Golf Tutorials

What Is a Good Putter for the Average Golfer?

By Spencer Lanoue
July 24, 2025

If you're looking to shave strokes off your score, a good putter is your best friend. A great drive and a perfect approach shot mean very little if you end up with a dreaded three-putt. This guide is here to walk you through exactly what makes a putter good for you, moving beyond brand names and marketing hype. We’ll cover the main types of putters, how to identify your putting stroke, and the key features you should look for to match a putter to your game.

Good Putting Starts with Confidence, Not Just a Club

Putting accounts for roughly 40% of the strokes in an average round of golf. Think about that for a second. It's the one club you will almost certainly use on every single hole. This is why finding the right putter isn't just about owning the latest technology, it's about finding a club that gives you unshakable confidence when you're standing over the ball.

We’ve all been there: a fantastic drive and a crisp iron shot leave you with a 15-footer for birdie. You feel the pressure, your hands get a little shaky, and that confident feeling starts to fade. Having a putter in your hands that feels stable, looks right to your eye, and is designed to work with your natural stroke can be the difference between making a nervous jab and a smooth, deliberate roll. The goal isn't just to buy a "good" putter, it's to find your putter, one that makes you feel like you can sink anything.

The First Big Choice: Blade vs. Mallet Putters

The first and most important choice you'll make is between the two main categories of putters: blades and mallets. They look different, they feel different, and they are generally designed for two different types of putting strokes.

The Classic Blade Putter

A blade putter has a simple, traditional, and narrow clubhead. Think of the classic putters you’ve seen in grainy black-and-white photos of golf legends. They offer a great deal of feel and feedback, meaning you can really feel where you've struck the ball on the face. Because of their design, the weight in the clubhead is distributed more towards the heel and toe, but they are generally less forgiving on off-center hits than their mallet counterparts.

  • Best For: Golfers with an "arcing" putting stroke. This means the putter head swings on a slight inside-to-square-to-inside path, much like a mini full swing. The face naturally opens on the way back and closes on the way through.
  • Look For: If you identify as an arc-stroke putter, you’ll want a blade with some degree of "toe hang." If you balance the shaft on your finger, the toe (the far end of the putter head) will hang down towards the ground. This design helps the face rotate open and closed smoothly throughout the stroke.

The Modern Mallet Putter

A mallet putter features a much larger, heavier clubhead that comes in all sorts of shapes and sizes, from semi-circles to futuristic designs that look like spaceships. Their main advantage is stability and forgiveness. The larger size andperimeter weighting mean that even if you strike the ball slightly off-center (towards the heel or toe), the putter face is less likely to twist, helping the ball roll straighter and truer. Most mallets also feature very prominent alignment aids (lines, dots, or shapes) to help you aim the face squarely at your target.

  • Best For: Golfers with a "straight-back, straight-through" putting stroke. These players try to keep the putter face square to the target line throughout the entire motion, with minimal rotation.
  • Look For: If this sounds like you, you’ll benefit from a "face-balanced" mallet. When you balance the shaft on your finger, the face of the putter will point straight up to the sky. This construction resists face rotation, making it easier to maintain that straight path.

Find Your Stroke: The Simple Drill to Understand Your Natural Motion

Alright, so how do you figure out if you have an "arc" or a "straight" stroke? You don't need a high-tech putting lab, you can do this simple drill at home on your carpet.

The Putting "Track" Drill:

  1. Find a straight putt of about 6-8 feet. If you're on a carpet, just pick a target.
  2. Place two alignment sticks (or two other golf clubs) on the ground, parallel to your target line. Create a "track" for your putter head that's just a little bit wider than the putter itself.
  3. Place a ball in the middle and make ten putting strokes. Don't try to force anything - just make your natural, comfortable stroke. Pay close attention to how the putter head moves in relation to the track.

What did you notice?

  • Did the heel of your putter occasionally touch the back stick on the backswing, and the toe touch the front stick on the follow-through? If you noticed the face seeming to open and close slightly as it moved, you have an arcing stroke. A blade putter with toe hang would be a fantastic place for you to start.
  • Did your putter move straight back and straight through down the track, staying perfectly inside the rails without touching either one? Did the face seem to stay perfectly square to your target line the whole time? If so, you have a straight-back, straight-through stroke. A face-balanced mallet will likely be your best friend.

Knowing this one thing about your game is more valuable than any product review or brand name you'll ever read. You're now equipped to match your equipment to your motion, not the other way around.

Other Putter Features to Consider

Once you’ve decided between a blade and a mallet and know whether you need toe hang or a face-balanced model, there are a few other elements to consider that will dial in your feel and performance.

Face Technology: Milled vs. Insert

The face of the putter is where the magic happens. What it's made of dramatically changes how the ball feels at impact.

  • Milled Faces: A milled face is crafted directly from a solid block of metal (usually stainless steel). It provides a firmer, more direct feel and sound. Players who prefer a lot of feedback and have a good sense of pace often lean toward milled faces.
  • Face Inserts: An insert is a separate piece of material placed on the putter's face. These are often made from softer materials like urethane or other polymers. They provide a softer, quieter feel at impact and can help get the ball rolling more quickly with less skid, which helps with distance control. If you often play on very fast greens or just prefer a muted feel, an insert is a great option.

