Why Do Golf Shoes Have Flaps?

Ever noticed those fringed leather flaps covering the laces on a pair of classic golf shoes and wondered what they're really for? That distinctive feature, properly known as a kiltie, has a fascinating history rooted in both practical function and timeless golf fashion. This article breaks down exactly why they exist, how their purpose has changed over the years, and whether rocking this old-school look is right for your game today.

What Exactly Are Those Flaps on Golf Shoes Called?

The formal name for that fringed flap of leather is a kiltie. The term comes from its resemblance to the decorative flap on Scottish kilts, and given that golf’s origins are so deeply tied to Scotland, the connection makes perfect sense. These kilties were not just for show, they were a clever, functional piece of equipment for golfers of a bygone era.

You’ll see them almost exclusively on traditional, all-leather, brogue-style golf shoes - the kind that evoke images of golf legends like Ben Hogan and, more recently, Payne Stewart. While you might not see them on the latest athletic-style shoe from a major brand, they remain a powerful symbol of golf's classic heritage.

The Original Purpose: More Than Just Decoration

Long before golf courses were the perfectly manicured carpets we know today, they were much rougher affairs. Early morning rounds meant trudging through heavy morning dew, an adventure that could soak your feet before you even made the turn. The original golf shoe kiltie was developed to solve a few specific, nagging problems that golfers faced on these rustic links.

Keeping Debris and Moisture Out

The primary job of the kiltie was to act as a shield. It covered the shoe's tongue and laces, creating a barrier that did a surprisingly good job of keeping unwanted elements out. Think of it as a mudguard for your foot. It helped prevent:

• Water and Dew: In the pre-Gore-Tex era, leather was the best you had for water resistance. Still, moisture could easily seep in through the stitching around the tongue. The kiltie provided an extra layer of protection, diverting water away from this vulnerable area and helping to keep a golfer’s feet a little drier and more comfortable throughout the round.
• Dirt, Sand, and Grass: The kiltie also effectively blocked dirt, sand, and freshly cut grass clippings from getting inside the shoe. This wasn’t just a matter of comfort, gritty sand or dirt rubbing against your sock for 18 holes is a recipe for blisters and irritation.

By covering the top of the shoe, the kiltie was a simple yet effective piece of low-tech engineering designed to handle the unpredictable conditions of early golf courses.

Protecting the Shoelaces

The second key function of the kiltie was to protect the shoelaces themselves. In the past, laces were typically made from waxed cotton or raw leather. While sturdy, they were susceptible to the elements. They would get caked in mud, absorb water, and become weak and prone to snapping. A broken lace in the middle of a round was a real nuisance.

The kiltie acted as a protective cover, shielding the laces from abrasion, moisture, and grime. This extended their life and kept them cleaner, making them easier to tie and untie after a messy round. It was a practical solution that saved golfers a small but significant headache.

From Function to Fashion: The Kiltie's Evolution

So if a kiltie was such a great idea, why don’t all modern golf shoes have them? The answer lies in the incredible advancements in shoe technology. The practical problems that kilties were designed to solve have largely been eliminated by better materials and smarter design.

• Waterproof Technology: Modern golf shoes often feature waterproof membranes like Gore-Tex, which are built directly into the shoe's lining. This technology makes the entire shoe waterproof from the inside out, rendering the external protection of a kiltie obsolete.
• Gusseted Tongues: Many high-quality shoes now use a "gusseted" or "bellows" tongue, which means the tongue is stitched to the sides of the shoe's upper. This design creates a seamless barrier that effectively seals out water and debris without needing an extra flap.
• Durable Laces: Today's a's shoe laces are made from resilient synthetic fibers that are far more resistant to water, dirt, and wear than the organic materials of the past.

As these technological improvements took hold, the kiltie’s functional role faded away. However, it didn't disappear. Instead, it transformed into a purely stylistic element - a symbol of something more profound. It became a powerful icon of traditional golf fashion, a nod to the game's rich history and classic aesthetic. For players like the famously dapper Payne Stewart, the kiltie was an essential part of a signature look that championed golf's heritage in an era of increasing modernization.

Should You Wear Golf Shoes with Kilties Today?

For the modern golfer, choosing a shoe with kilties is all about personal style and what you want to communicate on the course. There are compelling reasons for and against it, and the right choice is entirely up to you.

The Case for Rocking the Kiltie

Choosing to wear a kilted shoe is a deliberate style choice. Here’s why some golfers love them:

• Timeless Style: Let’s be honest, they just look cool. When paired with classic trousers and a sharp polo, a pair of traditional kilted golf shoes creates a sophisticated, timeless look that stands out. It shows you appreciate the finer points of golf’s history and dress code.
• Setting Yourself Apart: In a world filled with sneaker-like golf shoes, a kiltie is a conversation starter. It’s a unique look that says you’re not just following the latest trends.
• A Nod to Tradition: Wearing a kiltie is a way of connecting with the history of the game. It’s an homage to the legends who walked the fairways long before us. For some, this connection adds another layer of enjoyment to the experience.

The Arguments Against the Kiltie

Of course, the classic look isn’t for everyone. Some valid points against the kiltie include:

• Potentially Dated Look: For some players, the kiltie just feels old-fashioned. It can look out of place if the rest of your outfit is very modern and athletic, like joggers and a blade-collar shirt. Style is subjective, and this look might not align with yours.
• Extra Maintenance: While minor, the kiltie is another surface that can collect dirt and morning dew, meaning it's one more thing to wipe down and clean after your round.
• Limited Availability: Far fewer brands produce kilted golf shoes today. You'll primarily find them from classic, high-end shoemakers, which often come with a higher price tag and may not feature the same lightweight performance technology as the top athletic models.

Making the Kiltie Work for You

If you're intrigued by the idea of an old-school kiltie but aren't ready to commit fully, you're in luck. The best feature of most modern kilted golf shoes is that the kiltie is removable. It's simply held in place by the shoelaces.

This gives you incredible versatility. You can keep the kiltie on for a round with your buddies at the historic club and then easily remove it for a different, more streamlined look the following week. To do this, you just unlace the shoe, slide the kiltie off, and re-lace the shoe as you normally would. It essentially gives you two styles in one pair of shoes.

Styling-wise, kilties look best when they’re part of a coherent, classic outfit. They pair perfectly with traditional golf trousers (like slacks or tailored chinos) and classic shorts. They create a deliberate, polished look that respects the rich traditions of the sport.

Final Thoughts

That fringed flap on old-school golf shoes, the kiltie, began its life as a brilliantly practical solution to the messy conditions of early golf courses. It kept golfers' feet drier and protected their equipment, but has since transformed into a beloved symbol of golf's distinguished heritage. Today, choosing to wear them is a personal statement - a way to blend a deep appreciation for the game's history with your own on-course style.

Much like understanding a small detail like a kiltie enriches your appreciation for the game, getting a clear 'why' behind your on-course decisions can transform your play. Often, we get stuck with tricky shots or unusual lies where the best course of action isn't clear, leading to frustrating mistakes. We built Caddie AI to be that instant, rational second opinion in your pocket. From getting a smart tee-shot strategy to analyzing a photo of a tough lie in the rough, it provides simple, expert guidance to eliminate guesswork so you can step up to every shot with confidence.