What Is Modified Scotch in Golf?

Tired of the same old weekend four-ball? Modified Scotch is a fantastic two-person team format that blends strategy, teamwork, and a unique twist that keeps every hole interesting. It's a game that reduces pressure, speeds up play, and will have you and your partner working together like tour pros. This guide will walk you through exactly how to play, offer some killer strategy to help you win, and show you why it might just become your new favorite way to play golf.

What Exactly Is Modified Scotch?

Modified Scotch, often called "Greensomes" in other parts of the world, is a two-person team game that combines the excitement of everyone hitting a drive with the strategic challenge of alternate shot golf. It's the perfect middle ground between playing your own ball and the unforgiving nature of a pure alternate shot match.

Here’s the basic flow:

• Both players on a team hit a tee shot.
• They then choose the single best tee shot out of the two.
• From that point, they play alternate shot until the ball is in the hole.

The beauty of this format lies in that second step. It takes the gut-wrenching pressure off the tee shots. In a standard Scotch Foursomes (or pure alternate shot) game, if your partner hits a truly terrible drive, you’re stuck with the consequences. In Modified Scotch, a bad drive is instantly forgiven if the other partner finds the fairway. This keeps morale high and makes the game far more approachable and enjoyable for golfers of all skill levels.

It’s a game of leveraging strengths. You're not just playing golf, you're actively managing your team's assets on every single hole.

The Step-by-Step Rules of Modified Scotch

Understanding the rules is simple, but there's одном key detail about the second shot that often trips up new players. Let’s break it down in order so you never get it wrong on the course.

1. Both Players Tee Off

Just like it sounds. On every hole, both Player A and Player B on a team will hit their own tee shot. This is a big part of the fun - everyone stays in the rhythm of the game and gets to hit a driver (or whatever club they choose) on every tee box.

2. Choose the Best Drive

After both players have hit, you walk or drive up to the balls. As a team, you survey the situation. Which ball is in the best position? "Best" doesn't always mean longest. You might choose the ball that's 20 yards shorter but sitting perfectly in the fairway over one that’s longer but in the first cut of rough with an awkward angle to the pin.

3. Pick Up the Unused Ball

Once you’ve made your decision, pick up the ball that you decided against. From this point forward, you will only play one ball for the rest of the hole. This is what helps speed up the pace of play so significantly compared to a four-ball best-ball match.

4. Play the Second Shot (The Important Part!)

Here’s the rule you have to get right: The player whose tee shot was not used plays the second shot.

Let's run through an example:

• Player A hits their drive into the right fringe of the fairway.
• Player B hits a beauty right down the middle, 20 yards past Player A.
• The team unanimously agrees to play Player B’s ball.
• Because Player B's drive was chosen, Player A must hit the second shot.

This is the great equalizer of the format. You can't just have your long bomber hit every drive and your great iron player hit every approach. The game forces you to deal with different a different sequence on every hole.

5. Continue with Alternate Shot

After that crucial second shot, you continue alternating shots until the ball is holed. Following our example above:

• Player A hits the second shot (the approach).
• Player B would then hit the next shot (the first putt).
• Player A would hit the second putt.
• And so on, until the ball is in the cup.

You record one score for the team on each hole. At the end of the round, you simply add up your totals. It's that easy!

Why You Should Play Modified Scotch

If you haven't tried this format yet, you're missing out on some of the most dynamic and enjoyable golf you can play. Here are a few reasons why it's so popular.

• It's Fun and Less Stressful: The "safety net" of having two tee shots is a tremendous relief. It eliminates the fear of hitting one wild drive that ruins the hole and puts your partner in a terrible spot. This alone makes the game more relaxing and fun.
• Faster Pace of Play: While you have two balls in play off the tee, you're only playing one ball from the second shot onward. This makes it significantly faster than a four-ball, where four players are hitting shots all the way to the green.
• Perfect for All Skill Levels: This is arguably one of the best formats for pairing a skilled golfer with a less experienced one. The better player's consistent drives can provide a good safety net, while the higher handicapper can feel like a hero when they pipe a drive and their ball gets chosen. It allows both players to contribute meaningfully.
• Promotes Teamwork and Strategy: You quickly realize that golf becomes a team sport. The conversations you have on each hole - "What club are you comfortable with from 150?" or "I know my drive is shorter, but it gives you a clear look at the flag" - are what make the format truly special. You start thinking about setting your partner up for success, not just your own shot.

