The over the top golf swing is the single most common fault that frustrates amateur golfers, leading to weak slices and frustrating pulls. This article will show you exactly what is happening when you come over the top, explain the simple reasons why it happens, and give you clear, actionable drills to finally fix it.
What Exactly Is an 'Over the Top' Swing?
Imagine your ideal swing path as a big, tilted hula hoop standing on the ground. On the way back, the club travels up the inside of that hoop. On the way down, it should follow that same path down and from the inside to hit the ball. An "over the top" move is when your downswing breaks that beautiful loop. Instead of dropping back down on that same path, your arms and club are thrown outward and over that ideal swing plane at the start of downswing.
Think about casting a fishing rod - that forward throwing motion is a great feel for what an over the top move is. It's an aggressive move from the top, usually with the right shoulder and right arm, that throws the club out and away from your body. This forces the club to cut across the ball from out-to-in at impact.
What Shots Does it Cause?
- The Slice: This is the classic symptom. The out-to-in path puts a glancing blow on the ball, creating sidespin that sends it curving weakly to the right (for a right-handed golfer).
- The Pull: If you manage to get the clubface square or closed to that out-to-in path, the ball starts left of your target and stays there.
- Skied Shots and Weak Contact: Because the club is coming down at such a steep angle, you often hit the top half of the ball or catch it thin, resulting in a dramatic loss of power and distance.
At its core, "over the top" is a sequencing problem where the wrong parts of your body are starting the downswing.
Why Does It Happen? Understanding the Root Causes
No golfer actively tries to come over the top. It’s an instinctual, yet incorrect, move that almost every golfer battles at some point. Understanding why you do it is the first step to a permanent fix.
The All-Too-Common Upper Body Impulse
The most frequent cause is very simple: you trying to hit the ball with your upper body. From the top of the backswing, a lot of players think "hit the ball!" and their first move is to fire their shoulders, chest, and arms forward. This feels powerful, but it throws the club's path way off track.
Your golf swing is supposed to be a rotational action, with the club moving *around* your body. It is mainly powered by the turning of your torso and hips. The "over the top" move changes it to an athletic but ineffective chopping or throwing motion, using only the arms and shoulders. This loses the power generated from the ground up.
Bad Sequencing: A Traffic Jam in Your Swing
A good golf swing sequence starts from the floor. The downswing is initiated by a small bump of the hips toward the target, which then starts to unwind the torso, which then brings the arms and club through. It's a chain reaction.
An over-the-top swing flips that sequence entirely. The shoulders and arms go first, creating a traffic jam. The hips and lower body have nowhere to go and no time to do their job. When the upper body wins the race to the ball, the club has no choice but to be thrown outward and across the line.
Setup Issues Setting You Up for Failure
Sometimes, the problem begins before you even swing. If you set up with your shoulders "open" (aimed left of the target), your subconscious mind knows this. As a compensation, you might throw the club over the top to get it back towards the target. Poor posture, like standing too stiff and upright, can also limit your ability to rotate properly, again promoting an arm-driven, over-the-top motion.
Your Step-by-Step Guide to Fixing It
Fixing an over the top move isn't about one secret tip, it's about re-training your body to understand a different feeling and sequence. The following drills are designed to do just that, starting with simple feels and moving to tangible feedback.
Feel the 'Drop': The Re-routing Drill
This is a feel-based drill that focuses on fixing the sequence. You can do this without a ball first, then with slow, easy swings.
- Take a Normal Backswing: Get to the top of your swing in a good, athletic position.
- The 'Magic' Move: Instead of immediately firing your shoulders, I want you to feel your hands and arms *drop* slightly downward and behind you. Imagine letting the clubhead fall an inch or two toward the ground behind you. This can only happen if you initiate the downswing by shifting your weight and starting to turn your hips first.
- Rotate Through: Once you've felt that slight drop, simply rotate your body through to the finish. The club will naturally approach the ball from the inside.
This will feel strange at first. It will feel like you're going to miss the ball or hit a huge push, but this "dropping" sensation is the exact opposite of the "throwing" sensation of an over-the-top move.
The Headcover Drill: Your Feedback Station
This is probably the most effective drill ever invented for fixing the out-to-in swing path because it provides immediate, non-negotiable feedback. If you do it wrong, you’ll hit the object.
- Find an Object: Use a spare headcover, a partly empty range basket, or even a rolled-up towel.
- Place the Obstacle: Put the object on the ground just outside of your target line. A good position is about a foot outside the ball and a foot behind it. It will be slightly diagonally behind the ball.
- Make a Swing: Now, set up to your ball and just try to hit it without hitting the headcover.
- If you come over the top, your club will crash right into the headcover on the way down.
- To miss the headcover, you are forced to make your club approach the ball from a more shallow, inside path - the very fix you’re looking for!
Start with half swings at a slow tempo. Hitting a real golf ball next to the obstacle can be nerve-racking, so begin by just taking practice swings. As you get more confident you can hit balls, but the goal is to ingrain the feeling of the club coming from the inside to miss the obstacle.
The Step-Through Drill: Hardwiring the Sequence
This brilliant drill forces your lower body to lead the downswing, making an upper-body-led, over-the-top move almost impossible.
- Start with Feet Together: Address the ball with a middle iron, but stand with your feet almost touching.
- The Backswing Step: As you start your backswing, take a small step a few inches back with your trail foot (your right foot for a right-hander). This helps you make a full body turn.
- The 'Step-Through' Downswing: As your club reaches the top of its backswing, take a decisive step forward toward the target with your lead foot (your left foot).
- Swing Through: Let your momentum carry you through the shot as your body rotates.
By stepping toward the target, you are physically forcing your lower body to fire first. This automatically puts your arms and club on the proper inside path. It physically demonstrates what correct sequencing feels like.
Taking the Fix from the Range to the Course
Ingraining a new move on the range is one thing, trusting it on the course is the real test. Here are a couple of thoughts for making the transition a little smoother.
- Rehearse the Feeling: Before every single shot on the course, make a slow-motion practice swing focusing on the feeling you learned in the drills. Feel the drop from the inside. This is your number one priority.
- Commit to the New Move: Your new swing might produce some wayward shots at first (often pushes or hooks). That's okay! It means you're actually changing your path. Don't revert to the old 'safe' sliced swing. Stick with the new feeling.
- Relax the Transition: A major trigger for an over-the-top move is a rushed transition from backswing to downswing. Feel a slight pause at the top. Let a smooth sequence, not a violent lurch, start your motion down.
Final Thoughts
An over-the-top swing path is a frustrating but fixable habit rooted in poor sequencing. By learning to lead the downswing with your lower body and feeling the club approach from the inside, you can replace those high, weak slices with powerful, straight golf shots.
Drills create better ball-strikers, but smarter course management creates better scores. Knowing what shot to hit in tricky situations is just as valuable as the swing you make. For that, Caddie AI acts as your on-demand course expert. When you're facing a tough lie or feel uncertain about strategy, you can get instant, simple advice right in your pocket. It removes the doubt so you can fully commit to every swing and play with more confidence.