Why Am I So Inconsistent at Golf?

One minute you're flushing a 7-iron that sits down softly for a tap-in putt, and the next, you're shanking a simple wedge into the trees. Sound familiar? That jarring feeling of brilliance followed by disaster isn't just frustrating, it’s the single biggest complaint I hear from golfers of every handicap. This wild swing in performance isn't just bad luck - it’s a clear signal that something in your fundamentals is shaky. This article will break down the five most common reasons for golfing inconsistency and give you a clear, actionable game plan to build a more repeatable, reliable swing.

Your Setup and Ball Position Are Haphazard

Think of your golf setup as the foundation of a house. If you pour that foundation on a different angle or in a different spot every time, the house is going to be crooked - no matter how well you build the walls. It’s the same with your golf swing. If your starting position is inconsistent, your body will instinctively try to make a series of last-second compensations during the swing to get the club back to the ball. That 'rescue' mission is the very definition of inconsistency.

Many golfers I work with simply walk up to the ball, plant their feet, and swing, paying little attention to the details of their posture or where the ball is in relation to their feet. Their setup changes with every club and every shot, and they wonder why they can't get the same result twice.

You need to build a setup that is both athletic and, more importantly, repeatable. Yes, the correct golf stance can feel a little weird at first. As a coach, I often hear, “This feels so strange, am I sticking my butt out too much?” The answer is almost always no. That "weird" feeling is usually just the feeling of getting into an athletic, balanced position ready to generate power.

How to Build a Consistent Setup:

1. Start with the Clubhead: Before you take your stance, place the clubhead directly behind the golf ball. Your number one job is to return it to this spot. Critically, make sure the leading edge is aiming squarely at your target. This provides a constant reference point.
2. Lean From Your Hips: Now, tilt your upper body forward from your hips, not by slouching your shoulders. As you tilt, your bottom will naturally push backward. A great checkpoint is to feel your arms hang down straight and relaxed from your shoulders. If they feel jammed into your body, you’re too upright. If they feel stretched and reaching, you’ve leaned over too much.
3. Establish Your Stance Width: For a mid-iron shot (like a 7, 8, or 9-iron), a good starting point is to have your feet shoulder-width apart. This provides a stable base that’s wide enough to allow your body to rotate powerfully, but not so wide that it restricts your hip turn. For shorter clubs, you can go slightly narrower, for longer clubs and woods, slightly wider.
4. Check Your Ball Position: This is a massive source of inconsistency. A simple rule of thumb: for your shortest clubs (wedges and short irons), position the ball in the absolute middle of your stance. As the clubs get longer, the ball should move progressively forward. A 7-iron might be a ball or two forward of center, and your a driver is played off the inside of your lead heel. If your ball position is too far back, you’ll hit down on it too steeply, too far forward, and you’ll tend to hit it thin or on the upswing. Get this right every time, and you’ve eliminated a huge variable.

Your Grip Varies From Swing to Swing

If your setup is the foundation, your grip is the steering wheel. It has the biggest influence of any single element on where the clubface is pointing at impact. If your hands are on the club differently every time you swing, that clubface is going to arrive at the ball in a different position. A grip that's too "strong" (turned too far away from the target) will tend to shut the face and send the ball left. A "weak" grip will do the opposite. When the grip is a moving target, you're forced to manipulate the club with your hands at 100 mph to try to square it up. Good luck doing that consistently.

The goal is to find a neutral grip that allows you to return the clubface to square with minimal effort. It will feel strange at first, especially if you have been holding it incorrectly for a while, but committing to a good grip is non-negotiable for consistency.

How to Build a Repeatable Grip:

• Left Hand (for righties): Start with the clubface square. Place your left hand on the grip so that you are holding the club more in your fingers, from the base of your little finger to the middle of your index finger. When you look down, you should be able to see the knuckles of your index and middle fingers. The "V" formed by your thumb and index finger should point roughly toward your right shoulder.
• Right Hand (for righties): Bring your right hand to the club. The palm of your right hand should cover your left thumb. Just as with the left hand, the club should rest primarily in the fingers. The "V" formed by your right thumb and index finger should also point up toward your right shoulder, mirroring your left hand.
• The Connection: You have three primary options for connecting your hands: the ten-finger (like a baseball bat), the overlap (right pinky resting on top of the left index finger), or the interlock (right pinky and left index finger hooked together). There is no "right" way. Choose whichever feels most secure and comfortable to you. The key is that your hands work as a single unit.

Perform a grip check before every single shot on the range. Make it as much a part of your routine as picking a target. In time, this correct, neutral hold will become second nature.

