Ever tuned into a pro tournament or overheard chatter at your local club about medal play and just nodded along, not fully certain what it meant? You're not alone. Medal play is a fundamental format in golf, and grasping what it is completely changes how you approach the game. This guide will clarify exactly what medal play is, how it's different from other formats, and provide you with a coach's perspective on the strategy you need to succeed in it.
What is Medal Play in Golf? The Straightforward Answer
In the simplest terms, medal play is just another name for stroke play. It is the most common form of golf played around the world, from the PGA Tour to your Saturday morning round with friends.
Here’s the core concept: you play a round of 18 holes, and you count every single stroke you take. Every putt, every chip, every swing - even the whiffs and penalty strokes - they all get added up. Your final number at the end of the round is your score. The player with the lowest total score is the winner.
Think of it as the golf equivalent of a 10k race. In a race, you are judged by your total time from start to finish. In medal play, you are judged by your total score from the first tee to the 18th green. It’s a measure of your total performance over the entire round. In a formal competition, this format rewards the most consistent and skilled player over 18, 36, or 72 holes.
A Quick History Lesson: Why "Medal"?
The name "medal play" has simple, historic roots. For centuries, club golf competitions were played for a physical prize. The most prestigious monthly competition at many golf clubs was often for, you guessed it, a medal. The format used for these prestigious events was stroke play, where every shot counted towards victory. Over time, the format itself became synonymous with the prize, hence the term "Medal Play" and the very common "Monthly Medal" competition you’ll find at clubs everywhere.
Medal Play vs. Match Play: Understanding the Two Granddaddies of Golf Formats
To truly understand medal play, it’s essential to contrast it with golf’s other primary format: match play. While both involve hitting a golf ball into a hole, the mindset, strategy, and even the pressure feel completely different.
The Anatomy of Medal Play (Stroke Play)
In medal play, you are essentially competing against the golf course and the entire field of players simultaneously. Every stroke has the same weight, whether it’s your first drive on hole #1 or your final putt on hole #18.
- Every Shot Counts: A 10-foot putt for birdie on the 3rd hole is just as important as a 3-foot putt for bogey on the 17th. There are no "throwaway" strokes.
- One Bad Hole Can Be Damaging: This is a major defining characteristic. Scoring a 9 on a par-4 is disastrous. That high score stays on your card and you have to spend the rest of the round trying to recover from it. It's a weight that you carry with you.
- Focus: Your complete attention is on managing your total score. You worry less about what your immediate playing partners are doing and more about posting the lowest number you possibly can.
The Anatomy of Match Play
Match play is a head-to-head battle. You are playing against a single opponent, and the goal is to win more individual holes than they do. A round is a series of 18 separate, one-hole contests.
- Hole-by-Hole Scoring:If you make a 4 and your opponent makes a 5, you win the hole. Your score on the scoreboard is now "1 up." If you both make a 4, the hole is "halved" (tied), and the score remains the same. The total stroke count doesn't matter, only who won the hole.
- Big Numbers Are Forgivable: This is the beautiful, liberating part of match play. Let’s say you hit two shots out of bounds and end up with a 10 on a par-4. Your opponent makes a simple par 4. What’s the damage? You just lose the hole and go "1 down." That’s it. That terrible "10" is gone forever. You can walk to the next tee with a clean slate.
- Focus: Your entire strategy is based on what your opponent is doing. If they hit their tee shot into trouble, you might play more conservatively. If they stuff their approach shot to two feet, you might have to take a bigger risk to try and match them.
The Mental Game: How to Strategize for Medal Play
As a coach, this is where I see golfers make the biggest gains. Shifting your mindset from 'how do I make a birdie?' to 'how do I avoid a double bogey?' is the foundational secret to scoring well in medal play. It’s a marathon, not a sprint, and your strategy should reflect that.
Embrace 'Boring' Golf
The champion of a medal play tournament is often the player who was the most boringly effective. They didn't necessarily hit the most spectacular shots, but they certainly hit the fewest catastrophically bad ones.
