Making an eagle is one of golf's ultimate achievements, a moment of brilliance that often feels reserved for the pros you see on TV. This article breaks down exactly how common - or uncommon - eagles really are for everyday golfers. We'll look at the raw statistics and, more importantly, give you a practical, step-by-step game plan to chase your next one.
So, What Percentage of Golfers Actually Make an Eagle?
The short answer: not many. An eagle is a score of two strokes under par on a single hole, and it is a genuinely rare event for the average amateur player. While there isn't one single, definitive database for all golfers, we can pull data from major shot-tracking apps and handicap systems to get a very clear picture. The numbers paint a story of difficulty, but also opportunity.
Here’s a look at the odds, broken down by handicap:
- PGA Tour Professional: The best players in the world make an eagle roughly once every 75 to 90 holes on average. They possess the combination of immense power, pin-point accuracy with long irons, and world-class putting needed to convert eagle chances regularly, primarily on Par 5s.
- Scratch Golfer (0 Handicap): A scratch player is a fantastic golfer, but they aren't a touring pro. Their chances drop significantly. A typical scratch golfer might make an eagle once every 25 rounds, or about once every 450 holes.
- 10-Handicap Golfer: For a solid mid-handicap player, eagles become a an exciting but infrequent bonus. A golfer at this level might card an eagle once every 70-80 rounds, or approximately once every 1,350 holes.
- Average Golfer (18-20 Handicap): This is where most golfers live. For this player, an eagle is a true once-a-year (or once-every-few-years) feat. The data suggests an average of one eagle per 200+ rounds played. Many golfers in this range will go their entire lives without one.
What does this tell us? It confirms that making an eagle is tough. But it also shows that as your skills and strategy improve, your chances increase dramatically. It’s not just about getting lucky, it’s about putting yourself in a position to let luck happen.
The Three Ways An Eagle Happens
While the score is always "two-under," an eagle can happen in three distinct ways. Understanding each path helps clarify where your best opportunities lie.
Path 1: The Par-5 Eagle (Your Best Bet)
This is the classic and by far the most common way to make an eagle. The formula is a showcase of power and precision:
- A powerful and well-positioned drive leaves you within striking distance of the green.
- A perfectly struck fairway wood, hybrid, or long iron finds the green.
- You drain a single putt for a score of 3.
Alternatively, if your second shot just misses the green, you can still chip in for an eagle. For the vast majority of golfers, targeting manageable Par 5s is the most realistic path to making an eagle.
Path 2: The Drivable Par-4 Eagle
This is the high-risk, high-reward play. Some Par 4s are designed to be short, tempting long hitters to go for the green off the tee. If you manage to drive the green and make the putt, you’ve carded a 2 for an spectacular eagle.
However, these holes are almost always defended by serious hazards - deep bunkers, water, or thick rough - punishing a miss. The decision to attempt this shot is a major moment of course management.
Path 3: The Par-3 Eagle (A Hole-in-One)
The ultimate feat in golf. A hole-in-one on a Par 3 is technically an eagle, as it's a score of 1 on a Par-3 hole (two strokes under par). Combining jaw-dropping skill with a healthy dose of good fortune, the "ace" is the rarest eagle of all.
Your Practical Game Plan for Chasing an Eagle
Alright, enough with the statistics. Let's talk strategy. You can't just hope for an eagle, you have to build a game that creates eagle opportunities. Since the Par 5 represents your best chance, our entire game plan will focus on mastering them.
Step 1: Get More from Your Driver
The entire sequence of a Par-5 eagle starts with the tee shot. A weak or off-line drive takes you out of the running for reaching the green in two. You need distance, but you need playable distance. A 300-yard drive into the trees is useless. A 250-yard drive in the fairway is your ticket to the next step.
Actionable Advice: Focus on the engine of your swing: your body's rotation. The feeling isn’t one of swinging your arms harder, but of turning your torso more efficiently. As you make your backswing, focus on rotating your shoulders and hips, coiling your body like a spring. The downswing is then about unwinding that coil. A smooth, powerful rotation is the source of effortless distance, making the club feel like it’s being pulled around your body in a stable, round motion.
Step 2: Build Confidence with Your "Go Club"
The second shot on a Par 5 is often the most demanding shot in golf. You're likely 200+ yards out and need a club you can trust. For many, this is a 3-wood, 5-wood, or a hybrid. This is not the time to try a club you only hit once per month on the range.
Actionable Advice: Identify your "go club" for long approach shots. Dedicate a portion of your practice time specifically to this club. Don't just hit it off a perfect "range mat" lie. Practice hitting it off the fairway, from light rough, and even from slightly uneven stances. Your goal is to build an unshakeable confidence that you can advance the ball cleanly toward the target, even if you don't hit it perfectly every time.
Step 3: Turn Near Misses into Opportunities with Your Wedges
Let's be realistic: even with a great drive and a solid second shot, you might end up just short or to the side of the green. This is where your short game can steal an eagle. A holed-out chip or pitch shot is one of the most exhilarating feelings in golf.
Actionable Advice: Practice chipping and pitching to a specific target, not just a general area. Try to land the ball on a specific spot and let it roll out to the hole. Learn to control trajectory - practice hitting low, running chips as well as higher, softer pitches. The more shots you have in your short-game arsenal, the more likely you are to see one disappear into the cup.
Step 4: Sharpen Your Putting From Eagle Range
You've done the hard work. A strong drive and a phenomenal second shot have left you with a 25-foot putt for eagle. Now you have to finish the job. This is not a moment for a lag putt, it’s a moment to try and make it.
Actionable Advice: When you practice putting, spend less time on 3-footers and more time on putts in the 15-to-30-foot range. Get a feel for the speed required to get the ball to the hole. Walk around your putts to see the break from different angles. On a real eagle putt, give it a confident, committed stroke. Even if you miss, an aggressive roll that just slides by the edge often leaves you with a simple tap-in for birdie, which is still a fantastic result.
Step 5: Pick Your Spots with Smart Strategy
This is arguably the most important step. Knowing when to go for the green in two - and when to play it safe - is what separates low-scoring golfers from high-scoring ones. Not all Par 5s are created equal.
Actionable Advice: Before pulling the trigger on your second shot, do a quick risk assessment.
- Where is the trouble? Is there a lake guarding the front of the green? Are deep bunkers waiting on the left and right?
- What is my lie? Do I have a perfect fairway lie, or is the ball sitting down in the rough, making a clean strike difficult?
*
What is the smart miss?** If I don't hit it perfectly, where's the best place to end up to still give myself a simple up-and-down for birdie?
Sometimes, the smart play is to a lay up to your favorite wedge distance (e.g., 100 yards), take the big trouble out of play, and give yourself a great look at a stress-free birdie.
Final Thoughts
Making an eagle is a landmark moment for any golfer, and the stats confirm it's a rare and special event. While luck plays a part, eagles don't just happen by accident. They are the result of a well-executed strategy, starting with a powerful drive and culminating in a confident stroke on or around the green.
Building that strategy and making smarter decisions is where I can help. When you’re standing over the ball on a Par 5 wrestling with whether to go for it, I can analyze the situation and give you a clear, simple recommendation in seconds. By acting as your personal caddie, I help you assess risk, choose saner targets, and navigate those tough moments with confidence, taking the guesswork out of your round so you can commit to every shot. The next time you have a genuine eagle opportunity, you’ll be ready to seize it with a sound game plan, thanks to Caddie AI.