What Is a Gimme in Golf?

A gimme in golf is that friendly tap-in putt your buddy tells you to pick up, often accompanied by a casual gesture and the words, That’s good. This article will go through what a gimme is, the nuanced etiquette surrounding it, and how it fits within the official Rules of Golf. You'll learn the unwritten rules for giving and receiving gimmes so you can handle these situations with confidence and keep your friendly rounds fun and moving along.

What Exactly Is a "Gimme"? A Closer Look

In simple terms, a gimme is a short putt that another golfer concedes to you. By conceding the putt, they are saying, “I am certain you would have made that, so for the sake of time and friendship, let's just count it as made and move on.”

This is a purely informal agreement, a piece of golfing culture born out of a desire to speed up casual rounds and relieve some of the nerve-wracking pressure on those tiny, must-make putts. It's a hallmark of friendly matches between partners, weekend four-balls, and any round where bragging rights are more important than a handicap score. However, it's vital to remember that the gimme exists outside the official rules of individual stroke play. It has no place in a tournament or any round you intend to post for your handicap.

How Far Is a Gimme? The "Inside the Leather" Debate

The most common, age-old yardstick for a gimme is “inside the leather.” This refers to the length of a standard putter from the club head to the bottom of the leather (or rubber) grip. If your ball is closer to the hole than that distance, it's generally considered a candidate for being a gimme.

But this isn't a hard-and-fast rule. A two-foot putt "inside the leather" can be very different depending on the circumstances:

• A straight, flat two-footer: Almost always a gimme in a friendly game.
• A downhill, breaking two-footer: You might be asked to putt this one out, even if it's short. These are notoriously easy to miss.
• Your opponent’s skill level: If you're playing with someone who is a fantastic putter, you might give them longer gimmes. Conversely, if a player has been struggling on the greens, you might be less generous.

Ultimately, the gimme is a social contract. Its length and frequency are determined by the specific group you’re playing with and the nature of the game. The key is to establish a consistent precedent early in the round. If you give a two-footer on the first hole, you should probably be giving similar putts for the rest of the day.

The Unwritten Rules: Gimme Etiquette 101

While not a formal part of the game, a very real etiquette exists around gimmes. Handling these situations smoothly shows you're a knowledgeable and considerate golfer. Here’s how to navigate them.

Giving a Gimme

The grace of the gimme lies in how it's offered. Follow these simple guidelines to do it right:

• Be Proactive and Clear: The best time to give a gimme is as soon as the player's ball comes to rest near the hole. Don't make them sweat or stand over the ball wondering. Use clear, simple language like, "That's good," "Pick it up," or just, "Good." A clear gesture toward the ball works, too.
• Don't Give a Teammate's Gimme: In a team game, each player should generally concede their opponent's putts. It can be seen as poor form to give a gimme on behalf of your partner, especially if the putt matters.
• Hold Back Early On: In more competitive friendly matches, many golfers prefer to have everyone putt everything out on the first hole or two. This sets a baseline for the match and avoids any early misunderstandings.

Receiving a Gimme

When someone offers you a gimme, how you react is just as important.

• Acknowledge and Accept Quickly: A simple "Thanks" is all that's needed. Pick your ball up immediately.
• NEVER "Practice" a Gimme: This is a major a breach of etiquette. Once a putt has been conceded, the play is over. Knocking the conceded putt toward the hole anyway can imply that you think your opponent misjudged and that you might have missed. It can come across as ungrateful or even a bit arrogant. Just pick up your ball and move on.
• Don't Ask! Never, ever ask, "Is that good?" It puts your opponents in an incredibly awkward position. Assume every putt is one you have to make until a player explicitly tells you otherwise. If you're left wondering, just go through your routine and prepare to putt. More often than not, they'll stop you if they intended to give it to you.

The Psychology of the Missed Gimme

There's a fascinating mental dynamic at play with gimmes. Conceding a short putt is a gesture of goodwill that relieves stress. Conversely, not conceding a very short putt can amplify the pressure exponentially.

Imagine your opponent has a 20-inch putt. In a casual round, it would be 'good' 99% of the time. But if you’re in a tense match and your opponent makes you putt it, suddenly that short putt feels like it’s 10 feet long. The hole shrinks, your hands get tight, and the possibility of missing becomes very real.

This is a strategic - and sometimes ruthless - part of match play. Withholding an expected gimme is a quiet way of saying, "I'm going to make you earn everything today." It tests your opponent's nerve. If they miss, it can be a huge mental victory for you and a crushing blow to their confidence.

On the flip side, be careful what you wish for. Consistently relying on gimmes in casual play can make your short putting lazy. When you finally find yourself in a situation where youmust hole out, like in a club competition, you won't have the mental resilience or repetitive practice to knock in those crucial 2- and 3-footers with confidence.

Match Play vs. Stroke Play: Where Gimmes Officially Count

This is the most important distinction in the entire discussion of gimmes. How they are treated depends entirely on the format of golf you are playing.

Match Play: A Legitimate Strategy

In match play, you are playing against a single opponent (or a team of two) to win individual holes. The total score doesn't matter, only who won more holes. In this format, conceding a stroke or a putt is a strategic tool, outlined explicitly in Rule 3.2b of the Rules of Golf.

You can concede your opponent’s next stroke at any time, and once you do, it cannot be undone. An opponent can pick up their ball, and the stroke is counted as holed.

Why would you concede a putt in match play?

• To Speed Up Play: If your opponent has a two-footer to tie the hole, there is often no point in making them putt it.
• To Apply Pressure: You might generously concede a few short putts early on. Later in the match, on a critical hole, you might make them putt one of the same length to test their nerves.
• When a Putt Is Irrelevant: If you are already lying 5 on the green and your opponent has a three-foot putt for a 4 to win the hole, you should concede it immediately. Making them putt it serves no purpose and slows the game down.

Stroke Play: Every Shot Counts

Stroke play is the format where every single stroke is tallied to produce a final score for 9 or 18 holes. This is the format used for most tournaments and for posting scores for handicap purposes.

In stroke play, there is no such thing as a gimme. The Rules of Golf are unequivocal: to complete a hole, your ball must be holed out. Picking up your ball after being "given" a putt means you have not completed the hole and cannot post that score for your handicap.

If you're playing a casual game that mixes friendly match-play wagers with a score you intend to post, you must ignore any offered gimmes and tap the ball in. It may feel a little awkward to reject a friendly gesture, but just explain politely, "Thanks, but I need to putt this out for my handicap." Any true golfer will understand and respect that completely.

Final Thoughts

The "gimme" is one of golf's friendliest traditions, designed to maintain pace of play and reduce stress in casual rounds. Understanding the unwritten rules of when to offer, when to accept, and how to behave will make you a more respected playing partner. Just remember the crucial distinction between match play, where it's a strategic part of the game, and stroke play, where every putt must find the bottom of the cup.

We know golf has many of these traditions and nuanced rules that can be confusing, and knowing when a gimme is proper is just scratching the surface. That is why we built Caddie AI. For those moments on the course when you're faced with a tough ruling, want to know the right etiquette, or need a smart strategy for a tricky shot, you can get a clear, immediate answer. It's about taking the guesswork out of the game so you can play smarter and with much more confidence.