Trying to figure out where your golf game stacks up as a high school player can feel overwhelming. You see incredible scores online and wonder, What does the average high school golfer actually shoot? This article will give you a straight, no-nonsense answer. We’ll break down the scoring numbers for different levels of high school golf, look at what college coaches are recruiting for, and give you a simple, actionable plan to lower your own scores.
The Straight Answer: What Is an "Average" Score?
If we poll every single high school golfer in the country - from the freshman who just made the team to the senior captain - the true "average" 18-hole score would likely fall somewhere between 90 and 105. For 9 holes, which is the format for most high school matches, that average is around 45 to 52.
But let's be honest, that number doesn't tell the whole story. The term "average" is tricky because the skill level on a high school golf team can vary dramatically. The last player on the junior varsity team has a very different scoring expectation than the #1 player competing for a state title. Averages are a starting point, but understanding the different tiers of players is far more helpful for figuring out where you stand and what you should be aiming for.
Breaking Down the Averages: From JV to Varsity Star
High school golf isn't a one-size-fits-all world. Your "target score" really depends on your role on the team and your personal goals. Here’s a more realistic look at scoring expectations based on skill level.
The Beginner or First-Year Player
Typical Score (18 holes): 100+
If you're new to the team or the sport, the goal isn't breaking 80. It's about learning the fundamentals, understanding the rules, and getting comfortable playing in a competitive setting. At this stage, scores in the high 90s or over 100 are completely normal. The focus should be on making consistent contact, reducing the number of lost balls, and avoiding three-putts. Every round is a learning experience.
The Junior Varsity (JV) Player
Typical Score (18 holes): 88-98
The JV team is the heart of most high school programs. These players have solid fundamentals but are working on consistency. A JV golfer likely shoots in the 90s, with good days dipping into the high 80s and tough days climbing over 100. For a 9-hole match, they’re usually posting scores between 44 and 49. They have moments of brilliance mixed with a few blow-up holes that inflate their scores. The primary goal for a JV player is to eliminate an 8 or a 9 score on the card by playing smarter golf.
The Solid Varsity Player
Typical Score (18 holes): 80-87
This is your reliable varsity starter. They consistently break 90 and regularly post scores in the low-to-mid 80s. A 9-hole score is typically in the 40-43 range. They possess a more well-rounded game, have a decent short game, and understand course management. They might not be on the radar of top college programs, but they are a vital asset to their high school team, contributing a counting score in almost every match.
The College-Bound Golfer
Typical Score (18 holes): 72-79
This is the team's ace. This player consistently shoots in the 70s. They don't just play well, they compete well. Their misses are manageable, they have multiple ways to score around the greens, and they can handle the pressure of tournament golf. For a 9-hole match, they are regularly at or below 40, often shooting in the 30s. The score they shoot with their friends isn't what defines them - it's their tournament scoring average that matters.
What Scores Do College Coaches Actually Look For?
If your goal is to play golf after high school, your tournament scoring average is your resume. Coaches want to see how you perform under pressure, on challenging courses, over multiple days. Here’s a general guide to what different college levels are looking for.
- NCAA Division I: Top D1 programs are looking for players with tournament scoring averages of 74 or lower. These players are typically winning or finishing in the top 5 of major state and regional junior tournaments. Mid-major D1 programs might look for players with averages in the 74-77 range. Consistency is the name of the game. A coach would rather see a player who shoots 75-75 than one who shoots 70-80.
- NCAA Division II: Strong D2 programs often recruit players with tournament averages in the 76-79 range. This is an extremely competitive level, and top players are more than capable of competing with D1 talent. Showing you can consistently break 80 on tough courses is a great target.
- NCAA Division III &, NAIA: The range here is wider. Top-tier D3 programs (like Methodist, Emory, or Carnegie Mellon) recruit players with scores similar to D1 and D2 programs (low-to-mid 70s). Other solid D3 and NAIA programs might find great talent in the high-70s to low-80s. This level provides a fantastic opportunity to continue your athletic career while focusing on academics.
Remember: These are just guidelines. Coaches also look at academic performance, character, and potential for improvement. A great score is only part of the equation.
Forget Averages - Focus on Your Own Improvement
Comparing yourself to a vague "average" isn't going to help you shoot lower scores. The best golfers focus on their own game. It’s not about finding a magic move, it’s about making smart, measurable progress. Here’s a simple four-step plan to get started.
Step 1: Track Your Key Stats (The Right Way)
Your final score is a result, not a process. To understand your game, you need to look deeper. For your next five rounds, forget your total score and track these four numbers instead:
- Fairways Hit: Did your tee shot end up in the fairway? Yes or No.
- Greens in Regulation (GIR): Did your approach shot land on the green? Yes or No. (Par 3s: on in 1, Par 4s: on in 2, Par 5s: on in 3).
- Putts Per Round: How many total putts did you take?
- Penalty Strokes: How many shots did you add for out-of-bounds, water hazards, etc.?
After a few rounds, your weaknesses will become obvious. If you're only hitting 3 Fairways and taking 38 putts, you know exactly what to work on. This is how you stop guessing and start improving.
Step 2: Practice with Purpose
Simply hitting a large bucket of balls at the range with your driver won't cut it. Your practice needs to be structured and simulate the pressures of the course.
- Short Game First: 70% of your practice time should be from 100 yards and in. Become an expert with your wedges and your putter. Practice landing chips on specific spots, not just getting them "close." For putting, work on speed control with lagging drills from 30-40 feet.
- Play Games Against Yourself: Don't just hit shots. Create scenarios. Try the "Par 18" chipping game: pick 9 spots around the green and try to get up-and-down from each one. Anything under 18 strokes is a great score. This builds pressure and focus.
Step 3: Play Smarter, Not Harder (Course Management)
High school golfers often lose the most strokes to poor decisions, not poor swings. Big numbers kill your score, and good strategy is all about avoiding them.
- The Goal is "Boring Golf": Aim for the middle of the fairway. Aim for the center of the green. Try to two-putt every time. Chasing sucker pins tucked behind a bunker is how you make a double bogey. A boring par is your best friend.
- Know Your Misses: Every golfer has a typical miss. Is it a fade that becomes a slice? A hook that ducks left? Understand your tendency under pressure and aim accordingly. If you tend to miss right, aim down the left center of the fairway to give yourself room for error.
- Have a "Go-To" Shot: When you're standing on a tight tee box and feeling the pressure, you need a shot you can trust. often this is a 3-wood or a hybrid instead of a driver. A shot that you know will find the fairway, even if it’s 20 yards shorter, is more valuable than a big drive into the trees.
Step 4: Compete As Much As You Can
Shooting 78 with your friends is great, but shooting 82 in a tournament with a shaky start is often more impressive to a coach. Playing tournament golf is a skill in itself. Sign up for local junior tours (like the Hurricane Junior Golf Tour, AJGA, or your state's golf association events). Learning how to manage your nerves, grind when you don't have your best stuff, and post a score is what separates good players from great competitors.
Final Thoughts
The "average" high school golf score is a wide-ranging number that shifts based on team role and individual experience. Instead of getting caught up in that number, the best path forward is to track your own stats, practice with purpose, and learn to manage your way around the course to develop the consistency that truly defines a good golfer.
Breaking down a challenging hole or trying to decide how to play a weird lie in the rough can feel like you're on your own. My goal with Caddie AI is to give you that expert second opinion right in your pocket. You can get a simple, smart strategy for any hole on the course or even snap a picture of a tough shot get an instant recommendation, taking the guesswork out of the game so you can play with more confidence and commit to every swing.