Putter Length: The Critical Foundation

This is arguably the most overlooked - and most influential - part of a putter fitting. A putter that is too long or too short will force you into an uncomfortable and inconsistent posture. A putter that's the correct length allows your arms to hang naturally from your shoulders, lets your eyes get directly over the ball, and promotes a pendulum-like stroke without tension.

A quick way to estimate your ideal length: Get into your athletic putting stance. Let your arms hang completely loose and relaxed. Measure the distance from the top of your hands to the floor. This measurement will be very close to your ideal putter length. Most standard off-the-rack putters are 34 or 35 inches, which is often too long for many average golfers.

Grip Size and Style

The putter grip is your only connection to the club. Modern grips come in a huge variety of sizes and shapes.

  • Standard or Pistol Grips: These are thinner and often allow for more "feel" and release of the putter head with your hands.
  • Midsize & Oversize (Jumbo) Grips: A thicker grip has one goal: to quiet your hands and wrists. If you find your hands get too "active" or twitchy, especially on short putts, a larger grip can engage the larger muscles in your shoulders and arms, promoting a more stable and less handsy stroke.

Don't be afraid to experiment. A new grip is a cheap and easy way to completely change the feel of your current putter before buying a whole new one.

Final Thoughts

Finding a good putter for an average golfer isn't about the price tag or what the pros are using. It’s about a simple process of discovery: understanding your unique putting stroke and then selecting the style (blade or mallet), balance (toe-hang or face-balanced), and components (length, grip) that complement your natural motion and give you the most confidence.

Gaining confidence on the greens is a huge step, and the same principle applies to the rest of the course. With knowledge comes freedom from doubt. For all those other moments of uncertainty - what club to hit from an awkward lie, how to play a tricky hole, or just getting a smart strategy on the tee - we developed Caddie AI. It gives you 24/7 access to an expert golf coach right in your pocket, providing the real-time advice you need to play smarter, simplify your decisions, and ultimately, feel more confident over every shot.

Spencer has been playing golf since he was a kid and has spent a lifetime chasing improvement. With over a decade of experience building successful tech products, he combined his love for golf and startups to create Caddie AI - the world's best AI golf app. Giving everyone an expert level coach in your pocket, available 24/7. His mission is simple: make world-class golf advice accessible to everyone, anytime.

Other posts you might like

How to Throw a Golf Tournament Fundraiser

Thinking about hosting a golf tournament fundraiser is the first swing, executing it successfully is what gets the ball in the hole. This guide will walk you through the entire process, step-by-step, from laying the initial groundwork months in advance to watching your happy golfers tee off. We’ll cover everything from securing sponsors and setting your budget to planning the on-course fun that makes an event unforgettable.

Read more
card link

What Is a Golf Handicap?

A golf handicap does more than just give you bragging rights (or a reason to demand strokes from your friends) - it’s the game’s great equalizer and the single best way to track your improvement. This guide breaks down what a handicap is, how the supportive math behind a handicap index a is, and exactly how you can get one for yourself. We’ll look at everything from Course Rating to Adjusted Gross Score, helping you feel confident both on the course and in the clubhouse.

Read more
card link

What Is the Compression of a Pinnacle Rush Golf Ball?

The compression of a Pinnacle Rush golf ball is one of its most defining features, engineered specifically to help a huge swath of golfers get more distance and enjoyment from their game. We'll break down exactly what its low compression means, who it's for, and how you can use that knowledge to shoot lower scores.

Read more
card link

What Spikes Fit Puma Golf Shoes?

Figuring out which spikes go into your new (or old) pair of Puma golf shoes can feel like a puzzle, but it’s much simpler than you think. The key isn't the brand of the shoe, but the type of receptacle system they use. This guide will walk you through exactly how to identify your Puma's spike system, choose the perfect replacements for your game, and change them out like a pro.

Read more
card link

How to Use the Golf Genius App

The Golf Genius app is one of the best tools for managing and participating in competitive golf events, but figuring it out for the first time can feel like reading a new set of greens. This guide cuts through the confusion and shows you exactly how to use the app as a player. We’ll cover everything from logging into your tournament and entering scores to checking the live leaderboard so you can enjoy the competition without any tech headaches.

Read more
card link

How to Not Embarrass Yourself While Golfing

Walking onto the first tee with sweaty palms, worried you’ll be a good partner to paly wtih...or even asked back again ...We’ve all been there - trust me! The real trick of feeling confortable... is about how you handle you’re ready to plsy. THIS guide explains the simple rules of the rode to show you hnow t play golf while staying calm relaxed and focused... an having much morse fun while you,',re aat it? You'll also play with confidence a dn make fiendsa while you're at i

Read more
card link
Rating

Instant advice to help you golf like a pro

Just ask a question or share a photo and Caddie gives personalized guidance for every shot - anytime, anywhere.

Get started for free
Image Descrptions