Heard someone on your foursome mention getting a bagel and had no idea if they were talking about breakfast or a bad shot? You’re not alone. A bagel in golf is purely a slang term for scoring a zero on a hole, specifically within certain team game formats. Far from being a total failure, understanding the bagel is the first step to playing smarter team golf. This article will break down exactly what it means, the games where you’ll encounter it, and how consciously taking a bagel can actually be a strategically brilliant move for you and your partner.
What Exactly Is a "Bagel" in Golf?
In the simplest terms, a bagel is a score of “0” on a hole. The name comes from what you’d expect - the shape of the number zero looks just like a bagel. It’s important to know that this isn’t an official term you’ll find in the USGA Rule Book. It’s part of the rich vocabulary of golf course slang that’s passed between players, often causing a bit of confusion for those new to different formats.
A player "earns" a bagel when their score on a particular hole is so high that it will no longer count toward their team’s score. Instead of grinding over a five-foot putt for a triple-bogey - filled with frustration and embarrassment - a player realizes their score is irrelevant and simply picks up their ball. On the team’s scorecard for that hole, let’s say a four-ball, their partner might have a '4' written down, while there's just a dash or a '0' next to their own name. That '0' is the bagel. It’s not a mark of shame, often, it’s the sign of a savvy golfer putting the team first.
When Do Bagels Happen? Game Formats Explained
You’ll only ever encounter the bagel in team-based golf. If you’re playing your own ball in a standard stroke-play tournament or a one-on-one match play competition, you have to hole out on every green. There’s no picking up. Bagels come into play when your score directly intertwines with a partner's.
Four-Ball (also known as Better Ball or Best Ball)
This is the most common format where bagels appear. Here’s how it works: you and a partner play as a team, but you both play your own golf ball from tee to green on every hole. At the end of the hole, you compare scores, and the lower of the two scores becomes the team score. This is literally the "best ball."
- Scenario: You and your partner are on a par 4. Your partner hits a great approach shot and taps in for a solid par (a score of 4). Meanwhile, you’ve had a tougher go. You hit your drive into the trees, punched out, bladed your third shot over the green, and now you’re lying 4, still in the fringe. Rather than chipping on and grinding out two putts for a messy 6 (a double-bogey), you can look at your partner, get a nod, and just pick up your ball. Their par is already the best ball. You take the bagel, your team marks down a 4, and you move to the next tee with a clear head.
Best Two-Balls-of-Four
This is a common group game you might see in a member-guest or charity tournament. Your foursome is one team, and on each hole, the two lowest scores from the group are combined to make the team score. With four players in the mix, there’s even less pressure on any one individual.
- Scenario: You’re playing a par 5. Player A in your group makes a fantastic birdie (4). Player B taps in for par (5). The team already has its two required scores. Player C is staring down a long bogey putt, and Player D, after a disastrous tour of the sand traps, is lying 6. Both Player C and Player D can pick up their balls without a second thought. Their scores won’t count. Player D gets the certified bagel, and the team moves merrily along.
Scrambles: The Shot Bagel
Scrambles are a bit different, as the team only has one score on each hole. However, you can still apply the bagel concept to individual shots. In a four-person scramble, every player hits a tee shot, the team chooses the best one, and all four players hit their next shot from that spot. This process continues until the ball is in the hole. After one player hits a perfect drive down the middle of the fairway, the other three players on the team are free to swing for the fences. If their aggressive swing lands them in the water, it makes no difference. They essentially "bagel-ed" that shot, but the team is unharmed because they use the safe ball in the fairway.
The Unspoken Etiquette: Why Taking a Bagel is Often a Good Idea
Many golfers initially resist the idea of picking up. It feels like giving up or admitting defeat. But in team golf, taking a bagel is often the most considerate and strategic thing you can do. It's a fundamental part of playing as a partner, not an individual.