Winning Strategy for Modified Scotch

Playing Modified Scotch well is about more than just hitting good shots. It's about thinking as a team and making smart decisions together. Here's some coaching advice to give you an edge.

Choosing Your Partner

The best Modified Scotch teams often complement each other. A classic pairing is a Long Hitter and a Short Game Specialist. The long hitter's job is to give the team great birdie opportunities on par-5s, while the sharp short-game player can clean up from there. Another effective pairing is a "bomber" and a "plotter." One player can be aggressive off the tee, knowing their partner is consistent and likely to find the fairway, giving the team a good backup option.

Tee Shot Strategy: Longest is Not Always Best

Resist the temptation to always choose the longest drive. A shot from 150 yards in the center of the fairway is often light-years better than a shot from 135 out of thick rough, under a tree, or with a bad angle to a tucked pin.

The smartest question to ask when deciding is: "From which spot are we most likely to make par... or better?"

Also, consider who is hitting the next shot. If your partner absolutely loves their 9-iron, a drive that leaves them at their favorite 9-iron distance could be the much wiser choice, even if it’s 15 yards shorter than your ball.

Approach Shot Mentality

The player whose drive was benched now faces what is often the most important shot of the hole: the approach. The key here is to play the high-percentage shot. Don't feel you have to be heroic and gun for a flag tucked in a front-right corner behind a bunker. Your job is to get the ball on the putting surface to give your partner a good look at birdie or a simple two-putt for par.

Aim for the middle of the green. This simple strategy takes pressure off, dramatically reduces your chances of a "big miss," and is the foundation of smart team golf.

Communication is Everything

The best teams talk constantly (but efficiently). Before choosing a ball, talk it out. Don't just point and say, "Let's play yours." Discuss it.

• "My drive is great, but it leaves you a tricky downhill-sidehill lie. Your drive has a perfectly flat lie from 10 yards further back. What do you prefer?"
• "This hole has water short and right. My drive gives you an angle from the left, taking the water completely out of play. Let's go with that one."

Once a decision is made, you must both fully commit to it. No "I told you we should have played my ball" after a poorly struck approach. You're a team - you succeed and fail together.

Variations and Handicap Calculations

While the rules are straightforward, you might encounter slight variations. As mentioned, it's often called Greensomes in the UK and a Pinetree Scotch Foursome in some clubs.

Handling handicaps is necessary for fair competition. There isn't a universally mandated formula, but the most common one is a blend of the two players' course handicaps:

Take 60% of the lower-handicap player's course handicap and add 40% of the higher-handicap player's course handicap.

Example:
Player A has a 12 handicap.
Player B has a 24 handicap.
The team handicap would be: (0.60 x 12) + (0.40 x 24) = 7.2 + 9.6 = 16.8.
You would round this to 17. The team gets 17 strokes for the round.

Check with your club or tournament host for their specific rules, but this 60/40 formula is a reliable standard for a balanced game.

Final Thoughts

Modified Scotch is an incredible format that offers the perfect blend of individual contribution and team strategy. It encourages communication, smart course management, and provides a safety net that makes the game more enjoyable for everyone involved. If you're looking for a fresh, engaging, and faster way to play team golf, give it a try your next time out.

Executing that team strategy and making those confident decisions on the course is what separates the winning teams. When you and your partner are weighing which drive to take or what your approach shot should be, having an expert opinion can be a game-changer. That's actually why we designed Caddie AI. It can help you think through tough lies and tricky situations by providing instant strategic advice. Having that extra layer of confidence will help your team commit to a play and execute the shot without any doubt.