Let's get right to it: yes, you can absolutely have two putters in your golf bag. As long as you don't carry more than the maximum of 14 clubs, the rules don't care what combination of clubs you use. This article will break down the official rule, a few reasons why you might consider this unconventional setup, the major pros and cons, and a quick guide on how to smartly implement it if you decide it's right for your game.
The best AI golf app: Caddie is your personal AI golf coach. Get expert-level golf advice instantly, 24/7 to help you play like a pro. Try it free →
The Official Rule: Are Two Putters Legal?
The first thing most golfers want to know is whether this is even allowed. It can feel like you're trying to pull a fast one, but the governing bodies of golf, the USGA and R&A, are completely fine with it.
The relevant regulation is Rule 4.1b (Limit of 14 Clubs). This rule states that you must not start a round with more than 14 clubs or have more than 14 clubs during the round. That's it. The rule makes no specific distinctions about the types of clubs you can carry.
In the eyes of the rules, a putter is just another club. A driver is a club. A 7-iron is a club. A sand wedge is a club. As long as the total number in your bag is 14 or fewer, you could theoretically carry 14 putters and be perfectly within your rights (though your score probably wouldn't appreciate it).
So, the legality isn't the real question. The more important question is: should you carry two putters? And that's where the strategy comes into play.
Get pro-level golf advice instantly, 24/7
Ask Caddie anything. From “what club should I use?” to “how do I play this shot?” and get instant answers.
Should You Carry Two Putters? The "Why" Behind the Decision
Putting can feel like a game within a game, and sometimes a single tool just doesn't feel right for every situation. While most golfers stick with one trusted flat stick to build consistency, there are a few practical reasons why a two-putter system might be tempting.
Taming Different Green Speeds
This is probably the most common justification. The greens at your regular, budget-friendly course might be drastically different from the slick, glass-like surfaces at a private club or tournament venue. One day you're hammering putts just to get them to the hole, the next, you're just trying to breathe on the ball to get it started.
For Slow Greens: A lighter putter with a firm, milled face can help you feel like you can make a more aggressive stroke without the ball rocketing past the cup.
For Fast Greens: A heavier putter with a soft insert can help quiet your hands, promote a smoother stroke, and get the ball rolling gently.
Having a "slow green putter" and a "fast green putter" can give you a lot of confidence when you play a variety of courses.
The "Specialist" Approach: Tackling Different Types of Putts
Another popular strategy involves using different putters for different jobs on the green. This often comes down to long putts versus short putts.
For Long Putts (Lag Putting): Some players feel more comfortable using a heavy mallet or even a long/broomstick putter for putts outside of 30 feet. The extra mass can make it easier to deliver a smooth, pendulum-like stroke without getting handsy or jerky, helping you to control distance much more effectively. Your goal here isn't to make it, but to leave a stress-free tap-in.
For Short Putts: On the shorter putts that really matter for your score, some golfers prefer the feel and responsiveness of a traditional blade-style putter. They feel it gives them more precise feedback and control for those nervy three-footers. It's all about what gives you the most confidence when you absolutely, positively have to get the ball in the hole.
The Mental Game Lifeline
Let's be honest - putting is deeply psychological. When you're in a slump, your trusty flat stick can suddenly feel like a foreign object in your hands. Every putt feels doomed before you even start your stroke.
In this scenario, a second putter acts as a mental reset button. If your primary putter has betrayed you three holes in a row, the ability to switch to your "backup" can break that negative mental spiral. In your mind, it's not you that's the problem, it's the putter. Giving it a timeout and bringing in a substitution can be a powerful psychological trick to get you back on track.
Plan every shot like a pro
Describe your situation and Caddie AI helps you pick your target, shot shape, and club with confidence.
Weighing Your Options: The Pros and Cons of the Two-Putter Setup
Before you rush to the golf shop, it's important to understand the full picture. Carrying two putters comes with some real benefits, but also one massive drawback that can't be ignored.
The Advantages of Carrying Two Putters
Versatility: You have a purpose-built tool for multiple scenarios, whether it's navigating lightning-fast downhillers or lagging a bomb on a shaggy green.
Increased Confidence: If you truly believe your mallet is the best lag putter for you and your blade is money from inside 10 feet, you'll stand over each of those putts with more positive thoughts.
A Mental 'Eject' Button: As mentioned, it provides a crucial escape route during a bad putting round, potentially saving you from a total on-course meltdown.
The Disadvantages (And They Are Significant)
The Sacrificial Lamb: This is the big one. If you add a second putter, you must remove another club to stay at the 14-club limit. Which one goes? Your highest-lofted wedge you rely on for delicate greenside shots? A fairway wood that is your go-to on long par 4s? The hybrid you depend on to escape trouble? This decision is not a small one, and gapping your clubs correctly is important for your long game. Losing a versatile club at the top or bottom of your set can leave you with awkward distances that you simply can't cover.
Decision Paralysis: Having options is good, but too many options can be paralyzing. Standing over a 20-foot putt and thinking, "Hmm, is this a job for the mallet or the blade?" introduces doubt right when you need unwavering commitment. If you don't have super strict rules for which putter to use when, you can end up second-guessing yourself on every putt.
Hindering "Feel": World-class putters often talk about "becoming one with their putter." They use the same flat stick so often that its weight, balance, and feel are deeply ingrained. By constantly switching between two different putters, you may stop yourself from ever truly mastering one and developing that subconscious, automatic feel.