You're Using the Wrong Power Source

So many inconsistent golfers try to create speed and power using only their arms and hands. This leads to a steep, "up and down" chopping motion. You might catch one perfectly, but you’re just as likely to hit a fat shot where you hit the ground first, or a thin shot where you catch only the top half of the ball. This arm-dominant swing lacks both power and reliability.

The true engine of the golf swing is the body - the big muscles of your core and hips. The golf swing is a rotational action. You turn your body away from the ball in the backswing to create stored energy, and then you unwind your body through the ball to release that energy. The arms and the club are just along for the ride, transferring the power from your body into the ball. When you learn to sequence this correctly, you'll unlock a powerful, rhythmic, and far more consistent swing.

How to Feel a Body-Driven Swing:

Imagine you're standing inside a small barrel or cylinder. In your backswing, your goal is to rotate your hips and shoulders, turning your back to the target while staying inside that cylinder. You aren’t swaying side-to-side, you are coiling like a spring.

From the top, the downswing is initiated by unwinding from the ground up. Your hips begin to turn back toward the target, which then pulls your torso, which then pulls your arms and the club. It’s a chain reaction. To practice this feeling, take some smooth, 50% swings where your only thought is to turn your chest away from the target and then turn your chest all the way through to face the target. Notice how the club just follows your body's motion. That’s the feeling of connection you want.

You Don't Understand Solid Contact

Do you feel like you try to help or "scoop" the ball into the air? This is one of the most common instincts for amateurs and a primary cause of inconsistency. Trying to lift the ball leads to hitting shots thin (blading them across the green) or fat (hitting the chunk of turf behind the ball). All of your golf clubs (except your putter) are designed with loft. That loft is what gets the ball airborne. Your job is not to lift the ball, your job is to strike it solidly.

For consistent iron play, you want to strike the golf ball first, and then the turf just after it. This "ball-then-turf" contact compresses the ball against the clubface, creating a powerful, penetrating ball flight with predictable distance.

How to Achieve a Downward Strike:

The secret to solid contact is achieved by a small but important move at the start of your downswing. As you unwind from the top, you should feel a slight shift of pressure into your lead foot. You aren't lunging or sliding, it's a subtle but definite transfer of weight toward the target.

This move does something amazing: it moves the low point of your swing arc slightly in front of the ball. This ensures the clubhead is still traveling downwards as it contacts the ball, producing that pure, compressed strike. A great drill is to draw a line on the driving range an inch or two behind your ball. Your one goal is to hit the ball and have your divot start *after* the line - on the target side. This drill forces you to make that slight weight shift and automatically improves your contact and consistency. Don't be afraid to take a divot!

Your Mental Game is a Scrambled Mess

Inconsistency on the scorecard isn't just about swing mechanics. A huge part of it is mental. Think about it: you hit a bad drive. Do you get frustrated, then rush your next shot trying to make up for it? One mistake quickly compounds into another, a bogey turns into a triple bogey, and your round spirals out of control.

Likewise, standing over a shot riddled with indecision - "Should I hit 6-iron or 7-iron? Maybe I should try to cut it around this tree" - creates tension and a weak, uncommitted swing. A good mental game is about making a clear decision, committing to it fully, and accepting the outcome without letting it derail the rest of your round.

How to Build Mental Consistency:

• Have a Simple Pre-Shot Routine: Make it the same every time. For example: Stand behind the ball and pick your target line. Take one or two relaxed practice swings feeling the shot you want to hit. Step up to the ball, set your club, take one last look at the target, and go. This focuses your mind and quiets the frantic internal chatter.
• Commit to Your Shot: Indecision is a swing killer. Once you've chosen a club and a target, fully commit. A bad plan executed with 100% commitment is often better than a perfect plan executed with 50% doubt.
• The 10-Second-Rule: After you hit a shot - good or bad - give yourself about 10 seconds to react. Celebrate the good one or feel the frustration of the bad one. Then, as you put the club back in the bag, you let it go - completely. Your focus immediately shifts to the next shot. One shot has no bearing on the next unless you allow it to.

Final Thoughts

Achieving consistency in golf isn't a mystery, it’s the result of building a repeatable foundation. By focusing on a consistent setup, a neutral grip, using your body as the engine, and understanding what creates solid contact, you eliminate the variables that cause those wild swings in performance. It takes mindful practice, but improving these core fundamentals is your most direct path a more reliable and enjoyable game.

Building those solid routines takes practice and getting clear feedback is vital in the process. When you’re on your own, it’s easy to slip back into old habits, and that's precisely where we designed Caddie AI to help. Instead of guessing your way through a tough decision on the course, you get instant, data-backed strategy, taking the uncertainty out of club choice or how to play a tough hole. Should you feel stuck after a round, you have a 24/7 coach you can ask anything - whether it’s about your grip or course management - to get straightforward answers that help you practice with purpose. It’s about building confidence one smart decision at a time.