1. It’s Great for Pace of Play
This is the number one reason to embrace the bagel. Nothing slows down a round of golf more than players grinding out high scores that have no bearing on the outcome. When your partner is already in with a net-par, taking an extra two or three minutes to hole out for a triple-bogey is disrespectful to their good play and holds up the group behind you. Picking up is a courtesy to everyone on the course.
2. It Protects Your Mental Game
Golf is a game of momentum and confidence. Hitting four or five bad shots in a row on a single hole can be incredibly frustrating. That frustration from holing out for an 8 can easily bleed into your mindset on the next tee box, causing you to rush your routine or swing with tension. By picking up, you draw a line under the bad hole. It's over. You can wipe the slate clean, take a deep breath, and focus on hitting a great drive on the next hole, where your team is counting on you again.
3. It’s a Smart, Strategic Concession
Choosing to take a bagel shows that you understand the game format and that you're a team player. You’re acknowledging that your partner made a good score and that the team’s success is more important than your individual stats for the day. Trying to hole out for a 7 when your partner made a 4 is a signal that you're more focused on your own score than on winning the match or keeping the game moving. True partners understand when it’s time to lean on each other.
From Defensive to Offensive: Team Strategy to Avoid Bagels
While taking a bagel is often the correct move, the goal is always to have two (or more) players in every hole. Solid team golf is about proactively managing risk so that the dreaded "double bagel" - where both partners in a four-ball blow up on a hole - is a rare event.
Defining Roles: The Aggressor and the Anchor
A classic and effective strategy in any better-ball format involves assigning loose roles.
- The Anchor: This player’s priority is to keep their ball in play. They aim for the middle of the fairway, play to the center of the green, and focus on making a stress-free par. Their job is to ensure the team will, at minimum, have a decent score on the board.
- The Aggressor: Once the anchor's ball is safely in play, this player is freed up. They can take a more aggressive line off the tee, fire directly at a tucked pin, or try to reach a par-5 in two shots. If it pays off, the team likely wins the hole with a birdie. If it backfires, the anchor’s safe play is there as a backup.
These roles can and should change from hole to hole based on who feels confident or who has the honor.
Communication is Everything
The best golf partners talk constantly. They don’t just walk silently to their golf balls. They communicate and strategize before every shot.
- On the Tee: “I’m hitting a 3-wood to make sure I’m in the fairway. That gives you the green light to hit driver.”
- On the Approach: “My drive ended up in the rough. I’m just going to muscle it up towards the front of the green. You’re in a great spot, so feel free to go at the pin.”
- On the Green: “I have this three-footer for par. Why don’t you putt for birdie first? Be aggressive - if you miss, I’ll be here to clean it up.”
Mentally Recovering from a Bagel Hole
Even with great strategy, bagels happen. It's golf. The mark of a great partner isn't being perfect, it’s being resilient. After picking up your ball, the first instinct for many golfers is to apologize profusely. Don't fall into this trap. A simple "Nice par, you’ve got us covered," is all that's needed.
Your job on the next hole is now clear: get your ball in play and give your partner the chance to play aggressively. Reframe the narrative in your head. Your partner had your back on the last hole, and now you have the opportunity to have their back on this one. You’ll be surprised how often a player who gets a bagel on one hole comes back to make a net-birdie on the next to win the hole for the team. That's the beautiful rhythm of team golf.
Final Thoughts
Ultimately, the golf "bagel" is a simple concept with a surprisingly deep impact on strategy, pace of play, and the mental game. Understanding when and why to pick up your ball shows you're a knowledgeable teammate who prioritizes the good of the team over individual pride. As you play more team golf, you'll see it not as a failure, but as a smart and sometimes necessary part of a successful round.
Playing smart team golf often comes down to solid decision-making, and sometimes a second opinion can be the most valuable tool in your bag. We built Caddie AI to act as your on-demand strategist so you never have to guess. Before a tough hole, you can get a clear plan of action, helping you and your partner decide who plays the safe shot and who gets to be aggressive. You can even snap a photo of a tricky lie to get immediate advice on the best way to escape, giving you the best possible chance to contribute to the team and play with the confidence that you're making the smart play.