Medal play, officially known as stroke play, is the scoring system where your total number of shots over a round - or an entire tournament - determines your score and final standing. It's the most common format you see on professional tours and at most club championships for a simple reason: it identifies the most consistent golfer. This guide will walk you through what medal play is, the most important rules to follow, and the specific strategies you need to develop to post your best scores.
So, What Exactly Is Medal Play?
Unlike other golf formats where you compete directly against an opponent on a hole-by-hole basis, in medal play, you are competing against the entire field and the course itself. Every single shot counts toward your final score, from the first tee shot to the last putt that drops into the cup on the 18th green. The winner is the player who completes the round(s) in the fewest total strokes.
The beauty and brutality of medal play lie in its absoluteness. A great birdie on one hole is exciting, but a disastrous triple-bogey a few holes later can erase that progress and then some. This an entirely different beast from match play, where you only need to beat your opponent on an individual hole to win that hole. In match play, a triple-bogey costs you the same as a bogey would - you lose the hole, shake it off, and move on to the next one with a clean slate. In medal play, that triple-bogey stays on your scorecard, hanging around for the rest of the day.
This dynamic demands a different mentality. It rewards patience, conservative strategy, and resilience over aggressive, high-risk golf. Your goal isn't just to make birdies, it's to avoid the "blow-up" holes that can destroy your score in an instant.
The Rules That Matter Most in Medal Play
Because every stroke is recorded, adhering to the rules is fundamental. A few procedural rules take on extra importance in a medal play competition to protect the integrity of the field.
You Must Hole Out Everywhere
This is the most significant difference for many casual golfers. In medal play, there are no "gimmies." Every putt must be played until the ball is in the hole. That little two-footer you might scoop up during a friendly game must be stroked. This rule ensures every player's score is a complete and accurate reflection of their play. Missing short putts adds up quickly, and holing out under pressure is a skill that separates players in a competitive environment.
Your Scorecard is a Sacred Document
At the start of a medal play round, you will exchange scorecards with another player in your group, known as your "marker." Your responsibility is to keep their score, and theirs is to keep yours. After each hole, you should:
- Verbally confirm the scores with each other.
- Carefully write down your marker's gross score for that hole on their card.
- Keep track of your own score on their card (normally in a separate column marked "Player" or "My Score").
At the end of the round, it's time for the final accounting. You and your marker must review the scorecard hole by hole to confirm all scores are correct. Once you both agree, you each need to sign the card in the spaces designated for the "Player" and the "Marker." Signing an incorrect scorecard carries heavy penalties. Signing for a score higher than you actually shot means you have to accept that higher score. Signing for a score lower than you actually shot results in disqualification. After signing, the card must be returned to the tournament committee promptly. No detail is too small when it comes to the scorecard.
Keep the Pace
Because entire tournaments are running on this format, pace of play is a group responsibility. Nobody wants a five-and-a-half-hour round. Here a few simple habits to develop:
- Play ready golf: If you're ready to hit and it's safe to do so, go ahead. Don't always wait for the person furthest from the hole if they aren't prepared.
- Be prepared: Plan your next shot while you are walking or while others are hitting. Think about the yardage and the club you'll likely need before it's your turn.
- Keep moving: After you putt out, don't stand around the green tallying scores. Move to the next tee box and do your accounting there while the next group plays up.Developing a Medal Play StrategyPlaying well in a medal play format is less about hitting spectacular shots and more about playing smart, disciplined golf. You have to think your way around the course and manage your game from start to finish.Course Management is Your Best FriendForget trying to overpower the course. Instead, play a strategic game of chess. Before each shot, ask yourself a few questions:
- Where's the trouble? Identify the hazards - water, out of bounds, penal bunkers, thick trees. Your primary aim is to take them out of play, even if it means hitting a shorter club off the tee. A 3-wood or hybrid in the fairway is always better than a driver sliced out of bounds.
- What's the high-percentage play? Look for the largest, safest area to land the ball. On approach shots, aiming for the middle of the green is rarely a bad decision. Don't fire at every pin, especially the ones tucked behind a bunker or near a water hazard. A long putt from the middle of the green is a much better outcome than a short-sided chip from a bunker.
- Know your numbers: This isn't just about knowing your full-swing distances. It's about knowing your reliable "layup" distance. If you can't reach a par-5 in two, what's a comfortable distance to leave yourself for your third shot? Laying up to your favorite 100-yard wedge distance is a much smarter play than blasting a 3-wood and hoping for the best.
The Mindset of a Medal PlayerYour attitude on the course is just as important as your swing. Medal play is a marathon, not a sprint. - Stay Patient: Bogeys will happen. Even the pros make them. Don't let one bad hole convince you to start making rash, aggressive decisions to "get the shot back" immediately. Stick to your game plan.
- Amortize Your Mistakes: One of the best mental tricks is to forget the last shot, good or bad, and focus entirely on the one in front of you. You can't change what already happened, but you have complete control over your preparation and commitment to the current shot.
- Play Against the Course: Don't get caught up in how others in your group are playing. Their 300-yard drive doesn't add a stroke to your scorecard. Your opponent is the course architect's design. Your goal is simply to navigate the 18 holes in the fewest strokes possible for your game.
Damage Control: How to Avoid the Dreaded "Blow-Up Hole"The number one killer of a good score in medal play is the double, triple, or quadruple bogey. Knowing how to limit the damage when a hole goes sideways is a game-changer. This is often where people let ego take over. A smart golfer knows when to cut their losses.Let's say you've hit your tee shot deep into the trees. The hero shot would be trying to thread a 5-iron through a tiny gap between two pine trees. The smart play - the medal-play play - is to take a wedge and simply punch the ball sideways back into the fairway. Yes, you've taken a penalty stroke for being out of position, but now you have a clear shot for your next one. Trying the hero shot and hitting a tree could mean you're still in jail, and now a 6 has turned into an 8. Taking your medicine gives you the best chance to walk away with a bogey or, at worst, a double bogey.ConclusionFinal ThoughtsMedal play is the ultimate test of a golfer's complete game. It requires patience, solid course management, and the discipline to avoid big mistakes, because every single stroke counts toward your final score. By understanding the rules, developing a conservative strategy, and learning to control the damage when things go wrong, you can become a more resilient and successful competitive golfer.Mastering medal play strategy really comes down to ditching guesswork and making smarter decisions on the course. We designed Caddie AI to be your personal on-course advisor for exactly these moments. When you're standing on the tee unsure of the right play, you can get a simple, smart strategy for the hole. When you find yourself in a tricky lie in the rough or buried in a bunker, you can get instant advice on the best way to play the shot to avoid one of those dreaded blow-up holes. Having an expert second opinion in your pocket removes the uncertainty and helps you commit to every shot with confidence.