A Short-Term Fix, Not a Long-Term Solution: Often, using two putters is a band-aid covering up a fundamental flaw in your putting stroke or mental process. Instead of working on your speed control with one putter, you just switch to another one. This can stop you from putting in the focused practice that leads to real, lasting improvement.
Play Golf like a Pro with Caddie
Learn and improve your golf game as you play. Get pro-level tips, strategy and guidance anytime.
Making It Work: How to Smartly Implement a Two-Putter System
If you've weighed the pros and cons and still think a two-putter system could benefit your game, here's how to do it without torpedoing your scores.
Step 1: Get Specific on the "Why"
Don't just add a second putter because you're having a bad week. Identify the exact problem you're trying to solve. Write it down. Is it: "I three-putt constantly on fast greens"? Or: "I yip every putt inside four feet"? The more specific your problem, the better you can select a second putter to solve it.
Step 2: Choose Radically Different Putters
Don't just carry two similar blade putters. The two putters in your bag should feel and perform very differently. The goal is to make the decision of which one to use as black-and-white as possible. Think in terms of opposites:
A heavy mallet vs. a light blade
A center-shafted model vs. a heel-shafted model
A long/broomstick putter vs. a standard-length putter
A face-balanced putter vs. a toe-hang putter
Step 3: Make the Hard Sacrifice
Go through your bag and be brutally honest about which club you can live without. A good way to do this is to track your club usage for 5-10 rounds. Which club do you hit the least? Is there a big yardage gap between two clubs that you could solve by hitting one of them softer? For many, the club to go is either a long iron (like a 4-iron if you have a 4-hybrid) or a specialized wood (like a 5-wood if you can hit your 3-wood different distances).
Step 4: Create Strict Rules and Practice Them
This is the most important step for avoiding decision paralysis on the course. Before you ever put the system into play, you need to create your own personal set of "regulations." For example:
"I use the long putter for *every* putt outside the length of the flagstick. No exceptions."
"I use the blade putter for *every* putt inside that distance."
"I only use the 'ol reliable' Ping Anser. But if I have 3 three-putts in a round, it goes in timeout and my Spyder comes in for the rest of the day."
Whatever your rules are, stick to them. Go to the putting green and practice with this system until the decision of which putter to pull becomes completely automatic.
Legally putting two putters in your bag is simple, the strategic part is much more complicated. While it can be a clever solution for very specific challenges on the greens, you have to be honest about the major trade-off you're making by giving up another valuable club.
Making a smart, evidence-based decision about your club setup, like figuring out which club to sacrifice for a second putter, can feel like guesswork. That's why I can be a helpful partner on and off the course. You can use Caddie AI to analyze your shot data and see exactly which clubs you're using and which ones are just taking up space, giving you the confidence to make a data-driven choice for your bag. My goal is to take the uncertainty out of these decisions so you can play smarter.
Spencer has been playing golf since he was a kid and has spent a lifetime chasing improvement. With over a decade of experience building successful tech products, he combined his love for golf and startups to create Caddie AI - the world's best AI golf app. Giving everyone an expert level coach in your pocket, available 24/7. Caddie's mission is simple: make world-class golf advice accessible to everyone, anytime.
Other posts you might like
Can You Remove Golf Grips Without Damaging Them?
Yes, you can absolutely remove a golf grip without damaging it, but it requires the right technique, a little patience, and the right tools. For any golfer who likes to tinker with their equipment or save a great-feeling grip when making adjustments to a club, learning this skill is a game-changer. This guide will walk you through exactly how it's done, from the pro-level method using compressed air to an effective alternative you can use at home.
Tired of looking at snow-covered fairways or feeling the winter chill seep into your bones? That itch to play golf in February is perfectly normal, and the great news is, you absolutely can. This guide will walk you through the best sun-drenched U.S. and international destinations for a winter golf escape, and I’ll even share some practical tips for braving a round in the cold if a trip isn’t on the cards this year.
Planning a golf trip to Ireland but dreading the thought of dragging your clubs across the Atlantic? Here’s the straightforward answer: you don’t have to. You can absolutely rent high-quality golf clubs in Ireland, and it’s a remarkably common and easy process. This article will walk you through exactly where you can rent clubs, what the process looks like, how much it costs, and how to pick the right set for tackling Ireland's legendary links.
Thinking about playing a private golf course can feel like trying to get into an exclusive club with a secret handshake. But gaining access isn’t just for a select few. With the right knowledge and a bit of initiative, you can find yourself teeing it up on some of the most beautifully manicured and sought-after courses. This guide will walk you through the practical, actionable strategies you can use to make it happen, turning that dream round into a reality.
A standard round of 18 holes is often scheduled for four and a half hours, but the reality for most of us is closer to five hours or even more on a busy weekend. This article breaks down exactly why rounds get so slow and gives you a practical, coach-approved playbook for speeding up your pace without rushing your swing. You’ll learn how to save time between shots, allowing you to play faster, feel more athletic, and often, score better.
Challenging the course in 30-degree weather isn't just possible - it can be a truly rewarding experience, as long as you go in prepared. Forget just hoping for the best, playing well in the cold requires a specific strategy for your body, your equipment, and your expectations. This guide will walk you through everything you need to know to not just survive but enjoy your round in frosty conditions.
