What Does 5 and 4 Mean in Match Play Golf?

If you have ever settled in to watch thrilling team events like the Ryder Cup or Solheim Cup, you’ve likely heard the announcers declare that a match has ended 5 and 4 and found yourself completely lost. Don't worry, you aren't alone. This unique scoring system is the heart of match play golf, a format that turns a typical round into a head-to-head duel. This guide breaks down exactly what 5 and 4 means, how match play scoring works, and how you can use this knowledge to become a formidable match play competitor.

First Things First: Match Play vs. Stroke Play

Before we can understand the numbers, we need to understand the game. The vast majority of golf you see and play is likely stroke play. In stroke play, you are competing against every other player in the field, and your goal is to post the lowest total score for the round. Every single stroke counts, from the first tee shot to the final putt. A disastrous triple bogey on one hole can wreck your entire scorecard.

Match play, on the other hand, is a completely different beast. It’s a one-on-one battle played hole by hole. Think of it less like a marathon and more like a series of 18 individual boxing rounds. The total number of strokes for the entire round doesn’t matter. All that matters is winning more individual holes than your opponent.

In match play, you could make a 10 on a par 4. Your opponent could make a 5. In stroke play, you just lost five shots to them on one hole. In match play? You lost the exact same amount as if they had made a 4 and you had made a 5. You only lose one hole. This fundamental difference is what makes the psychology and strategy of match play so compelling.

How is Match Play Scored? The Basics

Forget adding up your total score. In match play, the scoreboard is tracked relative to your opponent. The standing of the match is always described in one of three ways:

• "Up": You have won more holes than your opponent. If you've won two more holes than they have, you are "2 up."
• "Down": Your opponent has won more holes than you. If they have won one more hole, you are "1 down."
• "All Square" (A/S): The match is tied. You have both won the same number of holes.

Here’s how a match progresses:

1. You and your opponent play the first hole. The player with the lower score wins that hole.
2. Let's say you make a 4 and your opponent makes a 5. You win the hole. The match status is now "1 up" for you.
3. On the second hole, you both make a 4. This is called "halving" the hole. When a hole is halved, the score of the match doesn't change. You remain "1 up."
4. On the third hole, your opponent makes a 3 and you make a 4. They win the hole. Your "1 up" lead is canceled out, and the match returns to "All Square."

This process continues throughout the course. You tally hole victories, not total strokes, with the score constantly adjusting as you battle for each hole.

Breaking Down the '5 and 4': What It Actually Means

Now we get to the heart of the matter. When you hear a result like "5 and 4," it's just a shorthand way of describing when the match officially ended. The rule is simple:

The first number represents a player's lead in holes. The second number is how many holes are left to play.

If a player becomes up more than there are holes left to play, the match is over. So, a result of "5 and 4" means that one player was 5 holes up with only 4 holes remaining. At that moment - standing on the 15th tee having completed the 14th hole (18 holes - 4 remaining = 14 holes played) - the match is mathematically over. Even if the trailing player won every single remaining hole, they could only win back 4 holes, but they are 5 holes behind. They can't possibly close the gap. It's a knockout.

Let's look at a few more common examples to understand this.

Example 1: The "2 and 1" Victory

This is a common match that ends late. A "2 and 1" result means that one player was 2 up with 1 hole to play.

Let's consider the situation. You are 2 up as you finish playing the 17th hole. Only one hole left (the 18th). At that moment, you have officially won the match "2 and 1" because your lead (2 holes) is greater than the number of holes remaining (1 hole). It's impossible for your opponent to erase it. They would be 1 down at best if they win the 18th. So the match officially ends on the 17th green, and your victory is a "2 and 1".

Example 2: A "1 Up" Win

It can't get much closer. A match went the full distance - all 18 holes - with the winning player only "1 up" with 0 holes to play once the 18th has been completed. This means they had to win or tie the final hole to secure this victory. A "1 up" victory signifies a very tight contest.

