Why Can't I Shallow the Golf Club?

If you're desperately trying to shallow the golf club but feel like you're just chopping down on the ball, you are not alone. It's one of the most common and frustrating problems in golf, one that turns promising swings into slices and weak contact. The good news is that coming over the top isn't a life sentence. This guide will walk you through exactly what shallowing means in simple terms, identify the real reasons you're struggling to do it, and give you practical drills to finally feel that professional-style drop into the slot.

What Does "Shallowing the Golf Club" Actually Mean?

Before we can fix the problem, we need to speak the same language. Forget complex talk about swing planes and degrees for a moment. At its core, shallowing the club is simply about changing the angle of the club shaft during the transition from the backswing to the downswing.

Imagine your backswing. As you reach the top, the club shaft is at a certain angle. Most amateurs start their downswing by moving their hands, arms, and shoulders *forward* towards the ball. This steepens the angle of the shaft, making it more vertical, like you're about to chop wood. This is the classic "over-the-top" move that leads to slices, pulls, and frustrating inconsistency.

Shallowing is the opposite. It's the move where, during that transition, the club head feels like it drops behind and below your hands. The angle of the shaft "lays down" or becomes flatter (more horizontal) relative to the ground. This move creates room for you to rotate your body freely and attack the ball from the inside, which is the secret to power, compression, and a desirable ball flight.

Think of it this way:

• A Steep Swing: Approaches the ball from out-to-in, like a guillotine. It cuts across the ball, imparts slice spin, and robs you of power.
• A Shallow Swing: Approaches the ball from in-to-out, like a discus thrower. It allows the club to sweep into the ball powerfully, promoting a draw and solid contact.

The Real Culprits: Why You Can't Get Shallow

Knowing you need to shallow the club is one thing, doing it is another. The desire is there, but a steep downswing is almost always a symptom of another problem. Trying to force the club to shallow without addressing the root cause is like trying to fix a leaning tower by painting it. Here are the most common reasons why your swing remains steep.

1. Your First Move Down is with Your Arms and Shoulders

This is offender number one. At the top of the backswing, there's a moment of truth. What moves first? For 99% of amateurs who struggle with a steep swing, the answer is the hands, arms, or upper body. They get anxious to hit the ball and aggressively throw the club "at" it from the top. This immediately forces the club into a steep, over-the-top path. The golf swing is a sequence, and starting with the upper body breaks that chain instantly.

The Fix: The downswing must start from the ground up. The very first move in transition should be a subtle shift of pressure to your lead foot, followed by the unwinding of your hips. This lower-body-led sequence creates the space and time needed for the club to naturally drop onto a shallower plane. The arms and club are the last things to fire, not the first.

2. Early Extension: The Killer of Shallow Swings

Have you ever seen a video of your swing and noticed that your hips and pelvis move towards the golf ball on the downswing? This is called "early extension," or as some coaches graphically put it, "humping the ball." It's incredibly common and disastrous for your swing plane.

When you start your downswing and your hips lunge forward, you stand up out of your posture. Your body is now much closer to the ball than it was at address. To avoid shanking the ball or hitting the ground a foot behind it, your brain instinctively reroutes the club. It picks the club up and throws it over the top on a steep path just to make contact. In this case, your steep swing is actually an athletic compensation for poor lower body movement.

The Fix: You have to maintain your posture and the space between your body and the ball. Focus on the feeling of your butt staying "back" and rotating behind you throughout the downswing, almost as if it's tracing the wall of a room. This keeps you in your spine angle and gives your arms and club the original space they had at address to swing through on an inside path.

3. An Incorrect Backswing

Sometimes the problem is baked in before you even start the downswing. One of the most common backswing flaws is "rolling" the clubface open and getting the club stuck too far behind you on the way back. When the club is too deep and the face is wide open at the top, the only way to feel like you can get the club back to the ball and square the face is to throw it over the top from the beginning of the downswing.

Another issue is lifting the arms without a proper body turn. If your backswing is all arms and no torso rotation, the club gets very vertical and out of sync with your body. From that lifted, disconnected position, the path of least resistance is often a steep chop down.

The Fix: Focus on a "one-piece" takeaway where your shoulders, arms, and club move away together. Feel like your chest is turning to face away from the target. This keeps the club "in front" of you and properly synced with your body rotation, setting you up for a much easier transition into a shallow plane.

Actionable Drills to Finally Shallow the Club

Reading about the move is great, but real change happens with practice and proper feelings. Here are three simple drills you can do to train the correct shallowing motion.

Drill 1: The Headcover Barrier

This provides immediate feedback on your swing path. It's simple but highly effective.

1. Take your setup addressing a golf ball.
2. Place a headcover (or a rolled-up towel) on the ground about six inches outside your ball and another six inches behind it. This creates a "barrier" on your typical over-the-top path.
3. Your task is to hit the ball without hitting the headcover.
4. If you come over the top, you'll hit the headcover - instant feedback. To miss it, you will be forced to drop the club into the slot and approach the ball from the inside. Start with half swings until you get the feel of it.

Drill 2: The Transition "Pump" Drill

This drill isolates the feeling of the club dropping in the transition without the pressure of hitting the ball.

1. Take your normal backswing to the top.
2. From the top, initiate the downswing motion by just using your lower body to slightly unwind and feel your arms and the club shaft "drop" back behind you. Only go about halfway down, just until the shaft is parallel to the ground.
3. Return to the top of your backswing.
4. Repeat this "pump" motion three times, really ingraining the feeling of the club laying down. The goal is to feel the weight of the clubhead fall, not pull it down with your hands.
5. After the third pump, go ahead and hit the ball while trying to replicate that dropping sensation.

Drill 3: The Motorcycle Feel

This is a pure feel drill that exaggerates the hand and wrist action required for shallowing.

1. Take the club to the top of your backswing.
2. For right-handed golfers, imagine you're holding the throttle of a motorcycle in your right hand. To shallow the club, you want to feel like you're "revving" the throttle. This means flexing your right wrist slightly so your palm faces more toward the sky.
3. For left-handed golfers, the feeling is more like your lead wrist is bowing slightly or pointing toward the ground.
4. This move subtly changes the geometry of your arms and wrists, causing the club shaft to lay down and the clubface to rotate into a stronger position. You will feel the clubhead move behind you. Once you get the a feel for it, you can hit shots by just focusing on that gentle revving motion at the start of your downswing.

Final Thoughts

Shallowing the golf club is a game-changer, transitioning you from an inconsistent slicer to a powerful, consistent ball-striker. Remember, a steep swing is just a symptom, so work on fixing the root causes - poor sequencing and early extension - using drills to train the correct feelings in the transition.

And when you're on the course or at the range trying to implement these changes, it can be tough to know if you're doing it right. I know that feeling of uncertainty. For those tough spots when you're not sure about your swing or need instant advice, a tool like Caddie AI can become an invaluable partner. When you have a question about swing mechanics, or even want feedback on a tricky lie by snapping a quick photo, we designed Caddie AI to give you an expert, personalized answer in seconds, helping you take the guesswork out of getting better.