What does boring golf look like?
- Aim for the Middle of the Green: See that pin tucked behind a deep bunker on the right side of the green? Ignore it. Your target isn't the pin, it's the fat, safe center of the putting surface. A 30-foot putt for birdie is a far better outcome than being short-sided in a bunker with no green to work with.
- Clubbing for the Back Edge: When in doubt, take one extra club for your approach shots. Most amateurs come up short of the green, leaving them tricky chips. Playing for the back of the green provides a margin for error. A slight mishit might still land on the front, while a purely struck shot leaves you with a putt - both good outcomes.
- Two-Putts Are Your Friend: The goal on the green isn't necessarily to make every putt. It's to never three-putt. On long putts, focus entirely on pace. Get the ball into a three-foot circle around the hole - what we call the "friendship circle" - and you can tap in with no stress. A scorecard full of two-putt pars is a beautiful thing in medal play.
Damage Control is Everything
Bad shots are inevitable. The best medal players are masters of damage control. They accept a bad shot, assess their new situation calmly, and make the smartest decision to prevent a bad hole from becoming a disaster.
Scenario: You've pushed your tee shot on a par-4 deep into the trees on the right. You can see a tiny, one-in-a-million gap through the branches back towards the green.
- Match Play Brain: "I have to try for this green to save par and try to win the hole." You take the hero shot, it hits a branch, and ricochets deeper into trouble. Your 4 becomes a 7 or an 8.
- Medal Play Brain: "The green is not the prize here. The fairway is the prize." You take your medicine, grab a wedge, and calmly chip the ball sideways back into the fairway. You now have a clear shot for your third. You play onto the green, two-putt, and walk away with a bogey 5.
That bogey is a victory. You've saved two or three strokes over the hero shot. Over 18 holes, making one or two of these smart, conservative decisions is a huge difference maker.
Scoring in Medal Play: Gross vs. Net Explained
When you enter a club's "Monthly Medal," you'll almost always see two types of winners: one for the Gross score and one for the Net score. Understanding the difference is vital for understanding competitive amateur golf.
Gross Score
This is as straightforward as it gets. Your gross score is the actual number of strokes you took to complete the round. If you hit the ball 88 times, your gross score is 88. This is how professional golfers are scored, and it recognizes the player who had the best "unassisted" round of golf that day.
Net Score
This is what makes golf competitions fair and fun for players of all skill levels. Your net score is your gross score minus your course handicap. The handicap system is designed to be the great equalizer in golf.
Let's look at an example to see how it works:
- Player A: Has a 10 handicap. They shoot a fantastic round of 82 (Gross Score). To calculate their net score, you subtract their handicap: 82 - 10 = 72 (Net Score).
- Player B: Has a 22 handicap. They shoot a solid round of 93 (Gross Score). To calculate their net score, you do the same math: 93 - 22 = 71 (Net Score).
In this medal play competition, even though Player A shot 11 strokes better in gross terms, it's Player B who wins the net competition because they played better relative to their own average ability. This system allows a 22-handicapper to have a legitimate and exciting competition against a friend who is a 10-handicapper.
Final Thoughts
At its heart, medal play is the purest accounting of your aolf game. It’s you against the course, with every single shot contributing to the final result. Adopting a medal play mindset requires patience, disciplined strategy, and an ability to manage the highs and lows of a round, prioritizing consistency and avoiding big mistakes above all else.
Knowing the right strategy is one thing, but executing it under pressure on the course is a different challenge. That’s really why we built our app. When you're standing on a new tee box or facing a weird lie, you can consult Caddie AI for personalized, strategic advice. It can analyze the situation, whether from your description or a photo of your ball's lie, and give you a smart recommendation that helps you avoid those scorecard-wrecking holes. Think of it as having a tour-level strategic coach in your pocket, helping you make the unemotional, smart decisions that lead to lower medal play scores.