What Is the Best Yardage Device in Golf?

Trying to find the right yardage device can feel like choosing a new driver - the options are overwhelming and everyone has a different opinion. The truth is, there isn't one single best device for every golfer. The right tool for you depends entirely on your game, your budget, and what you prioritize on the course. This guide will cut through the noise, breaking down the pros and cons of laser rangefinders, GPS watches, and handheld units so you can confidently pick the perfect partner for your game.

Good Numbers are a Pillar of Confident Golf

Before we break down the hardware, let’s quickly confirm why this matters so much. Getting an accurate yardage is about far more than just picking the right club for your shot to the pin. It's the foundation of smart course management and shot-to-shot consistency. Knowing the number isn't just about avoiding a mis-club, it's about playing with conviction.

Think about it. When you have a precise number to a target, indecision melts away. You replace a gut feeling with a fact. This simple shift empowers you to:

• Commit to the shot: Ditching the "is it a hard 8-iron or an easy 7-iron?" debate allows you to make a smooth, committed swing.
• Manage hazards: Knowing the exact carry distance over a bunker or the layup yardage short of a pond turns a potential disaster into a calculated strategic decision.
• Build a "knowledge bank": Consistently knowing your yardages helps you learn exactly how far you actually hit each club, not how far you think you hit it. This is invaluable information.

A good yardage device takes the guesswork out of the equation. It closes the gap between what you think you need to do and what the course is actually asking of you. Now, let’s find the right tool for that job.

The Contenders: A Breakdown of Your Options

Your main choices fall into three categories: laser rangefinders, GPS watches, and handheld GPS units. Each has distinct advantages and disadvantages, and the best fit depends on what kind of information you value most.

Laser Rangefinders: For Pinpoint Precision

A laser rangefinder is a point-and-shoot device that uses a laser beam to measure the exact distance to a specific object you aim at. You look through the eyepiece, place the crosshairs on the target (like the flagstick), press a button, and it provides a yardage to within a yard or less.

Pros of a Laser Rangefinder:

• Unmatched Accuracy: This is their biggest selling point. You can get an exact yardage to the flagstick, a specific tree guarding a dogleg, the front lip of a bunker, or the top of a mound. If you can see it, you can get a number for it.
• Slope Functionality: Many models include a "slope" feature that calculates the effective yardage based on elevation changes. A 150-yard shot that is severely downhill might only play 140 yards, helping you choose the correct club for the hole. (Note: This is usually not allowed in tournaments or handicap rounds, but it is an awesome tool for practice rounds.)
• Practice Station Game-Changer: A laser is invaluable on the range. You can "zap" different flags, signs, or landmarks to learn precisely how far you hit each club.
• No Fees or Subscriptions: Once you buy it, it's yours. Most models rely on a small battery that lasts for months on end – no subscriptions or fees needed.

Cons of a Laser Rangefinder:

• Requires a Steady Hand: Locking on to a thin flagstick or a distant target, especially on a windy day, can be challenging for some players. Most modern rangefinders have "pin-seeker" technology that helps, but it's still a potential issue.
• Line of Sight Required: Lasers are limited to line-of-sight analysis. If you can’t get a visual of a target, then it will not appear as a viable option to find your distance. For example, if you are stuck behind some trees, you cannot get your distance to the flagstick. A laser is useless for blind shots or holes with a sharp incline.
• Can Slow Down Your Play: Fetching the laser from its case, aiming for your shot, locking in a target, and then storing the device back in its pouch can take longer than simply checking your watch.

Perfect For: The golfer who is obsessed with precise numbers and makes confident decisions based on that feedback. If you enjoy playing most of your golf at your go-to home course and having the exact yardage to the pin is your main priority, then a laser device will probably be your optimal choice to advance your game.

GPS Watches: For At-a-Glance Convenience

A GPS golf watch comes pre-loaded with tens of thousands of course maps. Using satellites, it automatically recognizes which course and hole you're playing and provides instant yardages to the front, middle, and back of the green.

Pros of a GPS Watch:

• Incredible Speed: This is a GPS watch’s greatest strength. It takes less time than aiming a laser. The yardages are shown on your wrist and are easy and quick to glance at.
• Strategic Information: The old golf wisdom holds true: Aiming for the middle of the green is usually your best approach. A GPS watch is always centered around that philosophy. The watch will consistently give you numbers for the front, middle, and rear parts of the green.
• Helpful in a Blind Spot: Unlike a laser, the GPS can display how many yards until you reach the green - from wherever you are - in a blind spot scenario or in dog-leg situations. That makes them great for seeing the distances to hazards, like water or sand.
• Extra Features: A lot of GPS watch models offer more than just distance data. These additional features can include digital scorecards, play tracking, as well as health and fitness information like step counters, and other features on their smartphone apps.

Cons of a GPS Watch:

• General, Not Exact Yardages: You will always get the same front, middle, or rear distances to the green no matter how you are approaching the green. All the course's preprogrammed data is on a fixed location. The GPS device can show you how many yards you hit your last shot if tracked, but it won't give you the exact distance to the flag like a laser would.
• Dependency on Charging: Just like your smartphone, this device relies on battery power to function, so you'll need to recharge it between rounds of golf.
• Course Mapping Issues: Occasionally, you might encounter a hole or a tee box that has been relocated or a green that has changed shape, but the changes have not yet been inputted into the database of your selected course map, resulting in minor distance errors.

Perfect For: The everyday golfer who puts pace of play and convenience above all. If you're looking for basic and quickly accessible numbers so that you can choose your club with confidence and no fuss, then a GPS watch makes a great partner on the course.

Handheld GPS Units: Large-View Strategy

Handheld GPS units often display a detailed map of the course on a larger screen, offering a bird's-eye view for strategic play. This visual approach can help golfers plan their shots more efficiently, especially on unfamiliar courses.

Pros of a Handheld GPS Unit:

• Visual Course Strategy: The ability to see a complete bird's-eye-view of the hole you are playing is a great advantage, especially on an unfamiliar layout. You can drag your marker on the screen and see exact distances to strategic points on the golf hole - such as the fairway landing zones, the front lip of a bunker, or the carry distance over a creek, which is very helpful in planning your strategy.
• Data Tracking: Score-keeping and stat-tracking functions are often available, allowing you to analyze your play and improve over time.

Cons of a Handheld GPS Unit:

• Bulky and Inconvenient: Compared to a watch, it's less ergonomic to carry and must be manually stored and retrieved.
• Requires Regular Charging: Like your smartphone, it relies on battery power that must be recharged regularly.
• Course Map Updates: May require purchasing advanced features or mapping updates.

Perfect For: Golfers who enjoy a comprehensive strategic approach to the game. It's ideal for those who like having detailed information and enjoy planning each shot.

How to Make Your Choice

The best yardage device is the one that fits your specific needs and enhances your play. Whether you value the exactitude of a laser, the simplicity and speed of a GPS watch, or the strategic insights of a handheld GPS, the right device takes the guesswork out and helps you play with clarity and commitment.

While hardware can provide you with "the what" - the yardages themselves - real confidence on the course comes from knowing "how to execute" and "why you should make decisions" on the course. In the moments when you have your yardage, you are faced with decisions such as club choice or strategy.

Check out Caddie to enhance your golf experience with personalized strategy advice and in-depth course intel, enabling you to play smarter, save time, and improve your game.