Trying to figure out what you should be shooting in golf can be one of the game's biggest mind games, often leading to more frustration than positive motivation. This article cuts through the noise and provides a clear, practical roadmap for setting realistic scoring goals, whether you're just getting started or you're trying to break 80 for the first time.
Good Scores Are Relative, Not Absolute
Before we go any further, let's get one thing straight: comparing your weekend score to what you see on the PGA Tour is a recipe for disappointment. Professionals are playing a completely different game under different conditions. A "good" score is entirely personal and depends on your experience, how often you play, and what your individual goals are. The single best measure of a successful round for any amateur golfer is shooting at or below your handicap. That means if you're a 22-handicap and you shoot a 94 on a par 72 course, that's equivalent to a tour pro shooting par. It’s a great day! Chasing an arbitrary number is frustrating, chasing improvement is empowering. With that in mind, let's break down realistic milestones for different skill levels.
The First Victories: Scoring Goals for New Golfers
If you're new to the game, welcome! This is the most exciting - and sometimes perplexing - stage. Your main goal right now isn't about the final score on the card, it's about making small bits of progress and, most importantly, enjoying yourself enough to come back.
Milestone 1: Enjoy the Game and Make Solid Contact
Seriously. Your first several rounds shouldn't even have a score. You are learning a new, complex athletic movement. The goal is to celebrate the small wins:
- Making solid contact that gets the ball airborne.
- Hitting a drive that finds the fairway (or at least the first cut of rough!).
- Getting a chip to land on the green.
- Advancing the ball down the hole without hitting it backwards or sideways.
At this stage, a "good score" is simply a fun round where you hit a handful of shots that made you smile. Don't add up the numbers, it doesn't represent your potential.
Milestone 2: Breaking 120
Once you’re making contact more consistently, breaking 120 is a fantastic first scoring goal. Think about what this means: a score of 119 on a par 72 course is an average of 6.6 strokes per hole. This is mostly getting triple-bogeys with a few double-bogeys mixed in. This is 100% achievable.
How to get there:
- Simplify Your Goals on Each Hole: Forget about par. Your "personal par" is a triple-bogey. If you can make a 6 on a Par 3, a 7 on a Par 4, or an 8 on a Par 5, you are on track. This reframes the entire hole and reduces pressure.
- Avoid Penalty Strokes: Your number one job is to keep the ball in play. This means choosing a club off the tee that you are confident won't slice into the woods or hook into the water, even if it's a 7-iron instead of a driver. An ugly 150-yard shot in the fairway is infinitely better than a beautiful 250-yard drive that’s lost.
- Focus on Advancing the Ball: When you're in trouble, don't try the hero shot. Just get the ball back to the fairway. The goal is to get it onto the green in as few additional strokes as possible.
Milestone 3: The Classic Goal of Breaking 100
Ah, breaking 100. This is probably the most celebrated milestone in amateur golf. Shooting a 99 means you’re averaging 5.5 strokes per hole. If you make a double-bogey on every single hole, your score is 108. That means you only need to find a way to turn nine of those double-bogeys into bogeys over 18 holes to shoot 99. When you frame it like that, it feels much more manageable.
How to get there:
- Eliminate the "Other" on the Scorecard: To break 100, you need to get rid of the 8s, 9s, and 10s. This isn't about making more pars, it's about making your worst holes a double-bogey instead of a quadruple-bogey.
- Fall in Love with Your Pitching Wedge: A huge number of strokes for a 100+ shooter are lost from 50 yards and in. Spend time just learning to chip the ball onto the green. You don't need a fancy flop shot, a simple, repeatable chipping motion will save you countless strokes.
- The 2-Putt is Your Friend: The goal isn't to make every putt. The goal is to eliminate 3-putts and 4-putts. Focus on getting your first putt, your lag putt, close to the hole - think inside a three-foot circle. From there, your chances of making the second one are very high.
The Next Level: Scoring Goals for the Bogey Golfer
You’ve broken 100a few times and are now consistently shooting in the 90s. Welcome to the "Bogey Golfer" club (a player with around an 18 handicap). Your mission, should you choose to accept it, is to start converting some of those bogeys into pars and break 90.
Milestone 4: Breaking 90
Shooting an 89 is a huge accomplishment. This score means you are averaging just under a bogey per hole (a 4.9 average on a par 72). A great way to visualize this is to aim for a scorecard of nine pars and nine bogeys. That's it. Suddenly, making a bogey doesn’t feel like a total failure, it's part of the plan.
How you get there:
- Course Management becomes Your Superpower: The enemy of breaking 90 is the blow-up hole. At this level, you need a strategy. This means not automatically pulling driver on every hole. It means playing away from hazards and aiming for the fat part of the green, not at every pin. Smart, conservative play is how you avoid the dreaded triple bogey.
- Master the 100-Yard Shot: Get to know your full-swing yardage for your pitching wedge and sand wedge. Being able to confidently hit the green from 100 yards out turns a potential double-bogey into a routine two-putt par.
- Track Your Stats: Start noticing simple things. How many fairways did you hit? How many greens did you hit in regulation? How many putts did you have? This data doesn't lie. If you find you’re only at 3 GIR but have 40 putts, your time is better spent on the a practice green, not the driving range.
Entering elite Company: Scoring goals for the Advanced Golfer
You're consistently in the 80s now. You’re becoming a genuinely good golfer. But you have your eyes set on the next a big prize: breaking 80.
Milestone 5: Breaking 80
A score in the 70s puts you in a small percentage of golfers worldwide. A 79 on a par 72 is seven-over-par. To achieve this, you need a game with very few major weaknesses. This isn't about hitting more spectacular shots, it's about razor-sharp execution and almost completely eliminating dumb mistakes. A round of 79 could be 11 pars and 7 bogeys. It could also include a birdie or two, which then gives you more wiggle room for bogeys elsewhere.
How you Get there:
- Wedge Game Precision: From 120 yards and in, you're not just trying to hit the green anymore - you're trying to hit a specific section of the green to leave yourself a makeable birdie putt. This requires knowing your distances with every wedge to the exact yard.
- Develop a Go-To Tee Shot: You need one shot you can rely on under pressure to find the fairway. Maybe it’s a knockdown driver, a "fairway-finder" 3-wood, or even a driving iron. Whatever it is, you need to trust it when the out-of-bounds stakes are staring you in the face.
- Scrambling is a Skill a Scrappy Short Game: You will miss greens. Breaking 80 requires the ability to turn a missed green into a straightforward up-and-down for par. Chipping and putting a aren't just for saving bogeys anymore, they’re for stealing pars you don’t deserve.
- Mental Toughness: At this level, how you handle adversity is everything. One bad shot cannot lead to another. You must have a process for letting go of a mistake and focusing completely on the very next shot.
Understanding these milestones allows you to set a meaningful target. Instead of getting frustrated trying to shoot par, you can focus on the specific skills needed to get from 105 to 95, or from 88 to 82. That's how real, lasting improvement happens.
Final Thoughts
Ultimately, what you "should" shoot in golf is an intensely personal question with no single right answer. By setting goals in these digestible stages - from breaking 120, to 100, 90, and 80 - you create a practical ladder for improvement that keeps the game fun and rewarding.
As you focus on improving your course management to reach these goals, having a smart strategy is just as fundamental as your swing itself. We built Caddie AI to act as your on-demand caddie and coach, helping you make smarter decisions on the course that directly lead to better scores. It can give you a clear game plan for a tricky par 5, recommend a club for a tough approach, or even analyze a photo of your lie in the rough to recommend the wisest shot, helping to eliminate the kind of guesswork that leads to blow-up holes so you can just focus on your swing.