ranking, and most importantly, how you can use it to play smarter and shoot lower scores.
If you follow professional golf outside of the PGA TOUR, you’ve almost certainly heard commentators talk about the Rolex Series. It’s a term of prestige on the DP World Tour, but many golf fans aren't completely sure what it means. This article will break down exactly what the Rolex Series is, which tournaments are included, and why these events are so important for the players competing to make their mark on the world stage.
Seeing those red stakes or that intimidating red line alongside a fairway can make any golfer’s heart sink. You’ve just hit a wayward shot, and now you have to deal with a red penalty area. But this situation, while frustrating, doesn’t have to ruin your hole or your round. Understanding your options is the first step toward turning a potential disaster into a simple recovery. This guide will walk you through exactly what a red penalty area is, what your relief options are, and how to choose the right one with confidence.
Shooting a score that’s sub par is the goal for nearly every golfer, but what it means and how to achieve it can feel like a moving target. In its simplest terms, playing sub par golf means you’ve completed a hole, or an entire round, in fewer strokes than the designated par score. This article will break down the language of scoring, the strategies behind going low, and a practical path for you to start chasing those under-par scores yourself.
Pop quiz: how many major championships are there in men's professional golf? If you said five, you’re not alone, but it’s a common misconception. The truth is there are four, but a fifth tournament has earned such a celebrated reputation that many fans and even players consider it a major in everything but name. This article will walk you through the four official majors, detailing their unique histories and characteristics, and then introduce you to the prestigious event that created the five majors debate.