The two players fought all the way to the end. If it was all square playing the 18th, winning that hole would result in a "1 up" margin of victory. It signifies a hard-fought battle to the end in the final round.

Example 3: A Blowout - The "8 and 7"

This score signifies complete and utter domination. The player was 8 holes up with only 7 holes left to play. The handshakes would have happened on the 11th green (18 holes - 7 remaining = 11 holes played). In less than three hours, the match was over, and the winner could head to the clubhouse early. This kind of victory can make for a long, lonely ride back for the loser.

Talk Like a Match Play Pro: Other Key Terms

To really get a feel for the format, you should know a couple more pieces of lingo that are unique to match play.

Dormie: The Point of No Return

When a player is "dormie," the match reaches a crucial point. Dormie occurs when a player has a lead equal to the number of holes left to play. For example, if you're 3 up with 3 holes left to play, you become "dormie."

To put it another way, at that point, the trailing player must win every single remaining hole just to tie the match. If they tie (halve) even one hole while dormie, the match is over. The pressure is immense. When you get your opponent to dormie, you've backed them into a corner with almost no way out.

For example, if you're 3 up on the 16th tee (with 3 holes left to play), you're dormie.

Concessions: The Art of the 'Gimme'

Have you ever seen two players just "give" each other their putts? It happens all the time in match play. It's called a concession. A concession is when one player acknowledges that the other player would have made their putt, and they don't want them to go through the motions. It can be on a short putt, a tap-in, or even a short chip shot. An opponent might concede a putt if the ball is so close to the hole that they'd be silly not to have conceded it.

How Knowing the Score Changes Your Strategy

This is where match play becomes a fascinating game of chess on grass. Your strategy on every single shot should be influenced by the score of the match.

When You're UP in the Match

Your Mindset: Protective. Conservative. Make your opponent beat you.

When you have a lead, especially late in the match, your objective shifts. You no longer need to make birdies, you just need to make pars and avoid mistakes. The pressure is on your opponent to do something spectacular. You should aim for the safe side of fairways and the middle of greens. You're trying to force halves. If you're 2 up with 4 holes to play and your opponent pulls driver on a narrow par 4, your smart play is to hit an iron or hybrid into the fairway. Make them execute their risky shot perfectly. If they fail, you win the hole by just being in position.

When You're DOWN in the Match

Your Mindset: Aggressive. Desperate. Go for broke.

When you're behind, conservatism will get you nowhere. You have nothing left to lose. It's time to take on that tucked pin, flirt with that water hazard, and try to drive the green on that short par 4. A bogey loses you the hole just as cleanly as a catastrophic double bogey does. So you have to aim for a winning score - often birdie or better. If you're 2 down with 3 holes to play, playing for par might not be good enough. You have to push the envelope and create opportunities to win holes outright.

When the Match is All Square

Your Mindset: Opportunistic. Balanced.

When the match is tied, your strategy is more nuanced. Early on, you can simply play your normal game and look for an opening. However, late in an all-square match, you need to be very observant of your opponent. If they hit a poor tee shot into trouble, you might opt for a more conservative play to guarantee a par and likely win the hole. If they pipe one down the middle, you might need to be a little more aggressive with your approach to match their potential birdie. It becomes a hole-by-hole calculation of risk and reward.

Final Thoughts

Match play serves up a completely different flavor of golf, turning every round into a direct, personal competition. Understanding its unique scoring format, where "5 and 4" simply describes a knockout victory on the 14th hole, is the first step. Once you grasp the language, you unlock a deeper level of strategy where every shot is shaped by the current state of the match, creating a compelling mental challenge from the first tee to the final winning handshake.

Navigating the strategic twists of a match can be intense, especially when you're 2 down and trying to figure out if you should go for that sucker pin. We wanted to take the doubt out of those critical decisions, which is why we built Caddie AI. In a tough spot, you can get instant, on-course advice for your shot or a smart strategy for the hole, helping you choose whether to play aggressively or conservatively with expert backing. It’s like having a tour-level caddie making the calls right alongside you, giving you the confidence to execute when it matters most.